I’m on Skippy Creamy right now. But that’s because Costco had two packs for cheap. I like jif natural or jif regular as well. Anything will work as long as it’s the creamy kind and I have strawberry jelly.
Used to be Trader Joe's creamy but since moving to Canada Kraft all-natural with sea salt is our go-to. You do have to stir in the oil but it doesn't get all hard and unspreadable halfway through the jar somehow. Good stuff.
The honey variety (pictured earlier in the thread) is too sweet for me to use as my go-to, but it's okay occasionally.
While Skippy Natural Creamy is my standard go-to, I love trying new kinds of PB or offshoots like hazelnut or other nut spreads
All that said, I strongly feel like there's diminishing returns when it comes to expensive or high-concept PB. Skippy gets it right without breaking the bank.
If you don't believe me, just take a look at some PB blind taste tests. The more expensive ones tend to get rated a lot lower in blind tests, but tend to get rated higher in reviews... funny isn't it 😂