I feel better about my read on him at Fran right now, and I want to get some actual posts from Fran, but for he comes in and destroys my argument
This is crap and you know it. If you want answers, make questions. This "he will destrou my argument" looks really scummy to me. If you are town why are you worried that I could refute your arguments?
Actually @Fran and @ malus it seems both of you have been big proponents in testing the claim. Or outright scumreading Faddy. It seems the bulk of your posts have to do with it. Why haven't you guys put down votes yet?
Because I wasn't around much.
Same question to you @Fran as malus, what happens if faddy is telling the truth?
We will have another confirmed townie. And we can shout at Pedro for adding 2 lynchables in a 14 players game.
Here is my perspective on people believing me.
I think chuggs has the most reason to believe since I gave him the the Simon power. Maybe he has pocketed me...
Swamped seemed genuine and trying to solve the game and evaluate it. I thought she was town for a few reasons but she is the more likely out of these two to be scum.
Apollo is for me and unlikely to be with Cabot unless scum are just shooting each other for lols.
Everyone else has expressed some concern that my power is fake. That from my perspective must include scum. I think they don't believe my role which is why I think it is Fran, malus, Salva. They are going for the town cred because they have assumed I am lying and they will be proven right.
Remember scum doesn't know if I am telling the truth or not, they only know I am not with them, which is why Fran's neutral comment was a scum tell.
So everyone that believes you is town. People that doubt you is scum. OK.
It does seem strange to jump immediately to neutral from the claim, but I'm not sure why scum would assume a neutral and not just town having your claimed power.
Actually this plays into the answer to Zekes post: Scum has no reason to doubt the claim unless they believe there is a neutral. So I guess if you're telling the truth it would be worth looking into Fran.
I don't believe that town would have that power because I don't believe that we would have 2 town unlynchables. So either Faddy is a neutral unlynchable or he is a lying scum. My first thought was why he would claim that if he doesnt' have the role so he should have it and is a neutral.
Now I don't believe him. And it's not only because of the twilight thing but also how he went after Meatwad.
Her power was only available in the immediate time after end of day.
How do we know that if there is no flip. We don't know when she could use it. Maybe she could use it during the day as a normal override but she decided against it. That's why I asked you when you could use it as soon as you claimed.
Why can't scum have this power?
Because a unlynchable scum is the most OP role ever? The only way that town can deal with scum is with a lynch (and vig but that's another story). Taking that power from town and giving it to scum is OP. The only option would be is the scum team is really small, like only 2 players. And even then is still OP.