• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Gay Bowser

Member
Oct 30, 2017
17,650
There are tons of games out there, so it's really not hard for me to avoid supporting a given studio. They sell entertainment products in a crowded marked.

I was sort of looking forward to playing Darksiders on my Switch in a month, but whatevs. Saves me money.
 

Error 52

Banned
Nov 1, 2017
2,032
fk3vqzospjvp.png


And if you thought there's nothing worse than lolicon


GjX75aG.png
Apparently 8chan really trying to attract Ian Watkins to their site
 

Gotdatmoney

Member
Oct 28, 2017
14,487
You can not dismiss this is ignorance. There is no legitimate reason to believe otherwise. The were greeted with "Heil Hitler", posted under banners advertising child porn anime, and consistently interacted with posters throwing around biggoted language.

You cannot say 'they didn't know beforehand' as an excuse for their behavior because they it was plastered everywhere as soon as they got there AND THEY REMAINED. You cannot say this is one person's fault because multiple people were in on it, including the upper echelon board members.

Labeling this as mere idiocy completely diminishes the the ongoing malicious bigotry they were conversing with and deplorable imagery they were surrounded by. That's not idiocy, that's contentment with malfeasance.

Stop. Defending. This. Behavior.

Stop. Dismissing. This. Incident.

Oh he knows. He just wants to defend it
 

Kyougar

Cute Animal Whisperer
Member
Nov 3, 2017
9,354
That's not really true, every site I've looked at has at least one article about the situation.

I said "lackluster response", not "nothing"

When your bar is several articles defending shit a gaming company does or decide to do, or several articles defending anti-consumer practices
and then one soft article on a gaming company doing an AMA on a site banned by google,

"Lackluster" is the most neutral you could say.
 

Tahnit

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,965
Something needs to be done. We need to get ahold of Nickelodeon and other brands that use THQ Nordic. They can't just stay silent about this.
 

Baji Boxer

Chicken Chaser
Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,376
How gullible I am? Not nearly as much a you are mad about it. So what now? You'll gonna rally in streets bacause of some AMA? You have too much spare time?
Associating with pedophiles and hardcore racists is going to upset some people. You might think that stuff is perfectly fine, but expecting people to calmly move on from it is pretty unrealistic.
 

Castform

Banned
Jan 10, 2018
952
Florida, United States
15 people signed my petition calling for THQ to properly investigate: https://www.change.org/p/thq-nordic...-should-take-firm-action-after-8chan-incident

Their CEO told GI.biz the issue is done, which I think is bonkers for a 1000+ employee division of a big company presenting itself on a child porn site but hey.

They've gotten the devotion of the 8channers. As such, they can expect that anyone criticizing THQ will be met with harassment campaigns in the future. So they've gotten what they've wanted and this was all very much desired. Heck, they probably had a lower price to pay than they expected.
 
Oct 27, 2017
2,053
So THQN is currently with their head deep in the sand, the CEO considers that lame Twitter apology enough and they're just waiting for all of this to blow over.

7Dmw.gif


Great.

I would like to see the media push their business partners then for a reaction. They can't just get away with this scot free.

They will. Era won't even ban promotion of their products. They aren't just getting away scot-free, they're getting away with having made huge inroads into the alt right market. They win from this scenario because nobody is holding them to task and punishing their behavior. Shameful.

This is the worst look I've ever seen for this forum and I think I'm going to take a long, long voluntary break from coming here. If we can't say real abusive child harm is enough.... Then i don't even know man
 
Oct 30, 2017
636
Canada
I'm quite late to the party, but popcorn.gif. Who the sweet fuck at THQ thought this would be a good idea? Who doesn't source their interviewer/ panel? I've never been interviewed by a white supremecist, racist or the like and that's not some immense achievement when it takes 2s to Google. This isn't just shortsighted it's intentionally obtuse.
 

Deleted member 41931

User requested account closure
Member
Apr 10, 2018
3,744
Why the hell did they even bother with 8chan? Use Reddit like a normal person.
Purely speculation. Phillipp and Fabian seem to very familair with 8chan's "culture" and are likely regulars on the site. One of them probably mentioned they work for THQN and "Mark" approached them asking if they wanted to do an AMA. For some reason they agreed, probably knowing that the higher up individuals like Reinhard and the CEO are at the very least apathetic towards what goes on at 8chan.
 

devSin

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,194
This is a very murky subject. I don't think some of you are prepared for how far down this rabbit hole goes, if you are indeed serious about following through with boycotts and 'this game is related to a company that supports pedophilia' tags. I would expect consistency if that is the road you all would like to travel.
You keep pushing this slippery-slope nonsense. "Won't anybody think of the games?" you cry.

THQ Nordic GmbH knowingly engaged with and participated in a site that traffics in homophobia, white supremacy, and child pornography. Any action would apply to the games they publish. Yes, that includes development studios they've purchased in addition to contracted games because they're the publisher.

THQ Nordic GmbH doesn't own Koch Media. There would be no reason to take any action regarding their games, because they're not involved.

The only murkiness here is from your repeated attempts at obfuscation.
 

Icemonk191

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
3,814
The fact that I've seen more condemnation for Athem's load times than for something like this says a lot about the current state of games media.
 

Famassu

Member
Oct 27, 2017
9,186
I'd like to know where we draw the line as far as entering related threads and posting 'disclaimers' about how THQ endorses and promotes racism and child pornography:

1. Will any game published or developed by the following companies receive said disclaimer?
  1. Black Forest Games
  2. Bugbear Entertainment
  3. Experiment 101
  4. Foxglove Studios
  5. Grimlore Games
  6. HandyGames
  7. Mirage Game Studios
  8. Pieces Interactive
  9. Rainbow Studios
2. Will related companies receive said disclaimer?
  1. Deep Silver
    1. Including any game with the Sega or Atlus flag in Europe, as Deep Silver distributes all Sega & Atlus games in Europe
    2. Saints Row, Shenmue 3, Metro, etc.
  2. Anything published by Koch who is now wholly owned by THQ Nordic
    1. https://www.kochmedia.com/us/software
    2. KOCH MEDIA IS THE NUMBER ONE RETAIL DISTRIBUTOR OF DIGITAL MEDIA PRODUCTS IN EUROPE"
I feel like this blanket attack against any and all companies/games related to THQ Nordic will make this forum fairly unreadable. Are we REALLY going to attach a disclaimer to all Sega threads now? I just can't see how that will be a productive addition to this forum.

This is a very murky subject. I don't think some of you are prepared for how far down this rabbit hole goes, if you are indeed serious about following through with boycotts and 'this game is related to a company that supports pedophilia' tags. I would expect consistency if that is the road you all would like to travel.
Ah, yes, a horrible disclaimer in OPs a vast majority of ResetEra users who visit the thread will never read more than once, if even that. Such a massive sore to the eyes, such insurmountable obstacle to get through before getting to the free advertisement that are VGOT OPs & discussions about the game.

Won't someone think of all the developers who suffer from one short paragraph of red (?) disclaimer text.
 

Arttemis

The Fallen
Oct 28, 2017
6,195
Ah, yes, a horrible disclaimer in OPs a vast majority of ResetEra users who visit the thread will never read more than once, if even that. Such a massive sore to the eyes, such insurmountable obstacle to get through before getting to the free advertisement that are VGOT OPs & discussions about the game.

Won't someone think of all the developers who suffer for one short paragraph of red (?) disclaimer text.
Not to mention it's false. THQ Nordic GmbH, the company responsible for this garbage, is not THQ Noridc AB. GmbH is its subsidiary.
 

deepFlaw

Knights of Favonius World Tour '21
Member
Oct 25, 2017
23,493
I keep getting pinged about this thread. I think Nathan did a fine job. Not sure how anyone can read his opening few paragraphs and think he was being soft on THQ Nordic. I'm not going to get into any arguments about the content of an article I didn't write or edit (I was recording and editing a podcast when this entire thing went down), but I will explain that we didn't use "THQ Nordic" in the headline because very few people know what "THQ Nordic" is. That was a pretty clear cut decision, one we usually make when a story is interesting but our readers would mostly be unfamiliar with the party involved.

Others have covered it, but: I think largely the issue is the end, for me? It drops the apologies there without much comment on them or really discussing who was actively involved. I was surprised people were hard on the article when I read it today, but then got to the end and understood.

Should be said that it's not like I think Nathan, of all people, finds this ok or anything. And I appreciate that it does at least include their AMA comments before that, which is more than some other outlets (including mainstream press). But it sorta just... ends, without discussing the apology in the context of those comments, and how easily it's torn apart due to that.
 

Watchtower

Member
Oct 27, 2017
11,636
I keep getting pinged about this thread. I think Nathan did a fine job. Not sure how anyone can read his opening few paragraphs and think he was being soft on THQ Nordic. I'm not going to get into any arguments about the content of an article I didn't write or edit (I was recording and editing a podcast when this entire thing went down), but I will explain that we didn't use "THQ Nordic" in the headline because very few people know what "THQ Nordic" is. That was a pretty clear cut decision, one we usually make when a story is interesting but our readers would mostly be unfamiliar with the party involved.
Can't speak for others but the issues I personally have with the article are, mainly:
- No mention of the THQ representatives' joking responses to presented with homophobic and pedophilia-related images and memes. Indeed, no mention of the latter's presence at all.
- No mention of the overwhelming proof invalidating THQ's claim of it being a fuckup by a single PR person out of ignorance, like evidence that multiple people, including higher ups at THQ, were involved in the AMA, and the very tweet announcing the AMA being obviously aware of the controversy that it would spark.
- Implied acceptance of THQ's apology as sincere, as a result of both of the above lapses in providing the full picture, and the article ending right after presenting the apology with zero additional commentary.
- I'm also not buying the "nobody knows who THQ is and that's why we put 'video game publisher' in the title" excuse for one millisecond, sorry.

This is not what we've come to expect from Kotaku on these matters. It's not too late to update the article with the relevant information, but it's a really bad look when a thread by a fan in a message board is far more informative than an article on a dedicated professional videogame news site. To say I'm profoundly disappointed would be the understatement of the year.

Agreed entirely with Weltall's points here. And I'll add that the opening paragraphs do go soft on them. Treating it almost whimsically as "the mother of all fuck-ups" obfuscates clear evidence that they knew what they were doing and did it anyway. Even if you don't think they're deliberately courting controversy or promoting CP they still knowingly ran with this move and are casually shrugging along as if it never happened.

This especially coming from Kotaku of all sites is even more baffling. I thought they were supposed to be the ones with a spine?

Imagine if EA had done this. EA, one of the main pantomime villains in gaming, conducts an AMA on a website full of white supremacists that support and post child abuse and child porn. Gaming Youtubers everywhere would relentlessly swarm all over this like flies around a carcass, never willing to let go, because this is a legit goldmine. There would be material for weeks if not months, relentlessly and gleefully laughing at the company's expense for its association with child porn and loudly proclaiming it the worst PR disaster in living memory (most content creators and reports I imagine would gloss over the whole extreme homophobia and Nazism stuff). I can almost imagine the "EA ARE PAEDOS" video headlines and practically the whole of the gaming press going for the jugular with heavy hitting article after another. "After Anthem, EA drops to a whole new low!'

But since it's not EA or Activision but a smaller scale plucky publisher that so happens to have snapped up a whole bunch of formerly abandoned IPs that gamers remember and are fond of, the response has been as limp as a soggy rich tea biscuit left in a hot cuppa. Considering this is not some comparative "oopsie" where a single social media employee opts to be a bigot on Twitter but senior figures within the company making the active decision to happily play ball with some of the worst dregs the wretched corners of the internet have to offer and did not nope out after a nanosecond, is extraordinarily damning. In electing to give this story some of the most feeble coverage ever while sounding like they accept the bullshit apology as something genuine and said in good faith, the gaming press have failed spectacularly. In sounding as timid and feeble as they do, they are content with letting these guys off the hook. An all round trash fire.

The year may be young, but the magnitude of this fiasco is so damning and so great in multiple ways which go beyond the simple fact that there is almost certainly a pervasive corporate culture within THQ Nordic thinking it is worth courting child porn loving white supremacists, that I can't imagine this being topped as ResetEra's 2019 Fail of the Year. A travesty for the innocent employees and developers who had to watch in horror as their dipshit bosses went ahead with this stunt. A travesty for the gaming press in how reluctant it's been to rake THQ Nordic's asses over the coals for being chummy with regulars on a white supremacist child porn cesspool. A travesty for decent people as a whole with yet another likely confirmation that the company may get away with this relatively unscathed, but now protected by its own freshly recruited online brownshirts army.

I will legitimately lose my shit if at the end of the year this site votes for [insert another disappointing game similar to Fallout 76 or Anthem] as the Fail of the Year winner again when this shining jewel of shit is in the running.

And as for the CEO who would rather say and do nothing about this, your silence is more than enough to indicate tacit approval. To speculate that you're a coward would be way too charitable. To suggest you simply don't care would be way too kind. No, you flat out approve this shit given your sustained silence and without an ounce of moral integrity, would just rather it blows over. No reasonable CEO would stare at this raging fire, point to the guy holding the can of petrol and with suspicious burn marks all over him and be all "yeah what he said" and hope the inferno will quietly put itself out.

If I could give you a trophy for this I would. Agreed 100%.

The fact that I've seen more condemnation for Athem's load times than for something like this says a lot about the current state of games media.

This too. For God's sake gamers have some goddamn standards.
 

Skittles

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,257
Official Staff Communication
To address a few recurring points: We will not be banning games published by THQ Nordic and subsidiaries like Deep Silver. You are instead welcome to continue raising the issue in threads relevant to the publisher and its games. Disclaimers and boycotts as user driven initiatives are welcome as well.

As we have said before, issues like this should be talked about and should be aired in the open. There is not and will never be such a thing as a "partial ban" on a video game here.

Please do not throw around highly inflammatory accusations or insults at your fellow members. Thank you.
This is about what i've come to expect from this site at this point.
 
Oct 25, 2017
275
So been looking this list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_THQ_Nordic_games

I don't want to give these asshats any money by mistake, anyone know if the games marked distribution only are just for physical releases?

I wanted to pick up Pillars of Eternity 2 for xbox at some point, but I don't want a cent of my money going to THQ Nordic after this.

What's really upsetting as I've been waiting for a new TimeSpliters for years, and now these fools are in charge of the IP.
 

mattiewheels

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,107
Did that user who someone saw defending the AMA on twitter get nuked here? His profile page doesn't even exist anymore.
 

SantaC

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,763
I would expect it to take months for someone to get fired. I know of sexual assault cases where there were 2 months of investigation by lawyers while the accused was suspended before they were in the clear legally to fire them. I don't know of the Swedish laws specifically, but I imagine it's going to be a while, if they even want to fire him.
Swedish laws? The mistake was by the german division.
 

Runner

Member
Nov 1, 2017
2,698
every page has people "correcting" other users on how GMBH was at fault not AB when one of the involved parties is on the board of directors of AB
 

rras1994

Member
Nov 4, 2017
5,742
So been looking this list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_THQ_Nordic_games

I don't want to give these asshats any money by mistake, anyone know if the games marked distribution only are just for physical releases?

I wanted to pick up Pillars of Eternity 2 for xbox at some point, but I don't want a cent of my money going to THQ Nordic after this.

What's really upsetting as I've been waiting for a new TimeSpliters for years, and now these fools are in charge of the IP.
From a quick googling, it appears that THQ Nordic only published the physical release of Pillars of Eternity 2, it was Versus Evil who publish the digital version, so if you buy digital no money should go to THQ Nordic but others in this thread may know more so could confirm?
 

devSin

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,194
I don't want to give these asshats any money by mistake, anyone know if the games marked distribution only are just for physical releases?
That's typically the case.

I don't know for PoE2 specifically, as that has different publishers for the various platforms. It should list the publisher on the store page.

every page has people "correcting" other users on how GMBH was at fault not AB when one of the involved parties is on the board of directors of AB
AB is a holding company. It doesn't direct operations or do anything except dispense money.

The executive in question manages operations for GmbH. That's what he's responsible for.
 
Oct 25, 2017
275
From a quick googling, it appears that THQ Nordic only published the physical release of Pillars of Eternity 2, it was Versus Evil who publish the digital version, so if you buy digital no money should go to THQ Nordic but others in this thread may know more so could confirm?

Thanks, that's what it appeared to me too, but wanted to make sure. I hope other companies rethink working with them in the future, unless THQ's upper management is cleared out. Surprised how much MS partnered with them on that list.
 

Jom

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,490
I initially thought, like everyone else here, that going on 8chan was an incredibly stupid idea, but after seeing how this has gone down from media, gamers, and this site even, I don't really think so anymore.

This whole thing will have resulted in a net positive for THQ Nordic and all it took was some crocodile tears and some quick deletes of tweets. Nobody is going to see any punishment or repercussions of any sort from all this. It's a pretty sad state of affairs.

The cynic in me is wondering if PR is actually going to start looking at these tactics as a legitimate way to get huge attention for their product with little to no downside.
 

wrowa

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,372
So been looking this list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_THQ_Nordic_games

I don't want to give these asshats any money by mistake, anyone know if the games marked distribution only are just for physical releases?

I wanted to pick up Pillars of Eternity 2 for xbox at some point, but I don't want a cent of my money going to THQ Nordic after this.

What's really upsetting as I've been waiting for a new TimeSpliters for years, and now these fools are in charge of the IP.

Koch usually does both distribution and marketing.

Swedish laws? The mistake was by the german division.
Austrian, actually.
 

Deleted member 1849

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,986
every page has people "correcting" other users on how GMBH was at fault not AB when one of the involved parties is on the board of directors of AB
Yep, and I'll continue to correct those people.

For complete accuracy though: He is part of their management, with his job title being "Director of business and production development". He is also a fairly big shareholder, owning 115,681 class A shares and 655,524 class B shares in THQ Nordic AB

However, he is not technically listed as one of their board members. He is still on their list of management figures though, under their list of senior executives: http://www.thqnordic-investors.com/en/board-and-management/
 
Oct 30, 2017
3,147
So been looking this list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_THQ_Nordic_games

I don't want to give these asshats any money by mistake, anyone know if the games marked distribution only are just for physical releases?

I wanted to pick up Pillars of Eternity 2 for xbox at some point, but I don't want a cent of my money going to THQ Nordic after this.

What's really upsetting as I've been waiting for a new TimeSpliters for years, and now these fools are in charge of the IP.
Here you go. You'll also want to boycott anything made by Sega.

1. Will any game published or developed by the following companies receive said disclaimer?
  1. Black Forest Games
  2. Bugbear Entertainment
  3. Experiment 101
  4. Foxglove Studios
  5. Grimlore Games
  6. HandyGames
  7. Mirage Game Studios
  8. Pieces Interactive
  9. Rainbow Studios
2. Will related companies receive said disclaimer?
  1. Deep Silver
    1. Including any game with the Sega or Atlus flag in Europe, as Deep Silver distributes all Sega & Atlus games in Europe
    2. Saints Row, Shenmue 3, Metro, etc.
  2. Anything published by Koch who is now wholly owned by THQ Nordic
    1. https://www.kochmedia.com/us/software
    2. KOCH MEDIA IS THE NUMBER ONE RETAIL DISTRIBUTOR OF DIGIT

You're going to have a pretty slow year of gaming. Deep Silver publishes all Sega games in Europe. It seems Sega is now guilty by association.
 

Deleted member 36578

Dec 21, 2017
26,561
Yep, and I'll continue to correct those people.

For complete accuracy though: He is part of their management, with his job title being "Director of business and production development". He is also a fairly big shareholder, owning 115,681 class A shares and 655,524 class B shares in THQ Nordic AB

However, he is not technically listed as one of their board members. He is still on their list of management figures though: http://www.thqnordic-investors.com/en/board-and-management/

You're probably the best person to ask this to, so ultimately, who are the people to blame for this debacle? And are they people that can simply be fired or are they too important to the company to let go?
 

Rosenkrantz

Member
Jan 17, 2018
4,917
So, THQ just went radio silent and it seems there's not much pressure on them besides an article in WaPo. Imagine if shit like that happened in any other industry or even to big guys like Activision or EA, they would be roasted by the media and their corpse would be mutilated by a cheering crowd. Apparently mid-size publishers aren't worthy of the time to thoroughly examine their fuck ups, more importantly, people who can actually put a pressure on THQ (MS, Sony, Valve, Epic etc.) should take a stance on this matter.
 

Deleted member 36578

Dec 21, 2017
26,561
I initially thought, like everyone else here, that going on 8chan was an incredibly stupid idea, but after seeing how this has gone down from media, gamers, and this site even, I don't really think so anymore.

This whole thing will have resulted in a net positive for THQ Nordic and all it took was some crocodile tears and some quick deletes of tweets. Nobody is going to see any punishment or repercussions of any sort from all this. It's a pretty sad state of affairs.

The cynic in me is wondering if PR is actually going to start looking at these tactics as a legitimate way to get huge attention for their product with little to no downside.

What do you think they gained anyway? Just that their name is on everyone's tongue? That's meaningless when it doesn't seem like they were promoting a specific game.
 

SantaC

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,763
That's typically the case.

I don't know for PoE2 specifically, as that has different publishers for the various platforms. It should list the publisher on the store page.

AB is a holding company. It doesn't direct operations or do anything except dispense money.

The executive in question manages operations for GmbH. That's what he's responsible for.
Phillip and Reinhard were the ones who hold the AMA, if they had any common sense they wouldnt do this. It is their fuckup.
 

Aeana

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,922
Here you go. You'll also want to boycott anything made by Sega.



You're going to have a pretty slow year of gaming. Deep Silver publishes all Sega games in Europe. It seems Sega is now guilty by association.
Why are you so concerned with finding gotchas and testing people's resolve? If THQ Nordic actually takes appropriate action, there would not be any reason to boycott or disclaim their games at all.
 

Jom

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,490
What do you think they gained anyway? Just that their name is on everyone's tongue? That's meaningless when it doesn't seem like they were promoting a specific game.
As someone else has stated above in this thread, the majority of people will chalk this up to a mistake and continue buying their games, while the alt right and gg crowd (which is not a small portion of the gaming community) will now go out of their way to support games by thq nordic.

No publicity is bad publicity. There have undoubtedly been many people who have now searched thq nordic and now know what games they publish and will be publishing. That kind of publicity is valuable.