• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Phellps

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,810
OP, you can just remove all the text formatting so it adjusts automatically with the theme. It's unreadable with the light theme right now.
 

OrdinaryPrime

Self-requested ban
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
11,042
The hatred of China here is ridiculous. A tariff war is bad for both Chinese and American consumers. I don't know how the idiots here support this. Everyone says I hate the Chinese government, but you hate the Chinese. This kind of racial discrimination is really ridiculous in era. Your racial equality is only for blacks, not for other people of color.

I didn't see you quote any particular post, mind highlighting it for me? There has certainly been some issues with stuff like the Epic Game Store being used in this fashion but I don't see anything in particular on the page that jumps out to me.
 
Oct 25, 2017
32,298
Atlanta GA
The hatred of China here is ridiculous. A tariff war is bad for both Chinese and American consumers. I don't know how the idiots here support this. Everyone says I hate the Chinese government, but you hate the Chinese. This kind of racial discrimination is really ridiculous in era. Your racial equality is only for blacks, not for other people of color.

Is there anyone here in particular that you are accusing of hating and being racist towards chinese people? Where the hell would you get that from in this thread?

No one here hates Chinese people. It's this tariff war that is ultimately causing harm to regular people in both countries. And both countries are run by maniacal idiots, and not many people here support either of them.
 

eseqko

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,390
I'm guessing a LOT of behind the scenes activity is happening right now in evaluating prices. The announcement of prices of new consoles is probably going to wait for a while.
Nintendo is probably waiting until the last possible second to announce the Switch Mini until they get a clearer picture of what the situation will be like for the next 6 months.
 

Dekuman

Member
Oct 27, 2017
19,026
I'm guessing a LOT of behind the scenes activity is happening right now in evaluating prices. The announcement of prices of new consoles is probably going to wait for a while.
Nintendo is probably waiting until the last possible second to announce the Switch Mini until they get a clearer picture of what the situation will be like for the next 6 months.
Production has gone ahead
 

orochi91

Member
Oct 26, 2017
9,818
Canada
You're also forgetting as "concerned" US citizens we can at least fight against the injustices here or even attempt to garner support for the people who have been wronged. (Not saying it always works, it's just nice that we can disagree with the government, take action and attempt to right wrongs....)
+1

This is a fantastic point.
 

cakely

Member
Oct 27, 2017
13,149
Chicago
Nah, I'm with the US on this.

Fuck the Chinese government.

China's actions in Xianjing and Tibet are horrific, and have caused me to abandon all support for them.

American manufacturers and consumers pay import tariffs, not China.

You might not know if this if everything you learned about Dumbass Donald's unnecessary trade war came from Dumbass Donald himself.
 

Orbit

Banned
Nov 21, 2018
1,328
When Trump screws everything with his sanctions and he's not even aware.

i agree Trump is a huge dick and basically inhuman, but this is more an example of greedy companies being upset that they lost their slave labor/child labor. i don't mean to use 'slave' in such a shitty and non-chalant way, but after reading about foxconn work conditions, it is pretty disturbing (i mean look at the suicide rates!). but yeah, i have no empathy for Sony Nintendo Microsoft. yeah the tariffs are bad but seriously the companies deserve these expenses for how they keep supporting this child labor and terrible work conditions. i am glad they are losing their 'golden goose'.

edit: also apple you eat shit too i hope.
 

QBizM

Member
Oct 25, 2017
530
So all the nations joined forces to fight the aliens. Makes sense.
Sounds like an EDF reboot featuring Trump as the incoming threat...

To save Economies from yet another Trump attack
From shitty thoughtless sanctions that have once again come back
We'll combine all our forces, we won't cut them any slack
The TDF deploys!
 

Cordy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,351
Sounds like an EDF reboot featuring Trump as the incoming threat...

To save Economies from yet another Trump attack
From shitty thoughtless sanctions that have once again come back
We'll combine all our forces, we won't cut them any slack
The TDF deploys!
The Gamengers.
 

Antrax

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,286
Broad tariffs are shit policy in all scenarios. Protectionist nonsense.

Free trade is the way to go. Anything else is garbage.
 

Dekuman

Member
Oct 27, 2017
19,026
American manufacturers and consumers pay import tariffs, not China.

You might not know if this if everything you learned about Dumbass Donald's unnecessary trade war came from Dumbass Donald himself.
Tariffs are the.stick. the intended effect is for these companies to move manufacturing out of China permanently
 

Nanashrew

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,328
People bringing up working conditions in China don't seem to realize the similar/same working conditions in other countries that companies are moving to.
 

RPGamer

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,435
I live in europe but i would gladly pay some extra euros if the Switch "Pro" would be made in Japan or other asian countries. I have nothing against chinese people, in fact i'm a fan of the chinese culture (the old culture) but i can't unsee all the problems. While i don't think Trumps tarrifs are made because of the right reasons i think europe is sleeping entirely on Chinas behaviour.

Broad tariffs are shit policy in all scenarios. Protectionist nonsense.

Free trade is the way to go. Anything else is garbage.


Could you please tell that china too. They are very good in protecting their economy from foreign companies while flooding the world with cheap chinese products, often copies of western products. Its absurd how cheap they can ship goods around the world.
 

Deleted member 36622

User requested account closure
Banned
Dec 21, 2017
6,639
i agree Trump is a huge dick and basically inhuman, but this is more an example of greedy companies being upset that they lost their slave labor/child labor. i don't mean to use 'slave' in such a shitty and non-chalant way, but after reading about foxconn work conditions, it is pretty disturbing (i mean look at the suicide rates!). but yeah, i have no empathy for Sony Nintendo Microsoft. yeah the tariffs are bad but seriously the companies deserve these expenses for how they keep supporting this child labor and terrible work conditions. i am glad they are losing their 'golden goose'.

edit: also apple you eat shit too i hope.

Well Trump isn't really fixing that issue, he's only blocking China's expansion in hope to snatch a better deal while blocking their big companies, but manufacturing products in China had already become more expensive than what it used to be, so companies are already moving their productions to the "new China" which are now Vietnam and India.

Essentially you're only changing the nationality of your slaves.

Also while i agree that this is bad, we need to realize that the majority of the products you see today are made in those countries with those working conditions, with that much influence from the government on local companies, etc. It's time to change this, but we need some effort and time to adapt.
 

JahIthBer

Member
Jan 27, 2018
10,382
2 things can be true at once, Trump is an idiot & Nintendo, Sony & Microsoft want to make more money.
The big three could just move to Taiwan like others have & make a tiny bit less profit, or suck it up & eat the tariff, Microsoft's market cap is a trillion dollars for fuck sake.
Besides, Sony & Microsoft are likely not going to make a $599 Console ever again due to PS3's blunder, so they will likely eat the tariff & it won't hurt the consumer, not to say other tariffs won't raise prices on other goods, but probably not Consoles.
 

Nanashrew

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,328
2 things can be true at once, Trump is an idiot & Nintendo, Sony & Microsoft want to make more money.
The big three could just move to Taiwan like others have & make a tiny bit less profit, or suck it up & eat the tariff, Microsoft's market cap is a trillion dollars for fuck sake.
They already have been.
 

cakely

Member
Oct 27, 2017
13,149
Chicago
Tariffs will not impact manufacturers in a material way. They will largely impact consumers who will pay additional costs. The point of the tariffs is not to curb labor practices (or, as the letter says, to encourage better IP law enforcement, also a distraction). They specifically stem from Trump's inability to understand comparative advantage.

Suppose that China becomes impossible to manufacture in thanks to a magic policy. Any manufacturing shifted out of China will go to other south-East Asian countries with cheaper costs of labor and fewer regulations. This is already happening even in the absence of anti-Chinese tariffs. Even manufacturing in China often involves component outsourcing to, for instance, North Korea (where I assure you labor practices are far worse and external pressure to stop abuses far less).

There are many organizations and many people who dedicate their lives to improving labor conditions in China, and none of them think pulling the rug out in a spectacular fashion will solve anything. The main driver of increased wages, safer work conditions, and crackdowns on underage labor in China has been China's prosperity and pressure from external organizations to make incremental reforms. Even at periods where widespread abuse, manufacturing electronics was often safer and better compensated than alternatives (garment work, electronics recycling, begging) in the same areas: this is, after all, why people take these sweatshop jobs to begin with. Consider that if electronics manufacturing is not available in these areas, the people will not be liberated. They will be reduced to working more dangerous jobs for less wages. Many of the higher risk, lower wage jobs primarily serve China's internal trade needs and so cannot be effectively disrupted with tariffs or international pressure. A world where China is poor and isolated hurts average Chinese citizens more than it helps them.

Let's evaluate how things have changed in, for instance, the smartphone era. Ten years ago, many companies had no provisions to examine or control underage labor, overtime abuse, or injuries on the job. Today, most manufacturers in China have educational opportunities for workers, do not allow employees under age 14, cap hours worked to 60, etc. Wages have doubled in many of the electronics manufacturers during this period. Does this reach a standard we would consider fair, free, and empowering for workers? No, absolutely not. We don't want 15 year olds working. We don't want people working 50 hours a week. But significant progress has been made. Instances of 11 year olds working have dropped enormously in the last decade. As has the workers working 100 hours a week.. Today most of the issues in the labor supply chain deal with subcontracting agreements and enforcing the standards of primary manufacturers throughout the manufacturing chain. So, in other words, Foxconn is no longer the main problem, and now we're focusing on making sure all the companies Foxconn subcontracts with aren't either. These improvements have stemmed both from Chinese economic growth and the maturing Chinese middle class, and also due to NGOs and western companies forcing Foxconn and other manufacturers to meet higher standards.

While the Foxconn suicides are extremely disturbing, there is limited or no evidence that suicide rates in electronics manufacturing are higher than in any other industry. Foxconn has almost a million employees. During the period that the Foxconn suicides were widely reported, they had 15 suicides in a year. No one would look at, for instance, Austin Texas and conclude that 15 adult aged suicides in a year means something has gone gravely wrong with Foxconn. Moreover, and this should not be surprising given what I've just told you, the suicide rate at Foxconn was substantially lower than similar aged individuals elsewhere in China (largely because despite all of the very real problems at Foxconn at the time, other alternatives were worse). The frame shouldn't be "There were suicides at Foxconn. Fuck all this." It should be "What can we do to improve the life of people working in these conditions?"

I think if you feel this passionately about labor conditions in China, you should look into organizations that aim to help average people in China and see what they say and where they see things going in the next 10-20 years. I should say that none of this speaks to other and unrelated social issues in China, like for instance the Uyghur concentration camps, ongoing state censorship, the One China meddling in Hong Kong, etc. There are many reasons why you might personally choose to boycott buying goods from foreign areas: not because you believe your boycott is helping Chinese workers, but because you do not want any moral complicity in those other things. That's fine, I can't blame anyone who doesn't want to think about hard problems. But don't pretend such an attitude makes the lives of Chinese workers better.

Well put.

People in this thread want to punish China, and think that import tariffs on Chinese goods are a good way to do that.

They aren't. Import tariffs are a punishment to the American manufacturers who buy these goods and ultimately, American consumers.
 

jeelybeans

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,948
Don't we already know that Nintendo is manufacturing their new Switch's outside of China? That would indicate moving supply chains won't increase prices. It's only increasing costs probably for Nintendo.
 
Dec 11, 2017
4,836
I fear the tariffs will happen, and Sony and Microsoft will at the last minute lower their specs in an effort to cut costs rather than raise prices anywhere close to 25%.
 

The Watcher

Member
Oct 29, 2017
1,349
095517401aff1e69a16bb3192a3a7954da704749a15e4c565f7c77cd4add41b83c63c6d0.jpg


Sorry but I can't be helped.
Where is this from?
 

Deleted member 49804

User requested account closure
Banned
Nov 21, 2018
1,868
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin told CNBC on Wednesday the U.S. and China were close to a trade deal, and he's optimistic that progress can be made during weekend talks between President Donald Trump and China's Xi Jinping.

"We were about 90% of the way there [with a deal] and I think there's a path to complete this," he told CNBC's Hadley Gamble in Manama, Bahrain.


He said he's confident Trump and the Chinese president can make progress in stalled trade talks at the Group of 20 meeting. "The message we want to hear is that they want to come back to the table and continue because I think there is a good outcome for their economy and the U.S. economy to get balanced trade and to continue to build on this relationship."

He did not provide any detail on what the final 10% of an agreement might entail, or what the sticking points are to completing a deal.

That's also the reason for the stock market surge by the way
 

TheRulingRing

Banned
Apr 6, 2018
5,713
The hatred of China here is ridiculous. A tariff war is bad for both Chinese and American consumers. I don't know how the idiots here support this. Everyone says I hate the Chinese government, but you hate the Chinese. This kind of racial discrimination is really ridiculous in era. Your racial equality is only for blacks, not for other people of color.

Nah screw China, if anything there's not enough hatred of China in this thread.

And don't make this about racial discrimination - this is about the Chinese government, the government that's putting millions of muslims into death camps for the crime of appearing to be so, the government that's tightened its grip on power to infallibility, the government that stamps down on criticism harder than a guillotine.
 

Xpike

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,676
The hatred of China here is ridiculous. A tariff war is bad for both Chinese and American consumers. I don't know how the idiots here support this. Everyone says I hate the Chinese government, but you hate the Chinese. This kind of racial discrimination is really ridiculous in era. Your racial equality is only for blacks, not for other people of color.
hi chinese government
almost as bad as "hating israel means you hate Jewish people"
 

SinkFla

Member
Oct 26, 2017
9,446
Pensacola, Fl
People can be upset with the Chinese government all they want (And the American government for that matter too), but let's not pretend like these trade tariffs are being put in place because the US is taking the moral high ground with China.

This is about exerting dominance on the international scene between two super powers, and it's the average person who is going to bear the brunt of the damage.

When elephants fight, mice get trampled.
 

Orbit

Banned
Nov 21, 2018
1,328
Well Trump isn't really fixing that issue, he's only blocking China's expansion in hope to snatch a better deal while blocking their big companies, but manufacturing products in China had already become more expensive than what it used to be, so companies are already moving their productions to the "new China" which are now Vietnam and India.

Essentially you're only changing the nationality of your slaves.

Also while i agree that this is bad, we need to realize that the majority of the products you see today are made in those countries with those working conditions, with that much influence from the government on local companies, etc. It's time to change this, but we need some effort and time to adapt.

completely agree. it just makes me sick when all three of these gaming giants come together in unison when their low-cost labor may not be there so conveniently anymore in china.
 

Gatti-man

Banned
Jan 31, 2018
2,359
The hatred of China here is ridiculous. A tariff war is bad for both Chinese and American consumers. I don't know how the idiots here support this. Everyone says I hate the Chinese government, but you hate the Chinese. This kind of racial discrimination is really ridiculous in era. Your racial equality is only for blacks, not for other people of color.
Please post examples of racial discrimination in this thread or gtfo. No one in era hates the Chinese that's ridiculous.
 

slavesnyder

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,127
SlaveSnyder Media Corp.
i agree Trump is a huge dick and basically inhuman, but this is more an example of greedy companies being upset that they lost their slave labor/child labor. i don't mean to use 'slave' in such a shitty and non-chalant way, but after reading about foxconn work conditions, it is pretty disturbing (i mean look at the suicide rates!). but yeah, i have no empathy for Sony Nintendo Microsoft. yeah the tariffs are bad but seriously the companies deserve these expenses for how they keep supporting this child labor and terrible work conditions. i am glad they are losing their 'golden goose'.

edit: also apple you eat shit too i hope.
if products risk to become more expensive due to taxes, you just have to lower costs somewhere else. i am sure neither the corporations nor china would like to lose their good and established working relationships, so the best solution would be some optimisations on the cost of labour, as we, the customer rightfully insist on keeping low price and high quality.
a little tweaking and optimisation here and there on working conditions/hours, salary and entrance barriers to the career as industrual manufacturer (like age) and china should be able to compete with other countries who are ready to serve and please us.
 
Last edited:

unrealist

Member
Oct 27, 2017
757
Appears to be lots of hate for China / Xi Jinping. What westerners know about China is mainly from the media themselves, which try really hard to paint a bad picture of China whenever they can. It might be true is not doing a lot of things right but the media just makes it far worse than it actually is.
 

slavesnyder

Member
Oct 26, 2017
1,127
SlaveSnyder Media Corp.
Appears to be lots of hate for China / Xi Jinping. What westerners know about China is mainly from the media themselves, which try really hard to paint a bad picture of China whenever they can. It might be true is not doing a lot of things right but the media just makes it far worse than it actually is.
western media, please. chinese media has a far more balanced and unbiased viewpoint on these issues.
 

Andri

Member
Mar 20, 2018
6,017
Switzerland
Tariffs are the.stick. the intended effect is for these companies to move manufacturing out of China permanently

But if you actually read the letter you would know that they themselves said moving production out of china would cost more than just taking the tarrifs.

The costs are not paid by china anyway, so its a choice between consumers paying more due to the tarrif, or consumers paying even more for them to move production.
Since staying in china is still the cheaper option for both the manufacturers and consumers, its not hard to guess what will happen.

The "intended effect" just wont happen.
 

Sandersson

Banned
Feb 5, 2018
2,535
Tariffs will not impact manufacturers in a material way. They will largely impact consumers who will pay additional costs. The point of the tariffs is not to curb labor practices (or, as the letter says, to encourage better IP law enforcement, also a distraction). They specifically stem from Trump's inability to understand comparative advantage.

Suppose that China becomes impossible to manufacture in thanks to a magic policy. Any manufacturing shifted out of China will go to other south-East Asian countries with cheaper costs of labor and fewer regulations. This is already happening even in the absence of anti-Chinese tariffs. Even manufacturing in China often involves component outsourcing to, for instance, North Korea (where I assure you labor practices are far worse and external pressure to stop abuses far less).

There are many organizations and many people who dedicate their lives to improving labor conditions in China, and none of them think pulling the rug out in a spectacular fashion will solve anything. The main driver of increased wages, safer work conditions, and crackdowns on underage labor in China has been China's prosperity and pressure from external organizations to make incremental reforms. Even at periods where widespread abuse, manufacturing electronics was often safer and better compensated than alternatives (garment work, electronics recycling, begging) in the same areas: this is, after all, why people take these sweatshop jobs to begin with. Consider that if electronics manufacturing is not available in these areas, the people will not be liberated. They will be reduced to working more dangerous jobs for less wages. Many of the higher risk, lower wage jobs primarily serve China's internal trade needs and so cannot be effectively disrupted with tariffs or international pressure. A world where China is poor and isolated hurts average Chinese citizens more than it helps them.

Let's evaluate how things have changed in, for instance, the smartphone era. Ten years ago, many companies had no provisions to examine or control underage labor, overtime abuse, or injuries on the job. Today, most manufacturers in China have educational opportunities for workers, do not allow employees under age 14, cap hours worked to 60, etc. Wages have doubled in many of the electronics manufacturers during this period. Does this reach a standard we would consider fair, free, and empowering for workers? No, absolutely not. We don't want 15 year olds working. We don't want people working 50 hours a week. But significant progress has been made. Instances of 11 year olds working have dropped enormously in the last decade. As has the workers working 100 hours a week.. Today most of the issues in the labor supply chain deal with subcontracting agreements and enforcing the standards of primary manufacturers throughout the manufacturing chain. So, in other words, Foxconn is no longer the main problem, and now we're focusing on making sure all the companies Foxconn subcontracts with aren't either. These improvements have stemmed both from Chinese economic growth and the maturing Chinese middle class, and also due to NGOs and western companies forcing Foxconn and other manufacturers to meet higher standards.

While the Foxconn suicides are extremely disturbing, there is limited or no evidence that suicide rates in electronics manufacturing are higher than in any other industry. Foxconn has almost a million employees. During the period that the Foxconn suicides were widely reported, they had 15 suicides in a year. No one would look at, for instance, Austin Texas and conclude that 15 adult aged suicides in a year means something has gone gravely wrong with Austin (or Foxconn). Moreover, and this should not be surprising given what I've just told you, the suicide rate at Foxconn was substantially lower than similar aged individuals elsewhere in China (largely because despite all of the very real problems at Foxconn at the time, other alternatives were worse). The frame shouldn't be "There were suicides at Foxconn. Fuck all this." It should be "What can we do to improve the life of people working in these conditions?"

I think if you feel this passionately about labor conditions in China, you should look into organizations that aim to help average people in China and see what they say and where they see things going in the next 10-20 years. I should say that none of this speaks to other and unrelated social issues in China, like for instance the Uyghur concentration camps, ongoing state censorship, the One China meddling in Hong Kong, etc. There are many reasons why you might personally choose to boycott buying goods from foreign areas: not because you believe your boycott is helping Chinese workers, but because you do not want any moral complicity in those other things. That's fine, I can't blame anyone who doesn't want to think about hard problems. But don't pretend such an attitude makes the lives of Chinese workers better.
If you can find some sources to backup your comments, it would be greatly appriciated. Its extremely annoying to read this long and otherwise well thought comment without being able to verify a single thing on it. It would also give your points much more credence. Cheers!

Aaaaw crap, triple post..
 
Last edited:

Andri

Member
Mar 20, 2018
6,017
Switzerland
You guys really gotta start putting some sources on your comments. Its extremely annoying to read this long and otherwise well thought comment without being able to verify a single thing on it. It would also give your points much more credence. Cheers!

Aaaaw crap, triple post..

What are you actually asking for ?
It kinda reads like you dont want to believe things that are self evident, so you try to discredit people by saying "well, you didnt post sources, so you are lieing".

The source is like, common sense for most of what they said, and the whole thing about labor practices in china and how they have changed and due to who is just one google search away.

As for the first paragraph:

The tarrif is not paid by the target country of the tarrif.

Therefore, tarrifs are paid by the manufacturers.

The company then has to make a analysis on if moving production to a non tariff country is cheaper than just paying the tarrif.

And since the manufacturers basically decide how much they can ask for their devices, and this tarriff affects all manufacturers they have literally no reason to not pass on the costs of the tarrifs to either consumers or get the money by cuttinng costs elsewhere, like with wages of workers, especially since there is basically to less than no margin in the business of selling console hardware.