Spotify's most popular podcast "Joe Rogan" encourages healthy young people to Not get the Covid-19 vaccine

MIMIC

Member
Dec 18, 2017
6,286
Unlikely if you follow CDC guidelines sure. That includes their masking guidelines and social distance guidelines.

It *may* be true beyond that but it's far too early to know about variant strains.
You're already unlikely to get COVID if you wear a mask and maintain social distancing. Are you saying the vaccine does nothing on its own to reduce risk?
 

MIMIC

Member
Dec 18, 2017
6,286
Actually based on the cdc data, they used frontline medical provider and ems workers

They got the vaccines first anyways so they will be the population with data available the earliest
Oh wow. I didn't know that. So then the risk is substantially lower for everyone else I'm presuming (if the most susceptible people to the virus managed to keep from being infected)
 

Stooge

Member
Oct 29, 2017
4,793
You're already unlikely to get COVID if you wear a mask and maintain social distancing. Are you saying the vaccine does nothing on its own to reduce risk?
Is your argument that you get vaxxed and stop following CDC guidelines? I'm not sure what you are looking for.

Feel free to do whatever you want I guess?
 

MIMIC

Member
Dec 18, 2017
6,286
Is your argument that you get vaxxed and stop following CDC guidelines? I'm not sure what you are looking for.

Feel free to do whatever you want I guess?
No, that is not my argument. My argument was that the vaccine substantially reduces the risk of infection (and therefore transmission). You kept harping on the figure I used (and at the same time wouldn't use your own) and I'm trying to understand what you are trying to argue. I asked you a question, and then you answered it with a question.
 

GiJose

Member
Oct 25, 2017
285
Oh wow. I didn't know that. So then the risk is substantially lower for everyone else I'm presuming (if the most susceptible people to the virus managed to keep from being infected)
Ehh not really. It depends on what you mean by that. Healthcare workers are more likely to be appropriately protected, but also come across covid way more often. Hard to quantify when there are so many variables in play.

What's the actual risk if I, as a vaccinated person, spent 30 mins in a small room unmasked with someone also unmasked with covid-19? Probably a decent chance I'd acquire covid in that scenario. It's not an activity I'd like to do, even with the vaccine on board.
 

Stooge

Member
Oct 29, 2017
4,793
No, that is not my argument. My argument was that the vaccine substantially reduces the risk of infection (and therefore transmission). You kept harping on the figure I used (and at the same time wouldn't use your own) and I'm trying to understand what you are trying to argue. I asked you a question, and then you answered it with a question.
The vaccine substantially reduces your likelihood of contracting covid. You stated that you have a .01% chance of getting covid once vaccinated which is not true.

You are making far to strong a claim about the effectiveness of the vaccine which is the exact sort of arguement that is leading to people acting unsafely and not following CDC guidelines post vaccination.

.01% of people who were vaccinated have contracted covid over a 3-4 months window, but that has *loads* of factors at play including generally following CDC guidelines and a pretty short timeframe. Attributing that entire number to the vaccine is both untrue and could lead other to act against CDC guidelines thinking there is little chance of contracting the virus no matter what behavior they engage in.

The vaccine is wonderful and once you have it you can do LOTS of stuff you ought not do unvaccinated, but if you personally engage in behavior like going to packed bars unmasked you are not going to have a .01% chance of getting covid. Maybe once the numbers are down to Spring of 2020 levels and community transmission is low that might be true.
 

MIMIC

Member
Dec 18, 2017
6,286
Ehh not really. It depends on what you mean by that. Healthcare workers are more likely to be appropriately protected, but also come across covid way more often. Hard to quantify when there are so many variables in play.

What's the actual risk if I, as a vaccinated person, spent 30 mins in a small room unmasked with someone also unmasked with covid-19? Probably a decent chance I'd acquire covid in that scenario. It's not an activity I'd like to do, even with the vaccine on board.
I'm talking about the average person going about their day-to-day life grocery shopping, ordering fast food, etc.

But in your hypothetical, I wouldn't say there's a "decent chance." There's a study being conducted to address this very question. But the suggestion is that the vaccine stops transmission (again, not definitive):

There is mounting, though incomplete, evidence that people receiving inoculations are protected from all kinds of infections — including insidious, symptom-free infections that have made the virus so challenging to contain.

“This study is addressing the important issue about what does it mean to be vaccinated, as far as your risk for transmitting SARS-CoV-2 to people in your bubble of trust,” said Lilly Immergluck, a pediatric infectious-disease specialist at Morehouse School of Medicine.
 

MIMIC

Member
Dec 18, 2017
6,286
The vaccine substantially reduces your likelihood of contracting covid. You stated that you have a .01% chance of getting covid once vaccinated which is not true.

You are making far to strong a claim about the effectiveness of the vaccine which is the exact sort of arguement that is leading to people acting unsafely and not following CDC guidelines post vaccination.

.01% of people who were vaccinated have contracted covid over a 3-4 months window, but that has *loads* of factors at play including generally following CDC guidelines and a pretty short timeframe. Attributing that entire number to the vaccine is both untrue and could lead other to act against CDC guidelines thinking there is little chance of contracting the virus no matter what behavior they engage in.

The vaccine is wonderful and once you have it you can do LOTS of stuff you ought not do unvaccinated, but if you personally engage in behavior like going to packed bars unmasked you are not going to have a .01% chance of getting covid. Maybe once the numbers are down to Spring of 2020 levels and community transmission is low that might be true.
I didn't say anything about going to a packed bar or not wearing a mask. Those are assumptions that you are making. If anything, you should be glad that people are strongly advocating for getting vaccinated instead of worrying about what whatever "post vaccination" assumptions and implications are being made.

But like I just posted a little while ago, the evidence is highly suggestive that the vaccines do effectively stop transmission. Maybe I'm jumping the gun a bit but at least there's the suggestion.
 

Stooge

Member
Oct 29, 2017
4,793
Maybe I'm jumping the gun a bit but at least there's the suggestion.
I mean, you are actively and continually misconstruing a single study and making WILDLY stronger claims than anyone involved in public health like "vaccines do effectively stop transmission" which I don't think a single public health official has come close to claiming.
 

MIMIC

Member
Dec 18, 2017
6,286
I mean, you are actively and continually misconstruing a single study and making WILDLY stronger claims than anyone involved in public health like "vaccines do effectively stop transmission" which I don't think a single public health official has come close to claiming.
I have clarified my comment and said that it's looking like the vaccines do stop transmission. And as far as a public health expert on the subject:

Dr. Faucci:

And the question is — we do know now that we have a 94 to 95 percent efficacy in preventing clinically recognizable disease, but the looming question is: If a person gets infected, despite the fact that they’ve been vaccinated — we refer to that as a “breakthrough infection” — does that person have the capability of transmitting the infection to another person? Namely, does vaccine prevent transmission?

And I had mentioned to you that we, together with the Moderna company — and the Pfizer group is going to do it also — are also going to be looking at the viral load in the nasal pharynx to determine if, in fact, a person who’s vaccinated but has a breakthrough infection, compared to a person who’s unvaccinated and has an asymptomatic infection, is there a difference in the viral load? That will be very important.

What has happened over the past couple of weeks is there have been some studies that are pointing into a very favorable direction that will have to be verified and corroborated by other studies.
 
Oct 26, 2017
12,070
Can Canada please place Rogan on the no fly, no entry list for his affiliations and flirtations with white nationalism and therefore domestic terrorism watchlist
 

BWoog

Member
Oct 27, 2017
25,993
This fucking asshole isn’t going to stop. (Sorry for the Twitter account but I could only see it through right wing shit lords)

 

Rocky Road

Member
Jun 1, 2018
666
This dude is why I stopped giving Spotify any money. I've been using their webplayer with extensions that block all ads while I slowly acquire MP3s of everything that was in my library 100% and once I'm done with that I'm not giving them any more web trafic or touching any of their services again with a ten foot poll.
 

erlim

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,616
London
Idk if anyone watched Corridor Digital (their popular VFX react series), but man i was bummed to see them promoting this garbage.
Sam and Niko are pretty classic conservatives. Not Trump supporters, at least not Niko that I know, but definitely pro second-amendment and libertarian in their politics. Not something that should really effect your enjoyment of their art though. It’s like—you’re never 100% in political agreement with politics of any other huge entertainers or visionary creators, and that’s ok.
 
Last edited:

Fleck0

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,241
So Rogan has gone full anti-vaxer, again.
I want to leave Spotify so badly
Same, I only use it to sleep anymore and should replace it.

It's just exhausting, my family had to use the "you can't see us or get hugs" attack to get my sister and her boyfriend (Rogan listener) to get their first shots.
 
Last edited:
On the latest episode of his Spotify podcast, the sixth lead on Newsradio says woke culture is putting straight white men’s rights in jeopardy. “You can never be woke enough that’s the problem, it keeps going,” he explains. “It keeps going further and further down the line and if you get to the point where you capitulate, where you agree to all these demands, it’ll eventually get to straight white men are not allowed to talk, because it’s your privilege to express yourself when other people of color have been silenced throughout history.”
Now, keep in mind Rogan has never been at risk of losing his platform, which Spotify reportedly paid $100 million for, even while he pals around with the alt-right. Spotify omitted the episodes with Alex Jones, Proud Boys founder Gavin McInnes, Milo Yiannopoulos, and other alt-right figures, but never threatened to shutter Rogan’s podcast. As Newsweek reports, Rogan gets over 200 million downloads per month on Spotify. The streaming platform sure as hell won’t shut Rogan up anytime soon—it just doesn’t want him to talk to white supremacists. So, who exactly is doing the silencing?
The former Fear Factor host also doesn’t get how anything works, because he genuinely says he believes that at some point, people won’t be allowed to go outside because so many people will have been imprisoned. “I’m not joking,” he adds. “It really will get there. It’s that crazy.”