This is one of the rare times reviews will directly affect my purchase. I want this to be solid, and I've had mixed experiences with the series to this point. If this has a strong story/characters alongside the kind of power progression that makes the world feel engaging, I can see sinking a ton of time into it. I actually find fan impressions almost useless for the genre at this point; my patience for the genre's common shortcomings is dialed in closer to more "mainstream" press than thirsty fans. The trailers so far have, if anything, thrown up some red flags.
I don't care to put time into so-so RPGs that are just 90% fillter for 10% mediocre story writing, "bolstered" by trashy treatment and character designs for all but the entire female cast.