• Introducing Image Options for ResetEra 2.0! Check the left side navigation bar to show or hide images, avatars, covers, and embedded media. More details at the link.

The Mansion Mafia - Hold on tightly to your secrets

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,807
Do we actually believe Splinter? If he tells the truth we must lynch from a pool of only 7 players, but if he lies and we believe him we are probably fucked
 

Kalor

Resettlement Advisor
Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,633
Splinter claimed to essentially kill Wee so if he's scum as well, his role must be way better than a strong kill. Wee wouldn't have been lynched if it wasn't for that claim. It's not like she was dead anyway and Splinter claimed just for town cred.
 
Oct 25, 2017
746
Splinter claimed to essentially kill Wee so if he's scum as well, his role must be way better than a strong kill. Wee wouldn't have been lynched if it wasn't for that claim. It's not like she was dead anyway and Splinter claimed just for town cred.
Agreed. Not quite sure what good this would do scum if splinter had lied to throw wee under the bus
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,638
Splinter claimed to essentially kill Wee so if he's scum as well, his role must be way better than a strong kill. Wee wouldn't have been lynched if it wasn't for that claim. It's not like she was dead anyway and Splinter claimed just for town cred.
I agree, I mean even if there were three left yesterday (I’m assuming JOAT and scum watcher/goon). It would take a lot to sacrifice a teammate when you might not have to.

I’m choosing to believe splinter personally
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,807
Seanima - slight scum lean, feels like he is a mafioso that did a good job hidding in the first day phases, need to reread

Zipped - zipped, scum, his D3 is what looks the worst of him, that push for WSD is really scummy

Kalor - the vig, I believe him

Splinter - the cop, lean towards believing him because the claim is consistent with the subsequent playstile(following me in the Wee push mostly) and the breadcrumb is beliable

Stu - flipflopping between slight scum lean and slight town lean, need to reread

WSD - the sleepwalker mate, town, unless there is fuckery behind the scenes(mad scum JOAT with a namecop shot theory, posted it on D3)

Kitsu - probably town because zipped wanted to lynch her, but given that zipped could had "bussed" any teammate on his side of the wall and not matered as he wouldn't be able to vote for them, maybe they are scummates, but wouldn't lynch her today

gog - probably town if splinter tells the truth and she isn't a godfather

Muffin - lean scum, that vote for kitsu on d3 is sus

Bronson - need to reread, I think my guts were town on him

turmoil - me
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,638
Seanima - slight scum lean, feels like he is a mafioso that did a good job hidding in the first day phases, need to reread

Zipped - zipped, scum, his D3 is what looks the worst of him, that push for WSD is really scummy

Kalor - the vig, I believe him

Splinter - the cop, lean towards believing him because the claim is consistent with the subsequent playstile(following me in the Wee push mostly) and the breadcrumb is beliable

Stu - flipflopping between slight scum lean and slight town lean, need to reread

WSD - the sleepwalker mate, town, unless there is fuckery behind the scenes(mad scum JOAT with a namecop shot theory, posted it on D3)

Kitsu - probably town because zipped wanted to lynch her, but given that zipped could had "bussed" any teammate on his side of the wall and not matered as he wouldn't be able to vote for them, maybe they are scummates, but wouldn't lynch her today

gog - probably town if splinter tells the truth and she isn't a godfather

Muffin - lean scum, that vote for kitsu on d3 is sus

Bronson - need to reread, I think my guts were town on him

turmoil - me
Ok so if I am town, which I am, how does that change your reads?
 
Oct 25, 2017
8,003
Has anyone wondered why Bronson is still alive despite literally everyone reading him as town for no concrete reason and never having been a lynch candidate?

Because i have. Often.
 
Oct 25, 2017
8,003
Splinter claimed to essentially kill Wee so if he's scum as well, his role must be way better than a strong kill. Wee wouldn't have been lynched if it wasn't for that claim. It's not like she was dead anyway and Splinter claimed just for town cred.
Maybe wee had ran out of kills and had outlived her usefulness.
 

BronsonLee

Assistant (to the) Regional Administrator
Moderator
Oct 24, 2017
12,749
Has anyone wondered why Bronson is still alive despite literally everyone reading him as town for no concrete reason and never having been a lynch candidate?

Because i have. Often.
Because I wasn't as high a priority as the other people they went after

Can we get a kill order from night to night and have their roles put up, too?
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,807
Has anyone wondered why Bronson is still alive despite literally everyone reading him as town for no concrete reason and never having been a lynch candidate?

Because i have. Often.
NK targets so far:
n1:???(we should look for B-Dubs breadcrumbs just in case scum targeted his target)
n2:GF, obvious target
n3: Fat4All, confirmed townie basically, probably with more shots
n4: B-Dubs, odd choice but maybe they have a rolecop and they knew he was a doctor

But yeah we must look closer at bronson

Maybe wee had ran out of kills and had outlived her usefulness.
She likely didn't strongkill on n1 because of the no kill night. So at most she used two shots(n2 and n3)
 

BronsonLee

Assistant (to the) Regional Administrator
Moderator
Oct 24, 2017
12,749
I wish I could ask who Dubs had covered, he might be why the N1 kill didn't happen and why he was so gung ho on Hecht oh my gdod
 

Kalor

Resettlement Advisor
Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,633
NK targets so far:
n1:???(we should look for B-Dubs breadcrumbs just in case scum targeted his target)
n2:GF, obvious target
n3: Fat4All, confirmed townie basically, probably with more shots
n4: B-Dubs, odd choice but maybe they have a rolecop and they knew he was a doctor

But yeah we must look closer at bronson



She likely didn't strongkill on n1 because of the no kill night. So at most she used two shots(n2 and n3)
N1 might have been Hecht being shot and losing his vest. Though his role doesn't mention if he'd be notified unless he clarified that later.
 
Oct 25, 2017
8,003
Because I wasn't as high a priority as the other people they went after

Can we get a kill order from night to night and have their roles put up, too?
I just can't trust that face.

NK targets so far:
n1:???(we should look for B-Dubs breadcrumbs just in case scum targeted his target)
n2:GF, obvious target
n3: Fat4All, confirmed townie basically, probably with more shots
n4: B-Dubs, odd choice but maybe they have a rolecop and they knew he was a doctor

But yeah we must look closer at bronson

She likely didn't strongkill on n1 because of the no kill night. So at most she used two shots(n2 and n3)
Why wouldn't she? Saving it for later sounds like a waste. It's possible though.

N1 might have been Hecht being shot and losing his vest. Though his role doesn't mention if he'd be notified unless he clarified that later.
I don't think he ever did.
 

BronsonLee

Assistant (to the) Regional Administrator
Moderator
Oct 24, 2017
12,749
Options:

Wee didn't use her strong kill N1 (possible) and hit Hecht (also possible), but those two together seems off
Does Dubs' protection block strongkills?
 
Oct 25, 2017
8,003
Looked into Dubs early game for breadcrumbs and this is all i could find:

Don't worry, I'll protect you. Unless you're scum, then I'll kill you.
That was in response to Bronson. Can't really read anything from that.

Let's talk sleepwalker. What are the chances of both being it but one being town and the other one scum? So i can tunnel on Devious all over again. Sorry, nothing personal Devious. I like your avatar.

Because i'm running out of people who could be scum. We might just have the two left after all.
 

BronsonLee

Assistant (to the) Regional Administrator
Moderator
Oct 24, 2017
12,749
Dubs protected me! We stan a doctor legend

Also even if I remove myself from the equation, saenima's instant stanning attempts to push someone who's been townread all game into the scum pile seems shaky, especially based on no obvious tells
 

BronsonLee

Assistant (to the) Regional Administrator
Moderator
Oct 24, 2017
12,749
also for those who ask, my scumreads now are:

saenima
Kalor
WhySoDevious

In that order. Sae and Kalor overplayed their hands on Wee, and Devious is clinging to me because I'm America's Sweetheart
 
Oct 25, 2017
8,003
also for those who ask, my scumreads now are:

saenima
Kalor
WhySoDevious

In that order. Sae and Kalor overplayed their hands on Wee, and Devious is clinging to me because I'm America's Sweetheart
What if no one counterclaims Kalor? Do you still scum read him? And why Devious? I agree, but i wanna hear your reasoning.
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,807
Bronson don't make us waste time with your kalor scumread, it is garbage

I feel like I want to give saenima an extra day.

If I could pick today's choices it would be a thunderdome between Zipped and Muffin probably

Currently my best guess is

Town:splinter, gog, kalor, WSD
???:saenima, stu, kitsu, Bronson
Scum:Muffin, Zipped

With someone well hidden among '???'
 
Oct 25, 2017
746
Bronson don't make us waste time with your kalor scumread, it is garbage

I feel like I want to give saenima an extra day.

If I could pick today's choices it would be a thunderdome between Zipped and Muffin probably

Currently my best guess is

Town:splinter, gog, kalor, WSD
???:saenima, stu, kitsu, Bronson
Scum:Muffin, Zipped

With someone well hidden among '???'
Could I hear an argument for ScumMuffin because it's someone I've been wanting to reread
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,807
Biggest issue with muffin is that every day phase there has been scum in the running but he has never voted or even pushed for one, sure he could be town and just have a very bad streak but what are the odds at this point of the game?
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,807
I feel like Muffin wasn't at risk at all of being lynhed during D3, wee and zipped wanted z-beat, I think it could had been to protect Muffin
 
Oct 25, 2017
4,886
If one of them is scum, who do you think is more likely scum?
Between Muffin and Zipped?

Hmm. on balance, I'd guess Zipped. His D1 feels like an on purpose effort to make himself seem suspect while the rest of the days are about making people question but not lynch him if that makes sense.

That way, no one will question why he's still alive.
 

Kitsunelaine

My favorite cake is pie
Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,273
Let's shake some trees.

Kitsunelaine used HEADBUTT.

Vote: Zippedpinhead

Never liked the D1 play. The excuses given later about seeing how people reacted proved absolutely useless and had no attempts at follow through. Which means it was an excuse.
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,383
Confirmed (4):
Splinter
Turmoil
Girlofgotham
Kalor

Unconfirmed (7):
WhySoDevious
Stuart
Bronson
Kits
Saenima
Zipped
Muffin


Is that everyone?

Wow scum are boned