• Introducing Image Options for ResetEra 2.0! Check the left side navigation bar to show or hide images, avatars, covers, and embedded media. More details at the link.
  • Community Spotlight sign-ups are open once again for both Gaming and EtcetEra Hangout threads! If you want to shine a spotlight on your community, please register now.

What's your go to peanut butter?

Oct 26, 2017
I've tried all the organic and natural stuff. But honestly, I keep coming back to the Skippy's Creamy. It has my favorite taste and texture. Some childhood habits die hard.

Sometimes I rotate the chunky version of the same brand. Yeah, I know it's bad for you and it has all those terrible hydrogenated oils, but hey, I don't have many vices lol. And no need to stir the separated oil and all that nonsense.

What about you?
Nov 24, 2017
I buy bulk salted roasted peanuts at the grocery store and grind them into peanut butter using my food processor. Helps me avoid PBs that have added sugars or palm oil.
Oct 27, 2017
Kraft or Jif. Both are great IMO. Currently have Kraft in the cupboard. My jam lately is a small spoonful in instant oatmeal. Try it, it's good.
Oct 26, 2017
all y'all are disgusting. Get some class with your peanut butter.

Homeplate is wonderful. Same with Justin's

Look it this fancypants with Justin's ;P

I've tried their almond butter. It's good but it's crazy expensive! I think it was 8 bucks or something.

I don't know if that was seasonal pricing since there was California drought affecting almond prices. Almonds are a high water crop.

I haven't tried Homeplate, but man, that is pretty ass packaging.
Oct 27, 2017
Typically just the store brand, creamy. I have low standards. I enjoyed the (store brand) natural creamy peanut butter I picked up one time, though. I'll probably get it again the next time I run out.
Oct 29, 2017
That’s peanut butter in Canada right?
This is available in Canada, yup. All sorts of other varieties are available of course, but I just love the creamy texture and easy spredability of this stuff. I know it's less actual peanut butter than the normal stuff, but since I don't buy PB much I don't really care.
Dec 10, 2017

I've tried healthier organic alternatives like Whole Earth, and this has palm oil with no mention of sustainability, but nothing I've tried tastes anywhere near as good, sadly.
Oct 27, 2017
The myprotein crunchy peanut butter:

As opposed to their protein powders it's actually very good (better than most of those fancy peanut butters in glass jars you can buy here). It's also cheap for a 100% 🥜 peanut butter.

I've got like 10kg of it on my shelf.
Oct 27, 2017
Smucker's Chunky. For some reason the creamy version of Smucker's has more salt and it's a bit too salty for me.

There's also this

Which is delicious. It's just peanuts, chocolate, vanilla, and salt. It's hard to find in stores but I definitely snatch it up when I can find it.

and on a related note, I picked up a peanut butter stirrer/hand crank at my supermarket for $4. It's pretty great. This is the one;

I can't eat PB that has added oils and sugar. The texture is waxy and gross
Oct 25, 2017
Adam's Crunchy. Mix it really good when I open it and have to mix each time to make sure it doesnt separate a lot, but there is nothing in it but peanuts and salt. Decent consistency and good flavor. Plus the price is good.

Skippy Natural Super Chunk is my back up. Adds a lot more to it, but it tastes pretty good.