You want nuance? Okay get ready for paragraph mode.
TLJ is horrific, terrible, bad movie for mant reasons.
A) With the exception of Rey, all the other main characters and top supporting characters do super dumb shit, nonsensical desicision making that even a functional regular average person wouldn't do. And lots of dumb actions taken by characters seemed forced just to shoe horn the plot direction regardless of common sense.
B) Because important characters are making awful decisions with a layer of dumb, it also makes all the intertwining connections feel off. For like 99% of the characters.
C) so when a character acts not just impulse but sheer stupidity it ends making the situation around the character inevitably stupid.
You can't watch this installement (TLJ) in the series and have ??? pop everywhere because neatly all characters are continuously doing dumb shit.
List of dumb shit:
Poe: reckless run, no disregard of life of teammates. Constantly talks like pre-teem
Holdo: creating an atmosphere of questioning, bad judgement and distrust by not explaining her ill conceived plan that "artificially" creates a convenient narrative for a Poe vs Holdo situation that did even need to exist if she was a competant leader ( which she is not)
Huxx: downgrade from previous movie. His punching bag status reduces his threat notoriety making the audience not take him seriously.
I'm tired of typing but you see where this goes, aside from Rey, everyone else on the movie is a complete idiot
