-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Which Disney Movie has the better Vocal Songs - Frozen or Moana?
- Thread starter TheGamingNewsGuy
- Start date
Couldn't agree more. Love Shiny. It's still on my regular cycling playlist.Moana. Frozen is a piece of shit movie, and Let it Go is awful.
Also this song was the best:
Jemaine Clement - Shiny (from Moana) (Official Video)
"Shiny" from Disney's MoanaPerformed by: Jemaine ClementDownload/stream the Moana soundtrack here: http://disneymusic.co/MVOSndtrkWS?iqid=dmvevo.moanaStream ...www.youtube.com
For some reason that song reminds me a lot of Redbone by Childish Gambino.
Moana. Lin-Manuel Miranda came up with some of the best and most memorable Disney songs in decades.
Frozen has the more memorable and catchy songs as an overall whole. Moana has the better quality tracks.
That's kinda what Let It Go was written as, but they got rid of that angle in rewrites while leaving the song untouched.
Shiny alone makes the Moana soundtrack better. My daughter came in at the tail end of Frozen and Moana was the first Disney movie I took her to so I might be biased but the soundtrack is so much better.
I'm getting the impression that people mostly like "Shiny" because of Bowie. Would people like it as much if there wasn't any association with a famous personality and it had to stand on it's own within the context of the movie?
He spent thousands of years perfecting that verse and couldn't WAIT.
No lies detected. Not sure if it's just me but I feel like Princess and the Frog is super underrated. "Almost There" and "Friends on the Otherside" are among my favorite Disney songs period.
Moana was the first kid movie that my daughter was into enough to mostly watch all the way through, and half the songs in it still make me tear up. It's one of my favorite movies.
Moana has more songs that are also good but none of them are better than "Let it Go"
It's a Push.
It's a Push.
No, that's just a bonus. The song stands on its own. It's out there for sure, but it works within the context and confines of the film. A narcissistic crab living in the realm of the monsters is gonna sing something weird.
Never understood the hype for frozen and "let it go" specifically. Personally "do you want to build a snowman?", "Summer", and the intro song are all superior to it.
Moana and CoCo are both vastly superior to Frozen IMO and Moana has the GOAT soundtrack.
Moana and CoCo are both vastly superior to Frozen IMO and Moana has the GOAT soundtrack.
I know there's really no main villain in Moana given the nature of the story so this may seem like an unfair comparison, but would you say that "Shiny" is up there with "Kill the Beast" or "Be Prepared"?
Last edited:
Moana's songs are all so self-affirming, Frozen got some of the way there but Moana goes Whole Hog and I love it, it's so powerful. My three year old daughter is always singing them and I love that Disney flicks have gotten to this point in time for her to grow up with them. None of these stories about princesses pining for princes, just an amazing role model trying to find her place and her self that I'd love if she tried to emulate.
My cousin works at Disney and she told me once that they were right on the edge of cutting the entire sequence because focus groups hated it across the board. As in, almost all feedback for the movie was some form of "I loved the movie, but what was up with that crab?"
I love it though, so hearing this actually shocked me. Best part of the movie aside from the climax IMO. It is a huge tonal shift though so I do kind of get it.
Frozen's song doesn't fit the story.
Moana is better.
I'll say Coco with remember me wins the disney 3d world personally.
Moana is better.
I'll say Coco with remember me wins the disney 3d world personally.
Moana is so good. I've gotta throw out a mention to "I am Moana/Song of the Ancestors"; the way the emotion swells hits me every time.
For me personally, absolutely yes. It was a huge gamble and a win for me. And it did take me two viewings to see it. The first time I saw the movie I probably had the biggest "WTF was that?" expression on my face. I can totally understand how it's divisive.
Moana. Frozen is a piece of shit movie, and Let it Go is awful.
Also this song was the best:
Jemaine Clement - Shiny (from Moana) (Official Video)
"Shiny" from Disney's MoanaPerformed by: Jemaine ClementDownload/stream the Moana soundtrack here: http://disneymusic.co/MVOSndtrkWS?iqid=dmvevo.moanaStream ...
Hear hear!
I'm a non-disney watching layman and I've never heard a single song from Moana and I know half the lyrics to Let It Go and the snowman song.
Moana had the best Disney soundtrack since Lion King. True bangers.
Frozen is a bunch of cheesy kid shit.
Frozen is a bunch of cheesy kid shit.
Lol.
They're both Disney movies it's all cheesy kid shit.
Frozen is the like the Eminem of Disney flicks for Era members.
To a certain degree they are all cheesy kid shit, but with Moana, i feel some of the songs hit on a deeper level (How Far I'll Go, Where you Are, We know the Way) or are incredibly creative and catchy (Shiny, You're Welcome). You can feel Lin-Manuels elevated touch. Frozen songs feel like they were composed in a focus group.
Yup. Kinda weird. I remember enjoying the movie and thinking the water was amazing, but the songs never stuck with me.
