The Mansion Mafia - Hold on tightly to your secrets

[BronsonLee]

BronsonLee - how do you think scum player's play will differ from towns?

My limited experience with Mafia is that scum players tend to not do too much early on/not be too prominent? Unsure if that answers

In terms of rooms, I'm going to assume that the voices mean us and recommend the following rooms:

Yellow seems like it would probably allow us to vote for someone to have night immunity or similar (I recomend myself)

Why u

 

[BronsonLee]

we return to the white room if the game runs long enough to use up all the other rooms

Ahhh makes sense

I like the idea of popping Dark Room early as well so

VOTE: Dark Room

 

[Stuart444]

MOVE: Blue Room

Since there isn't a lot of support for Teal, I'll go blue. Because it's my favourite colour. Not as nice of a shade in that image as Teal but still good colour.

 

[Kopite]

If it's no NKs, that would be good for town. One less townie dies at night.

This post feels oddly noncommittal to me. You could have just added that it would be good for town later but definitely not now. It feels like you're somewhat suggesting we go to the room now, which would be bad for town.

 

[Grizzly]

That's enough BroLee.

Ok. Bed for reals.

 

[B-Dubs]

It occurs to me, what if Dark Room punishes prior post count?

I still think either Dark or Orange is the smart thing to do here.

 

[Stuart444]

This post feels oddly noncommittal to me. You could have just added that it would be good for town later but definitely not now. It feels like you're somewhat suggesting we go to the room now, which would be bad for town.

?

I said, no NK at night be it now or later would be good no matter what.

*sighs* I always seem to word things like absolute shite.

 

[B-Dubs]

MOVE: Blue Room

Since there isn't a lot of support for Teal, I'll go blue. Because it's my favourite colour. Not as nice of a shade in that image as Teal but still good colour.

Really? Just based off color? What about our trying to figure out what rooms do what?

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Was there enough time for Zippo to see Dubs' vote?

Hmm hmm hm.

no no there was not. I started my post after seeing the other vote for me.

 

[saenima]

MOVE: Blue Room

Since there isn't a lot of support for Teal, I'll go blue. Because it's my favourite colour. Not as nice of a shade in that image as Teal but still good colour.

I feel like this is a very bad way of going about it. This might be important.

 

[Fat4all]

It occurs to me, what if Dark Room punishes prior post count?

I think it would be more reasonable, where it ultimately punishes maybe the player with the lowest post count, either today or tomorrow

either would likely be a benefit to town

 

[Stuart444]

Really? Just based off color? What about our trying to figure out what rooms do what?

We don't know how rooms will work yet. Be they ones that do exactly what they say or if it's something more obscure.

It occurs to me, what if Dark Room punishes prior post count?

I still think either Dark or Orange is the smart thing to do here.

Like what you just posted. Most people assume a raise of min post count but it could be something like this instead.

Trying to figure out how the rooms work will just cause the whole day to revolve around mechanic talk. Boring.

 

[Grizzly]

no no there was not. I started my post after seeing the other vote for me.

But Dubs' vote was the only vote for you.

 

[Fat4all]

We don't know how rooms will work yet. Be they ones that do exactly what they say or if it's something more obscure.

my favorite color is purple and i ain’t voting purple

we can make assumptions on what the rooms do and try for those outcomes

 

[B-Dubs]

Stuart444 The way you're going for rooms is super weird considering we can only go to each a single time. We'll never know what a room really does until we're in it.

 

[saenima]

I'll go with this for now, but i think we should also consider Orange.

Vote: Dark Room

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Shit! I forgot to move when i posted last.

MOVE: red room

 

[Z-Beat]

Really? Just based off color? What about our trying to figure out what rooms do what?

Best case scenario it burns off coasting scum. Worst case scenario it burns off inactive town

 

[BronsonLee]

Yeah deadass teal is my favorite color of all time, but after thinking about it for a bit I wanna be actually logical about these things

 

[Kopite]

?

I said, no NK at night be it now or later would be good no matter what.

*sighs* I always seem to word things like absolute shite.

If you're experienced in Mafia surely you'd suggest a no NK ability is much more favourable towards the end of the game rather than early on?

 

[B-Dubs]

Best case scenario it burns off coasting scum. Worst case scenario it burns off inactive town

He's talking about blue though, not dark

 

[Z-Beat]

That was the wrong quote, sorry. That was for the dark room post

 

[Grizzly]

I lied. I still am here.

Unvote

Kopite is doing things.

Zippo is being weird.

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Anyway right now on my list of people to watch:

Zipped
Grizzly.

The former due to his first few posts, the latter because he reminds me of another game where he was mafia and tried to go at me early.

If you can't see what I'm attempting ( and so far failing to do) with my posts, then...

MOVE: dark room

 

[saenima]

Any thoughts on what the glass wall could be?

 

[Kopite]

@copite I don’t know you, would you say you’re a low, mediium, or high post quantity player?

I would say medium, although my last game I didn't do much D1

 

[Stuart444]

I always tend to have the weirdest logic that makes people jump at me.

x.x

well whatever, I'll stay on blue and that's fucking that.

 

[Fat4all]

Also, picking some of the more trying rooms, rooms that might be a detriment to us possibly, could give us insight into how some of the ‘better’ rooms might work.

maybe we’ll get to vote on specifics, or we’ll get insight on how a person is picked for whatever effect the room has

 

[BronsonLee]

Any thoughts on what the glass wall could be?

Some reflection shit maybe? Like if someone with a role does some stuff it reflects back on them instead?

 

[Stuart444]

If you can't see what I'm attempting ( and so far failing to do) with my posts, then...

MOVE: dark room

I can't, sorry.

Outside of failing to move places.

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Any thoughts on what the glass wall could be?

I don't know but since I already voted to move to red...

MOVE: Pink room


Gotta drive home, I'll check back later tonight for more fun

 

[Godfather]

So literally posting from a train here.(lol)
Knowing we can lose access to rooms, i’m giving anyone who suggest a room they think is bad some massive side eye right now.

 

[Kalor]

My first thought with the glass wall was something with reflections, since it's well... glass. But it doesn't really fit with the rest of the statement.

 

[Grizzly]

Stuart is weirdly reactionary aggressive but Jury is still out on if that is actually Alignment indicative.

I don't understand Zipped right now.

 

[Grizzly]

What vote are you referencing Zip, Dubs was the only vote on you.

 

[flatearthpandas]

So much for waking up for day start. move: dark room

[/highlight]Vote: b-dubs[/highlight]
Can I get a read list, please?

 

[Stuart444]

Stuart is weirdly reactionary aggressive but Jury is still out on if that is actually Alignment indicative.

Is it any different than usual for me? lol.

I say each game, I won't do that and yet I inevitably do.

 

[flatearthpandas]

Goddamn, that mess is my entrance

 

[Grizzly]

So much for waking up for day start. move: dark room

[/highlight]Vote: b-dubs[/highlight]
Can I get a read list, please?

Read list barely one hour in and so many people not around yet?

Whyyyy

 

[Grizzly]

Is it any different than usual for me? lol.

I say each game, I won't do that and yet I inevitably do.

It's different from your town games though.

 

[Aeleus]

My limited experience with Mafia is that scum players tend to not do too much early on/not be too prominent? Unsure if that answers



Why u

One of my favourite hobbies happens to be staying alive (it was meant to be humerous)

Like everyone else here I don't have a great view on Stuart right now the only reason I'm not voting for him was that I felt the exact same way while reading through Kingdom hearts and brexit, this stance will definitely change if he doesn't vote for something other than the Blue Room though, seems scary.

 

[saenima]

Let's do this the right way lol

MOVE: Dark room

 

[Stuart444]

Looking at the Move Tool...

Zipped has done a hell of a lot of room changing early on...

huh.

 

[flatearthpandas]

Once more, with formatting

So much for waking up for day start.
move: dark room

Vote: b-dubs
Can I get a read list, please?

 

[Kopite]

My first thought with the glass wall was something with reflections, since it's well... glass. But it doesn't really fit with the rest of the statement.

Some reflection shit maybe? Like if someone with a role does some stuff it reflects back on them instead?

Wouldn't the gamerunner call it a mirror instead? Although it could be intentionally obscure. I think it's more likely something to do with transparency, but it affects 2 rooms so I'm not sure how that works.

 

[Stuart444]

It's different from your town games though.

wut?

No, no it isn't. I've only been scum once and most games I get reactionary/aggressive. Almost every game.

 

[Grizzly]

Vote: b-dubs
Can I get a read list, please?

Whyyyyyyy

 

[BronsonLee]

noob question, what is a read list?

Wouldn't the gamerunner call it a mirror instead? Although it could be intentionally obscure. I think it's more likely something to do with transparency, but it affects 2 rooms so I'm not sure how that works.

What you do in one room actually takes affect when you move to the other, maybe?

 

[Zippedpinhead]

What vote are you referencing Zip, Dubs was the only vote on you.

I thought B-dubs previous post mentioning me had a vote on it. My mistake. That post was the one I was responding to.

MOVE: blue room

 

[Grizzly]

wut?

No, no it isn't. I've only been scum once and most games I get reactionary/aggressive. Almost every game.

Usually you seem to be aggressive when people doubt your reads. Here you seem aggressive for different reasons.

 

[Stuart444]

noob question, what is a read list?

Where we post who we think is scum/town and why