XD I love how convinced you guys are that there is a cop, and that it's meatwad lol
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Simon Says Mafia - I would never lie to you, please do what I say
- Thread starter Pedro
- Start date
XD I love how convinced you guys are that there is a cop, and that it's meatwad lol
I assumed they were going to kill me or Apollo. Chugg was my next highest town so I chose him.
'Sup, I'm late, but ready to party.
That kill makes sense, after the end of the last day phase. I like that Simon modifier choice, too. Though, I feel like it'd work pretty much at any point of this game.
The ones I suspect the most right now are Meatwad, exodus, and Swamped. Mainly feel right now; I need to take time to make some proper connections, but some things off the top of my head:
That kill makes sense, after the end of the last day phase. I like that Simon modifier choice, too. Though, I feel like it'd work pretty much at any point of this game.
The ones I suspect the most right now are Meatwad, exodus, and Swamped. Mainly feel right now; I need to take time to make some proper connections, but some things off the top of my head:
- Meatwad: Some weird play, like the avoidance to being Simon on D1 or the hammer.
- exodus: Uncertainty regarding Faddy's alignment, now apparently leaning scum, and reads I generally don't agree with.
- Swamped: Not even sure, but I did read most of the thread and it's a feeling. There's been more defense around Meatwad as the game's progressed, and Swamped is part of this.
I might have missed something, but why is there a certainty that Meatwad's a cop?
I think there are 4. Or effectively 4, if there's a neutral too.
Yeah, up until that DC flip, I thought that was where the ax would fall too.
I think the theory is that meatwad hammered D1, so that he could guarantee a check. I think it's more likely that he just screwed up though.
He feels like he is trying to solve the game and is contributing in a positive manner imo.
Why did you think DCPat was a bad lynch. He sure as hell didn't project town, he went willingly to his own death. It makes it seem like you had additional information.
I honestly almost dropped the vote on Malus because I was pretty confident in DC being town. I really didn't look much at Malus's posts over the day though so I went back to re-read for a bit and the hammer dropped. I didn't want to drop the vote blind.
I don't know about Salva. He was just a hunch and I wanted to offer up someone to counter the vote train on DC. At least we have a little bit more voting information now than if we had hammered DC outright.
Right now my top scum read is still Faddy. He got town laser focused on DC over nothing, and has picked Chugg as Simon even though Chugg's posting was extremely weak on day 2.
Nah. When I called cabot town and then went on Meatwad his response was that I went from being so right to being so wrong. That is softing a PR.
At the very least, I agree that exodus's opposition to DCPat's lynch came off as stronger than I would hve expected. I didn't look good to me
I voice my opinions yesterday. The lynch was too easy with no opposition from potential teammates. It's not hard to see why DC went willingly to his death, considering his ability.
Anyways, I'm not beating around this anymore.
Vote: Faddy
Yes. DCPat was not even trying.
I get that he had a lynchproof but that makes it even more important to contribute and make people have a proper opinion of you rather than get scum read for doing nothing.
LOL exodus.
I'm going to claim now because I was pretty shocked by DCPat's flip. I'm town governor and can override into a No Lynch. Which is actual garbage and I would never use unless it was to save myself.
He said that after cabot's flip. So I don't see how it's softing anything.
What am I meant to do here? I would only ever hold it for myself.
I guess I can prove it if I am alive in MYLO, we can lynch me and I will override myself.
Read the subtext. He is saying I was right for hitting scum but now I am very wrong because I am attacking a town PR.
I mean, why claim at all? There's nothing about DCPat's flip that justifies it.
I think I just wouldn't of claimed it tbh. You probably aren't in danger of being lynched for the rest of the game
Yes there is. His role is almost exactly the same as my role except I can target anyone. But I am only going to use it on myself. And I won;t get a confirmation like he did so everyone is going to say I am a scum counter to DCPat.
Exactly. And coupled with cabot's weird role PM win con it makes me think that we are missing something here.
I mean, maybe? It can also be easily read as "Faddy, you may have guess correctly on your first scum read, but you are wrong about me as I am town".
As for Faddy's claim, I think thats a lot of no lynch power between him, DCPat and a forced No Lynch D1. Somewhat balanced by having my day vig power to help rack up an extra kill? Idk.
If anything it makes you less town. Since 2 town can stop their own lynch.
Why do we need that plus a vig shot?
I see. Well, it seems the Simon power is picked at the start of the day, so Faddy would have been going off D1 play.
Powerful scum on the remaining members? Idk. But it can't be denied that I shot a scum player, so yeah. I'm still town.
That would mean a day going by without a lynch. That does not seem worth it.
I see. But, to the bolded, justifiably so. It seems like a small game to have so many circumstances revolve around people not getting lynched. Not sure what to make of it.
I can buy it, though. Still think both Apollo and Faddy are very much town for now.
I'm just going to keep going on assuming Faddy is town. Apollo could be a neutral, but I'm not super concerned with neutrals right now.
No it is a day pick.
Chugg you should put in at least a provisional simon to Pedro in case you get day killed or something.
Good plan. I'll just pick someone who I'm town reading right now, and I'll think about it more and change it later if I reconsider it.
If anyone doubts I am the governor. I was posting colours because I literally did not care about getting scum read. And then once the day started and there wasn't a lynch I laughed and mesaged Pedro and said I was going to do it for 2 days then override my lynch.
Actually exodus allow me to push you some more.
Your initial vote for Salva was because he was a coaster. Why call him out instead of other coasters? Also, you were scum reading me quite a bit. Why not vote for a scumread? You could have started an alternative train on me, many other vocal players would have joined you (probably Fran, possibly Chuggs).
Your initial vote for Salva was because he was a coaster. Why call him out instead of other coasters? Also, you were scum reading me quite a bit. Why not vote for a scumread? You could have started an alternative train on me, many other vocal players would have joined you (probably Fran, possibly Chuggs).
Not going to lie. My first thought when Faddy started saying saying Meaty was a cop was to trick scum into killing him so they would waste a kill on someone who was on a lot of peoples scum list and then Faddy would reveal he was actually the cop and he was going to give us a read during the night phase. Looked a bit too deep there
Then we would know when he doesn't die. It's a genius play that didn't actually happen.
Wouldn't this have been the best way to save DC though? Plus you get to lynch a scum read.