The Arena
- Rum 'n' Bass In The Arena, form a crew of four and play your instruments during a contest. 10
- Pints Mean Prizes In The Arena, deliver a chest during a contest - while drunk! 10
- Glorious Sea Dog Purchase the Glorious Sea Dog Jacket, Hat, Hook and Gloves. 10
- Nice Pirates Finish Last In The Arena, deliver a stolen chest during a contest. 20
- Hot Tub Crime Machine In The Arena's tavern, get at least one member of each crew into the hot tub at the same time. 25
- Capture the Swag In The Arena, deliver a chest within the first five minutes of a contest. 30
- Fortune and Glory In The Arena, have 15 chests in your crew's possession at the same time during a contest. 30
- Show Your Colours In The Arena, take part in a contest using every single colour of ship. 30
- Captain of Silvered Waters Receive the Commendation for placing in the top three 100 times in The Arena. 30
- Champion of Silvered Waters Receive the Commendation for placing first 100 times in The Arena. 50
- Legend of Silvered Waters Receive the Commendation for placing first 100 times in The Arena as a Pirate Legend. 50
- Sailor of Silvered Waters Receive the Commendation for completing 200 contests in The Arena. 35
- Master of The Arena Purchase the Arena Master Promotion from the Sea Dogs Trading Company. 35
- Dining With the Stars Cook a piece of food on a campfire at night. 5
- Well Done! Burn a piece of food. 5
- Not So Well Done Become sick from undercooked food. 5
- Five a Day Eat at least one piece of every kind of fruit. 5
- Another Pirate's Treasure Deliver a piece of treacherous loot to The Hunter's Call. 5
- Night Bite Deliver a luminescent fish to The Hunter's Call. 10
- A Rare Delicacy Deliver a rare coloured fish to The Hunter's Call. 10
- Meat and Greet Deliver every kind of cooked meat to The Hunter's Call. 10
- Hunter of Trophy Fish Receive the Commendation for delivering 25 Trophy Fish to The Hunter's Call. 20
- Hook, Line and Sinker Deliver at least one of every kind of fish to The Hunter's Call. 30
- Legendary Hunter of the Sea of Thieves Receive the Commendation for completing 57 Grade 5 Hunter's Call Commendations. 50
- Master of the Hunters Purchase the Master Hunter Promotion from The Hunter's Call Trading Company. 20
- The Shroudbreaker Complete 'The Shroudbreaker' Tall Tale. 10
- The Cursed Rogue Complete 'The Cursed Rogue' Tall Tale. 10
- The Legendary Storyteller Complete 'The Legendary Storyteller' Tall Tale. 10
- Stars of a Thief Complete the 'Stars of a Thief' Tall Tale. 10
- Wild Rose Complete the 'Wild Rose' Tall Tale. 10
- The Art of the Trickster Complete 'The Art of the Trickster' Tall Tale. 10
- The Fate of the Morningstar Complete 'The Fate of the Morningstar' Tall Tale. 10
- Revenge of the Morningstar Complete the 'Revenge of the Morningstar' Tall Tale. 10
- The Shores of Gold Complete 'The Shores of Gold' Tall Tale. 10
- A Sunken Legacy Receive all Commendations for 'The Shroudbreaker' Tall Tale. 30
- Fateful Memories Receive all Commendations for 'The Cursed Rogue' Tall Tale. 30
- Sea of Dreams Receive all Commendations for 'The Legendary Storyteller' Tall Tale. 30
- The Stolen Sky Receive all Commendations for the 'Stars of a Thief' Tall Tale. 30
- Always Yours Receive all Commendations for the 'Wild Rose' Tall Tale. 30
- The Trickster's Folly Receive all Commendations for 'The Art of the Trickster' Tall Tale. 30
- The Unbroken Bond Receive all Commendations for 'The Fate of the Morningstar' Tall Tale. 30
- The Morningstar Rises Receive all Commendations for 'The Revenge of the Morningstar' Tall Tale. 30
- Seeker of Grand Adventure Receive all Commendations for all the Shores of Gold Tall Tales. 130