-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Red Dead Redemption 2 Review Thread
- Thread starter spad3
- Start date
I want a 90 just so haters wouldn't say it's ''overrated'' (happened way too many times on games like BOTW and God of War) and would actually fucking play and appreciate it.
While the game itself being regarded as GOTG across the internet for decades.
While the game itself being regarded as GOTG across the internet for decades.
The time we live in where below 70 of 100 is "not recommended". I miss old, actually helpful review scores.
Is ACG likely to have a review up around the same time? I've only recently been made aware of him, so I don't know if he's likely to have been sent a review copy, but I really like his stuff.
With the previews comparing the gunplay favorably to Max Payne 3, I wouldn't count on it.
Did they finally do it? That was one of my major complaints about GTAV.
The consensus from the previews seems to suggest the gunplay is more akin to MP3 blended with the first RDR.
Would like to see some reasoning behind some of these score predictions people are posting.
I for one think the game has the potential to be in the 96-98 range. Looking at past scores for Rockstar titles and so many glowing previews, on top of the leaked footage I've seen so far, I feel like it's positioning itself to match or exceed GTA V's average score.
I for one think the game has the potential to be in the 96-98 range. Looking at past scores for Rockstar titles and so many glowing previews, on top of the leaked footage I've seen so far, I feel like it's positioning itself to match or exceed GTA V's average score.
Regardless of scores, I suspect there's going to be a pretty quick cycle of backlash against this game.
I love BOTW but if this game is what the previews have suggested, it's going to effectively bury it and every other open world game easily, including Rockstar's previous efforts.
That said, I think BOTW's score was well-earned.
Best open world game this gen.
Certainly will outdo GTA4 in critical reception and sales.
98 meta.
Certainly will outdo GTA4 in critical reception and sales.
98 meta.
I'm going with a 96 meta overall. Rockstar games are usually insanely polished and have a lot of hype behind them. I'm guessing the bulk of reviews will fall between 94-98.
There's a backlash to every well-reviewed game out there and the more effusive and copious the praise, the worse the backlash tends to be.
Just think about how many "I don't get the praise for [insert critically lauded game here] threads we get in here every month.
Been thinking 95 for weeks now but I'll push it and say 97 overall.
Highest rated multiplat this gen.
Highest rated multiplat this gen.
89
Story won't be as good as RDR
Praise the world and ecosystems
Hate the camps moving and forcing the player to play in specic areas
Some will call it boring and purely a cowboy simulator
Story won't be as good as RDR
Praise the world and ecosystems
Hate the camps moving and forcing the player to play in specic areas
Some will call it boring and purely a cowboy simulator
