This one's great, I like it!
New Game + is perfect.
It says everything. It acknowledges the past, whilst striding boldly into the future.
Oh fuck, THAT'S SO GOOD ON SO MANY LEVELS
Same. Sounds good right now, but I don't see it sticking a year or 2 from now.I am a fan of New Game + but I don't think it's something that can last over the years.
I really don't think we need one that references video games or that this is a legacy site. Something inclusive, and something that isn't an established 'in-joke' would be ideal.
This is the one. Put this under the ResetEra logo and call it a day.