The topic of Thanos as a protagonist deserves more nuance than my hyperbolic initial posts. I reacted strongly to the original post which features videos that do not exemplify any such nuance (the first one clearly uses protagonist in the title and the thumbnail says "hero" which people seemed to take surprisingly little issue with)
That being said, while the idea of Thanos as a protagonist might be interesting from the standpoint of insight into the creative process of the writers, this is still a comic book movie. It's not breaking new ground. You can point out aspects of Thanos's role that mirror certain aspects of a traditional protagonists journey, but they are skin deep.
Thanos killing Gammorah is not really an "all is lost" moment. It is not thrust upon him and it does not change his course. He gets a bit sad about it and then does it without hesitation. He gets what he's wanted all along out of it. It is a minor trial at its deepest.
What is clearly the actual "all is lost" moment in Infinity War is when Thanos snaps and literally 50% of the universe including the heroes die. Infinity was is not an entire story in and of itself, and Thanos winning is obviously the low point for the actual protagonists.
That being said, while the idea of Thanos as a protagonist might be interesting from the standpoint of insight into the creative process of the writers, this is still a comic book movie. It's not breaking new ground. You can point out aspects of Thanos's role that mirror certain aspects of a traditional protagonists journey, but they are skin deep.
Thanos killing Gammorah is not really an "all is lost" moment. It is not thrust upon him and it does not change his course. He gets a bit sad about it and then does it without hesitation. He gets what he's wanted all along out of it. It is a minor trial at its deepest.
What is clearly the actual "all is lost" moment in Infinity War is when Thanos snaps and literally 50% of the universe including the heroes die. Infinity was is not an entire story in and of itself, and Thanos winning is obviously the low point for the actual protagonists.