I’m on Skippy Creamy right now. But that’s because Costco had two packs for cheap. I like jif natural or jif regular as well. Anything will work as long as it’s the creamy kind and I have strawberry jelly.
Used to be Trader Joe's creamy but since moving to Canada Kraft all-natural with sea salt is our go-to. You do have to stir in the oil but it doesn't get all hard and unspreadable halfway through the jar somehow. Good stuff.