• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
I seriously am concerned for the people who keep making this argument in here.
It's like talking to a wall. You're not going to kick her out for a progressive agenda, she will push the most progressive agenda she can push while also getting votes from the centrists and moderates of the democrats. You need 218 votes to pass the House, there's a reason AOC isn't gonna be angling for speaker.
 

Atlagev

Member
Oct 27, 2017
686
We haven't lived in Pelosis West Wing fan fiction universe in a long, long time. In fact we never did. There is no compromise or working with repubs anymore. Obama tried that for eight years.

Who says anything about working with Republicans? You have to be able to control your caucus! One of the main reasons Boehner and Ryan were so bad as speakers is because they had no control over the Tea Party/Freedom Caucus. Nancy Pelosi got Blue Dog Dems to help pass a version of the ACA with a public option. That's someone who's good at her job.
 

Deleted member 25445

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 29, 2017
648
Pelosi filibustered in the House for 8 hours for DREAMers

She stood up and made an 8 hour speech
Great, too bad they weren't adamant about actual policy and budget proposals to help us. This forum is a great representation of what's wrong with the Democratic party in how it tries to represent minorities. "But we do enough for you, look what we do, now stay down and shut up". It's a good thing growing up in Westchester NY has shown me first hand how vapid almost all the responses are to the needs we have as minorities by wealthy white liberals. AOC is among the first, but there's real change coming.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
I mean, I'm suprised that some people here seem to think so highly of Nancy fucking Pelosi, she wasn't great the first time, has low public favorability, and she'll just energize the GOP base. She is still the better option though, so it is what it is.
She has low public favor-ability because of the GOP smearing, and she won't energize the base more than anyone else. She was going to be the speaker in 2018 and 317 districts swung left and we gained almost 40 seats lmfao
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
Great, too bad they weren't adamant about actual policy and budget proposals to help us. This forum is a great representation of what's wrong with the Democratic party in how it tries to represent minorities. "But we do enough for you, look what we do, now stay down and shut up". It's a good thing growing up in Westchester NY servin first hand how vapid almost all the responses are too the needs we have as minorities. AOC is among the first, but there's real change coming.
AOC won in one of the most diverse districts in an already liberal city. Good luck getting 217 other self described actual socialists to the house and agreeing with a president and senate.

And no, Bernie is not a socialist.
 

Kirblar

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
30,744
Great, too bad they weren't adamant about actual policy and budget proposals to help us. This forum is a great representation of what's wrong with the Democratic party in how it tries to represent minorities. "But we do enough for you, look what we do, now stay down and shut up". It's a good thing growing up in Westchester NY servin first hand how vapid almost all the responses are too the needs we have as minorities. AOC is among the first, but there's real change coming.
They lost the House in 2010. They lost the White House in 2016.

How exactly are they supposed to help you outside of the judiciary when they lose control of all levers of government?
 

ryan13ts

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,102
Well, that didn't take long, for them to turn on themselves and start the in-fighting. I was expecting at least a week of feigned peace before the sharks started to circle for the position of Speaker.

Seriously though, this really isn't the time for this. They really need to be focusing on getting their shit together so they can deal with the real problem, Trump and his administration.
 

jviggy43

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
18,184
That's not an argument. It's reality. Tim Ryan's group is the most conservative part of the Dem caucus. It's why Lamb and Spanberger are included.
The underlying assertion that if you agree with a conservative cabal of dems trying to push out the speaker, for entirely different reasons, than those of your own, you somehow must support a more conservative agenda is what I am calling out here.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
Well, that didn't take long, for them to turn on themselves and start the in-fighting. I was expecting at least a week of feigned peace before the sharks started to circle for the position of Speaker.

Seriously though, this really isn't the time for this. They really need to be focusing on getting their shit together so they can deal with the real problem, Trump and his administration.
Dems in red districts were running ads against her since the spring, and she let them because she's not stupid and realizes that's how they're gonna get elected.
 

excelsiorlef

Bad Praxis
Member
Oct 25, 2017
73,325
Well, that didn't take long, for them to turn on themselves and start the in-fighting. I was expecting at least a week of feigned peace before the sharks started to circle for the position of Speaker.

Seriously though, this really isn't the time for this. They really need to be focusing on getting their shit together so they can deal with the real problem, Trump and his administration.

This is the same Tim Ryan gang that does this everytime, take no heed to it.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
The underlying assertion that if you agree with a conservative cabal of dems trying to push out the speaker, for entirely different reasons, than those of your own, you somehow must support a more conservative agenda is what I am calling out here.

Right, you're just arguing for something that's a complete fairytale and is pointless arguing because it has no basis in reality and won't happen for multiple reasons.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
No. You're right, they did enough. All the information you've gathered so far is all the information you need.
Swell comeback, it's pretty hard to do much when you don't have a single branch of government and yet she did more than most democrats would ever do.
 

Kirblar

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
30,744
The underlying assertion that if you agree with a conservative cabal of dems trying to push out the speaker, for entirely different reasons, than those of your own, you somehow must support a more conservative agenda is what I am calling out here.
The conservative faction will propose a candidate more conservative than Pelosi. If you support the more conservative candidate over Pelosi in that election, it is a direct reflection on your individual priorities, yes.

You could basically make a meme of the guy sweating with "stick it to the establishment" and "push party leftward" as the two buttons.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
We haven't lived in Pelosis West Wing fan fiction universe in a long, long time. In fact we never did. There is no compromise or working with repubs anymore. Obama tried that for eight years.
Were you asleep during the first two years where Pelosi singlehandedly saved the ACA and Obama called her the best speaker the dems have ever had?
 
Oct 27, 2017
10,660
100% don't care who the speaker is as long as they're good at their job. We need lock-in-step unity. Whomever can get that, is boss. We need that Democratic cult to combat the other side.
 

Barzul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,965
Great, too bad they weren't adamant about actual policy and budget proposals to help us. This forum is a great representation of what's wrong with the Democratic party in how it tries to represent minorities. "But we do enough for you, look what we do, now stay down and shut up". It's a good thing growing up in Westchester NY has shown me first hand how vapid almost all the responses are to the needs we have as minorities by wealthy white liberals. AOC is among the first, but there's real change coming.
You are incredibly out of touch with the American electorate if you think AOC could win anywhere else other than NY. She's not the first of anything. How did Democrats get this house majority? In part by appealing to suburban white women along with the coalition of minorities that make up the Democratic Party stronghold. Until someone can show me someone as liberal as AOC winning in Virginia, Georgia, Florida, Arizona, Nevada, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan, Pelosi stays leader. She'll stop Democrats from doing shit like trying to impeach Trump that will ruin any chance of a slam dunk in 2020. And I am a minority and Pelosi is the by far the best option to lead the house going into 2020.
 

Darkstar0155

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,162
Only reason you don't want her imo is because:
A: You bought into the smears
B: You want a fresh face
C: You don't want her as a motivator for the right
C: You have no clue what your talking about
 
OP
OP
Stellar

Stellar

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
758
You are incredibly out of touch with the American electorate if you think AOC could win anywhere else other than NY. She's not the first of anything. How did Democrats get this house majority? In part by appealing to suburban white women along with the coalition of minorities that make up the Democratic Party stronghold. Until someone can show me someone as liberal as AOC winning in Virginia, Georgia, Florida, Arizona, Nevada, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan, Pelosi stays leader. She'll stop Democrats from doing shit like trying to impeach Trump that will ruin any chance of a slam dunk in 2020. And I am a minority and Pelosi is the by far the best option to lead the house going into 2020.

Wow sounds like you've got the election all analysed and figured out just a few days after it concluded. Usually it takes years and lots of research to see what trends had actual meaningful impact during elections but you do you king!!
 

Titik

Member
Oct 25, 2017
7,490
I hope Pelosi is taking names. It's time to hit the hammer on these jokers who would rather derail our majority than unite ans turn on our real enemy.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
Wow sounds like you've got the election all analysed and figured out just a few days after it concluded. Usually it takes years and lots of research to see what trends had actual meaningful impact during elections but you do you king!!
Lmao

Actually there were DSA candidates for various positions and most of them in red states lost if not all of them.

She'll get it in the final vote, the person earlier who called it political theatre for Blue Dogs was on the money.
Baffling that the left and right fall for blatant political posturing from either side still in the year of our lord 2018.
 
OP
OP
Stellar

Stellar

Banned
Oct 26, 2017
758
Lmao

Actually there were DSA candidates for various positions and most of them in red states lost if not all of them.

The DSA is an incredibly tiny org that only just sprang into life again literally less than a handful of years ago. Bottom up grassroots efforts take time to build. DSA have made headway into lots of other districts though.
 

Deleted member 31817

Nov 7, 2017
30,876
Yea it's an ideological position.
I mean my idealogy is more to the left than most dems too but from a practical standpoint with that idealogy calling for Pelosi to be removed is strange bc she has pushed for progressive agenda while getting moderates on board.
 

Antrax

Member
Oct 25, 2017
13,281
I'm sure a white guy from Ohio who never whipped votes for anything meaningful in his life is an improvement over a woman from SF who already has a 100 Hours plan ready to go just like the last time she held the position.

Totally
 

Barzul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,965
Wow sounds like you've got the election all analysed and figured out just a few days after it concluded. Usually it takes years and lots of research to see what trends had actual meaningful impact during elections but you do you king!!
All but one of the DSA and JD candidates put up lost in Congressional races but go on. If you actually want to see Trump 2020, make someone like AOC a party leader. I guess America showing how sexist and racist it is once wasn't enough. I actually want to win though and that means pragmatism.

Trump is basically "GOP Obama", I'll simply never underestimate him again and the electorate has shown us exactly where it is, it's slightly to the left of Obama and nothing more. Pelosi will win the speakership easily, I'd get used to the idea.
 

Kasumin

Member
Nov 19, 2017
1,931
I truly think shitty cable news has warped people's understanding of politics and the political process.

Pelosi is accountable to exactly two groups: her constituents in San Francisco and her caucus. Her job is to build consensus, find the most progressive legislation that can muster 218 votes, whip the votes, and pass it.

That's it. It's not her job to make you like her. It's not her job to make Republicans stop hating her. It's not her job to be the face of the party. She's responsible for the House and the House alone.

Stop being complicit in allowing stupid, superficial people to make a legislator into a boogeywoman.

Quoting this again because it's one of the most sensible posts in this thread. I'll still be ignored by the people raving against Pelosi, though.

And the underlying reasons for why I want her gone are distinct from theirs. Like its seriously mind blowing some of you are making thw jump from "I just agree she should be gone-despite a difference in opinion on why that is" to mean " I agree with a conservative Democrat outlook to change the entire party". The fact you cant wrap your head around the idea that we could support the call for it for entirely different reasons seriously concerns me.

Man, you are very unpleasant in this thread. People keep telling you what the reality of the situation is, and then you rail against them like they're offending you by... telling you what the reality of the situation is. You just sound really angry for no good reason. You don't like Pelosi, but the challenge is coming from her right. You claim to want her replaced with someone from the left, but that's not what's happening here. Yet you continue to get angry and act like an ass for no good reason. Putting you on ignore so this thread is less filled with crap. Go take a nap or eat a Snickers bar so you're less cranky, man.
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,645
Were you asleep during the first two years where Pelosi singlehandedly saved the ACA and Obama called her the best speaker the dems have ever had?
Were you asleep when her and Schumer were so certain they managed to save DACA only to get fucked by republicans anyway?

Who says anything about working with Republicans? You have to be able to control your caucus! One of the main reasons Boehner and Ryan were so bad as speakers is because they had no control over the Tea Party/Freedom Caucus. Nancy Pelosi got Blue Dog Dems to help pass a version of the ACA with a public option. That's someone who's good at her job.
Literally Pelosi did. Like I liked a tweet quoting her as doing so.
 

Maolfunction

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,871
I'm about as far left as a person can get but I recognize that the House in its current state would never listen to a far left candidate when it came time to whip up the votes for bills. Pelosi has years of experience and her voting record is pretty much flawless. Sure, her personal politics and stances don't line up with my ideals, but you can't play politics in the real world with just ideals.

SotH needs to be someone with a crazy amount of experience and an ability to network with every other Democrat who leans right of them and think the bills being pushed are too far left. Pelosi has this in spades, she's fucking terrifying in terms of her effectiveness to get people to vote.

If you're far left, we need to work on transforming the people who make up Congress until the far left are the majority of people in there, not a super small minority like it is now.