no need for a slogan, this is a forum not a fast food joint.
there is a need to adjust the site color and font size though. text font and/or size size is too small, especially on mobile and text on pure white is hard on the eyes. that's one thing the old forum got right. its much more readable than era.
I think either of those slogans hinted at the fact this is a fresh start, which still has connections to the old place. It doesn't have to be buried and forgotten, but I believe this place is great enough to not have to have a slogan that reminds that it was born from another website. It's history we take with us but it doesn't have to be reminded constantly. No slogan is a good choice at this point, though if we go for a slogan I'd go for something else entirely.
The only reason I voted no slogan was because the two options were both about continuing something old, rather than about being something self-contained and standalone new. Something about the new/now [of gaming] and looking forward is what I think the ethos of a slogan should be.
New Game+/Continue? Are punny, but also just remind people of how the site originally came about. I suppose the name already does that, but we don't need to double down on it imo.