• Introducing Image Options for ResetEra 2.0! Check the left side navigation bar to show or hide images, avatars, covers, and embedded media. More details at the link.

The Mansion Mafia - Hold on tightly to your secrets

weemadarthur

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,524
Turmoil’s role claim was very plausible alongside godfather’s claim of being a general watcher. Since he turned out a self watcher only, it is now suspect and i’ve moved him down from town read to null.

Bronson is town imo. Fat, good choice.
 

weemadarthur

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,524
I’m going to repeat what i posited yesterday. I don’t remember anyone replying to the thought. Would like some feedback please? If my theory is correct it could use up a ‘safe’ room but identify 2 others for late game usage.

So in case people had trouble understanding yesterday’s drunk posts i’ll repeat what i said.

In the room info, we have 3 rooms that reference “voices”. It seemed reasonable that we had chats. Since we had a verified lovers claim, i think that is an even stronger possibility. My expectation goes like this:

Green Room - "The voices will be pacified." (Lover )Roles don’t work that phase
Yellow Room - "The voices will also protect." The lovers are bulletproof this phase
Orange Room - "Noise will muddle the voices." The lover chat is closed this phase

Which I am suggesting that we test this theory by picking any of these 3 rooms to see if we get things that only apply to dead people. In theory voices could also refer to OTHER chats, including scum chat, which would suggest we should try that room. But i don’t believe that yellow would give bulletproof to an entire scum team, so it’s iffy.

The other possibility of “voices” is just....power roles. Which, green would stop them working, yellow would be beneficial, but orange in that case could mean Switcher Madness, a horrifying prospect.

So I suggest we do the Yellow Room and see if it gives us a vanilla modifier phase given that they are dead before it applies.

move: yellow room
 

B-Dubs

The Mad Titan
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
12,922
I’m going to repeat what i posited yesterday. I don’t remember anyone replying to the thought. Would like some feedback please? If my theory is correct it could use up a ‘safe’ room but identify 2 others for late game usage.
I still say voices are votes. Those are all way too specific to a single role.
 
Oct 25, 2017
9,548
I’m going to repeat what i posited yesterday. I don’t remember anyone replying to the thought. Would like some feedback please? If my theory is correct it could use up a ‘safe’ room but identify 2 others for late game usage.
I don't fully agree on the specifics but I did also vote for yellow.
 

Hecht

Stuck in the Thanus 🔨
Administrator
Oct 24, 2017
4,412
I’m going to repeat what i posited yesterday. I don’t remember anyone replying to the thought. Would like some feedback please? If my theory is correct it could use up a ‘safe’ room but identify 2 others for late game usage.
Maybe. "voices" might mean chats or it could be votes, or something else entirely. I think the only one I'd consider there is Orange since maybe it closes scum chat?
I'm currently wondering what "fates" means with respect to the blue room. "fates" to me would probably have something to do with a player's fate - i.e. death - so maybe there's a revive in play in that room? Maybe "fates" are roles and maybe everyone is vanilla in that one.
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,099
I'm currently wondering what "fates" means with respect to the blue room. "fates" to me would probably have something to do with a player's fate - i.e. death - so maybe there's a revive in play in that room? Maybe "fates" are roles and maybe everyone is vanilla in that one.
I'll admit, I'm super curious about that one.
 
Oct 31, 2017
2,061
I’m not feeling too hot right now so I don’t think I’ll be checking in too frequently.

I’ll be more active tomorrow when I’m stuck in front of a computer all day.

Some people are reading me scum. I’m not. I’m just a dumb noob overthinking too much. I was looking at the votes from D1 and early Day2 yesterday and I just couldn’t believe Kaz being scum.

Can someone answer this... what exactly did Lux do to get killed like that? What was so obvious that somebody risked that shot?
 

Hecht

Stuck in the Thanus 🔨
Administrator
Oct 24, 2017
4,412
Can someone answer this... what exactly did Lux do to get killed like that? What was so obvious that somebody risked that shot?
I don't think there was something obvious so much as getting clarification on how the votes may have fallen during D1, regarding grizz vs lux
 

B-Dubs

The Mad Titan
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
12,922
I’m not feeling too hot right now so I don’t think I’ll be checking in too frequently.

I’ll be more active tomorrow when I’m stuck in front of a computer all day.

Some people are reading me scum. I’m not. I’m just a dumb noob overthinking too much. I was looking at the votes from D1 and early Day2 yesterday and I just couldn’t believe Kaz being scum.

Can someone answer this... what exactly did Lux do to get killed like that? What was so obvious that somebody risked that shot?
He was as good as dead on D1 until the final rush to Grizz. Maybe our dayvig can check alignment too.
 

weemadarthur

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,524
Silence is the lack of voices. From there we can presume that voices are votes. If all those are just referring to the lovers then that's way too specific.
well silence does imply that *something* was silenced, and "voices" seems like a likely candidate
If that’s true, orange is probably hidden votes.
.....I can’t even guess whether it would be better to use that up early or leave it til the end....
 
Oct 25, 2017
9,548
Can someone answer this... what exactly did Lux do to get killed like that? What was so obvious that somebody risked that shot?
I assumed it was because we'd just end up running through the "kaz or lux" conversation again otherwise, but there may have been something there that I should look into.
 

B-Dubs

The Mad Titan
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
12,922
If that’s true, orange is probably hidden votes.
.....I can’t even guess whether it would be better to use that up early or leave it til the end....
I might skip that one altogether. Yellow seems like it would be a good pick next, protect someone from a nightkill (if that's what it does).
 

weemadarthur

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,524
Maybe. "voices" might mean chats or it could be votes, or something else entirely. I think the only one I'd consider there is Orange since maybe it closes scum chat?
I'm currently wondering what "fates" means with respect to the blue room. "fates" to me would probably have something to do with a player's fate - i.e. death - so maybe there's a revive in play in that room? Maybe "fates" are roles and maybe everyone is vanilla in that one.
Players went to spec, not some interim holding room.
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,833
WSD is giving me CoolestSpot in Berserk vives, playing the dumb noob role very well then turns out he was a framer or something and fucked us bad.

(Berserk was Coolest and mine's first game, he framed one of our cops the first night when the second cop checked on it, we lynched the first cop and next day the second one :x)
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,099
WSD is giving me CoolestSpot in Berserk vives, playing the dumb noob role very well then turns out he was a framer or something and fucked us bad.

(Berserk was Coolest and mine's first game, he framed one of our cops the first night when the second cop checked on it, we lynched the first cop and next day the second one :x)
wow. That's... actually quite masterful for CS XD (sorry CS. <3)
 

Hecht

Stuck in the Thanus 🔨
Administrator
Oct 24, 2017
4,412
Players went to spec, not some interim holding room.
Hmm, good point. I suppose that could be the vanilla room if "fates" = "roles." I do find it odd that it doesn't seem to have a "sister room."

I'll mull it over but it's definitely piqued my interest
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,099
Hmm, good point. I suppose that could be the vanilla room if "fates" = "roles." I do find it odd that it doesn't seem to have a "sister room."
Seems specific.

Fates could change could be giving PRs out. Maybe any Vanilla's in play gets a PR? Maybe everyone gets a new PR on top of any current PRs?

Just a few thoughts.
 

turmoil7

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,833
WSD is giving me CoolestSpot in Berserk vives, playing the dumb noob role very well then turns out he was a framer or something and fucked us bad.

(Berserk was Coolest and mine's first game, he framed one of our cops the first night when the second cop checked on it, we lynched the first cop and next day the second one :x)
Since I am having a Berserk PSTD episode rn, I will mention that Zipped isn't inspiring confidence to me, don't know, he usually is more sharp than this, I have to read him carefully later and make a read
 

B-Dubs

The Mad Titan
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
12,922
(since normally people tend to ask for spec after being killed I mean and getting it quickly)
Last time I got NKed in a game I didn't find out until start of the day.

If my guess is right then it'd be a good room to pick considering we have to do two lynches today.
 

Kitsunelaine

My favorite cake is pie
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
4,381
I'm not sure about what room I want since D3 isn't early game anymore. I wanted to get the red room out of the way early because it sounded like the worst but I don't know if I still want it since this is what the other "wall" room does
 
Oct 25, 2017
5,099
Last time I got NKed in a game I didn't find out until start of the day.

If my guess is right then it'd be a good room to pick considering we have to do two lynches today.
hmm.

but then wouldn't that cause both people to be revived? People who's flip won't be revealed until the end of the day.

Seems like a big risk actually if it is revive based.

But that seems so unlikely to me that we shouldn't consider it... maybe.
 

Hecht

Stuck in the Thanus 🔨
Administrator
Oct 24, 2017
4,412
hmm.

but then wouldn't that cause both people to be revived? People who's flip won't be revealed until the end of the day.

Seems like a big risk actually if it is revive based.

But that seems so unlikely to me that we shouldn't consider it... maybe.
I think he's talking about people killed during the night, not today's lynch
 

weemadarthur

Community Resettler
Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,524
Right, it might even give us info
Or, Hecht/his teammate gets powered up and they’re trying to bribe town into it with sowing seeds of a revive.
Hecht has done nothing in this whole game that wasn’t centered on self preservation and i’m saying he isn’t town.

Mind you he could be a neutral, i can’t tell scum from neutral necessarily, but i’m certainly going to the blue room because he “finds it intriguing”.