-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
The Mansion Mafia - Hold on tightly to your secrets
- Thread starter Brazil
- Start date
I don't take any accusations personally other than I may think you all are idiots.
I would send Splinter money but I'm still sure he's a moron
all right, I'm gonna head off for a bit. I may check in cause I have problems, but I'm gonna leave my vote on Z-Beat, and I'm not gonna fight the bullshit against my claim of getting shot on N1. That happened. If you don't believe me, then fine - lynch me. Once I flip then go after those people. I gave my reads for now and you can do whatever with them, but I won't be changing my story at this point.
ps3udo 8)
ps3udo 8)
saenima
But seriously, your posts are not gonna age well when I flip town. But I won't accuse you of being scum because the one thing I've learned is that they aren't being so overt in getting people to vote for someone, like you're doing.
For whatever's worth, i found less that i thought i'd find. And after reading your exchanges with Hecht i'm inclined to believe only one of you is scum, if any.
If you happen to flip town and eyes then turn on me, so be it.
Hecht's defense hinges on several leaps.
- that we believe his BP claim.
- that we then believe his revised BP claim.
- that we believe his gambit makes any sense.
- that we believe he was shot N1.
- that there is a strongman who killed GF.
Am i missing anything?
Because that's already a lot of faith required there.
- that we believe his BP claim.
- that we then believe his revised BP claim.
- that we believe his gambit makes any sense.
- that we believe he was shot N1.
- that there is a strongman who killed GF.
Am i missing anything?
Because that's already a lot of faith required there.
you're missing the fact that he doesn't think scum would believe his claim at all
Hear this
This is shockingly similar to my PM, conciseness, wording, what it says, I don't want to go into details because CnP role pms is against the rules and comparing PMs via extreme paraphrasing feels unfair
1/2 are the same thing
3 I don't care
4 that happened
5 find me evidence that GF was shot before that
that's not much faith past anything like "i saw saenima visit kistune on N1"
Right but it would undermine your entire play because the only point of doing something like this would be
1)Hunt for scum (if scum don't believe you why would they engage in ways that would rouse suspicion from such an obvious ploy, and how would you even be able to distinguish between scum and town questioning you when you're doing something that on it's face made no sense at the time)
2)Try to make scum waste a SK on you (which wouldn't work if they didn't believe you)
3)?????????
You do not have an obvious goal with this, or any goal that seems reasonable to align with any of your stated motives.
i'm saying "I want to know what you actually wanted because I don't believe you for a second"
I want town to win. I gave the information I had. I assumed town would then look at the interactions between players and myself. Apparently I was mistaken.
But what kind of interactions were you expecting that would be distinguishable from any other interaction? What would make them stand out from town probing for example?
I don't get it. I think no one does.
The thing is, Town can't believe you until the flip, and when you flip that's when we can start properly looking into that. And you claimed when you didn't need to, during a very chaotic.... ....*gestures at everything*... ...So of course, town wouldn't have the bandwidth to process any of that data. It'd have been better if you hadn't claimed. You've given so many different reasons at this point as to the purpose of your claim.
If they die, then they are likely scum anyways (unless they are a town that's bluffing about having any sort of protection), and if they live, then they are telling the truth and we won't have the lynch wasted on them.
Would that be to much of a waste of a vig shot/Hecht block?
Would that be to much of a waste of a vig shot/Hecht block?
Yes, that's true.
But I claimed at a moment when we didn't have a lot of information. No NK, the best we had was a Grizz flip. Whatever you want to do with that, then go with it.
Please just end this torment
That's not what's happening. We're in the position of needing to confirm that you got shot. Which is confirmation that you can't give us.
"I checked Devious, he's scum"
"oh shit a cop, better lynch him to make sure"
I can't vote Devious today and I also can't vote for you today
I'd rather not hinge our play on the nature of the rooms. that's a good way of getting blindsided
Turmoils role claim I took as definite when he made it, because godfather claimed watcher.
Then godf wasn't countered but flipped self watcher only.
So a sleepwalker is odd as a negative to a self watcher, but not inevitable. Just due to the likelihood that it will never set the one off, is why I say that.
But devious' claim seems less plausible....but not in a coached by scum team way, more in a "has no idea what roles can be and is on his own" way.
Then godf wasn't countered but flipped self watcher only.
So a sleepwalker is odd as a negative to a self watcher, but not inevitable. Just due to the likelihood that it will never set the one off, is why I say that.
But devious' claim seems less plausible....but not in a coached by scum team way, more in a "has no idea what roles can be and is on his own" way.
Well yes, the point isn't to use it now, the point is that it might still add protection.
And the ....yellow room? Or was it green. The one that says "also protect".
Could be lots of miscellaneous protections.
I reread muffin and don't see anything particularly bad in the past day phase and a half except maybe a tendency to believe anything anyone says, but i'm backing off my old read of him.