the thing about red dead, is as good looking as that game is, it doesnt have stuff as complex in models as, say the machines in horizon zero dawn.
it looks that good because it is the most grounded game ever. another issue i have with red dead is the blurryness. really bad.
which is why i will give my vote to horizon. because horizon does a lot more things while being very close to matching RDR2 in pure graphics comprison.
Blurry? Game is 2160p