- Oct 25, 2017
There is no point hammering.
There is unlikely to be a change before the deadline and it isn't like a lynch. Just keep the thread open so we can keep discussing stuff.
There is no point hammering.
Every single game I've been in that town have lost is because we focus too much on the loud players. Sure, we might get one scum out of that, but more often than not we end up forgetting about half the roster, and that's how scum just posts their way to victory.Yeah. She was a strong town read for me early on but on listening to people on this page and looking back at the post history I'm rethinking my stance.
Especially not a fan of this:
In terms of probability, of course scum is nearly always amongst the coasters. Scum is also amongst town leaders, chaotic players, etc... There isn't a single scum archetype and we pretty much see all of them every game. To single out coasters is to single out a target that Swamped wants to cast doubt on. I see this as scum play.
Are you kidding? Faddy asked for reads about you just 1 post before mine:
I answered him with my read. How is that convenient when I'm answering our semi confirmed townie about you?
Hello, and welcome to Simon Says!
You are a Vanilla Townie: your only power is to vote.
You are aligned with Town and win when all threats against Town have been eliminated.
The game thread is here.
If you have any questions, please send a PM to Pedro.
Simon says: "After reading this message, please reply to it to confirm you received it".
[highlight]DOUBLE: <Player name>[/highlight]
I assumed that the majority number is still the same so with 12 alive the majority is 7 but if everyone double votes it is now 4.
The majority is still the same, but it takes "half" the number of votes to get there. Current majority is 7, so 4 people voting for the same target would end the day.
Yes, thunderdome would have been bad. Why didn't you chose the roleblock? Wouldn't it prevent NKs also?I chose double vote because with 1 death it should still take a decent number of votes to turbo.
I was tempted to thunderdome with meatwad, dcpat and swamped the candidates but I think that wouln't have been great for today. The other things felt less important.
Everyone be CAREFUL with your vote.
I don't want to see anyone voting without a good reason attached.
I had thought my “bang” seconds after cabot’s death was pretty clear, but nobody seemed to really pay to any mind. I’m the day vig.
It also stops cops, doctors etc. Better to get more info out for today. Roleblock is just repeating day 1 when potentially we can get better use of it later in the game.
Now that Apollo claimed, can you explain your theory?
Four reasons. One, the posts from Cabot you pointed out seemed incredibly scummy when put together. I hadn’t noticed them like that prior, but I was thoroughly convinced. Two, swamped’s readlist prior. She had Cabot as scum, but I wasn’t quite seeing why. Three, exodus weakly prasiing your argument. For the last two, I figured that if Cabot was scum like I was believing, I at the time thought it would potentially implicate those two. Not very convincing, but that’s where I was at the time of the shot.
Because whoever shot cabot didn't know his alignment so if he flipped town it is a clear attempt to implicate me.
I can see that but I don't think scum would kill a partner just to incriminate a townie D1. And I find hard to believe that we have a neutral SK in a game with 14 players.Because whoever shot cabot didn't know his alignment so if he flipped town it is a clear attempt to implicate me.
I thought someone would have claimed it if they were town knowing they would have simon protection for the night so I immediately thought it was a serial killer.
The fact that apollo did claim, just everyone decided it was me makes me feel better about the situation.
Mini mafia can have a Serial Killer and that is 13 players.
I never played a mini but how would that work? With a lynch, scum kill and SK kill the game would end really quick.
I was thinking that too. Just be so scummy that you end up getting town read.I can't
Faddy states right at the top of the page that we should let the clock run out and discussion go where it will, and Meatwad once again flounces in and draws attention with an insane move after kind of disappearing back under the radar for the middle of the day. those people that were interpreting him as Town (like myself) based it mostly on how his early game moves were so terribly obvious and attention grabbing as to not be scum, but it's entirely possible that that's now a strategy that's being played into?