• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

The Bear

Forest Animal
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
4,211
I don't think Grizzly or Faddy are making sense in their argument btw. Grizzly should know he is town, therefore he should vote for the alternative, claims be damned.

Faddy wanting to lynch a claim he doesn't believe isn't unreasonable either.

I was not going to lynch LP when he had claimed a protective role, something scum was not going to do since it would just bite them afterwards. If LP was scum, he would have claimed something else.

At that time, it would have made more sense for town to lynch me. But I wasn't going to self-vote, either.
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
I was not going to lynch LP when he had claimed a protective role, something scum was not going to do since it would just bite them afterwards. If LP was scum, he would have claimed something else.

At that time, it would have made more sense for town to lynch me. But I wasn't going to self-vote, either.

Town bear doesn't vote
Allows scum faddy to choose
Logic is bad here
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
If the haiku is a scum role, that does tell us that scum didn't attack Faddy last night, which is suspicious in itself.
I'm not sure what assumptions you're making here regarding the scum team's view of our town ensemble and what said scum team can do. Do you think any scum team without Faddy in it should want him dead before anyone else, after yesterday? Didn't you claim to be dosed last night, which was (presumably) the scum team's (only?) means of "attacking" last night? Maybe you can break down some of those thoughts for me, maybe I'm reading too much into this.

That's lame if his wincon isn't connected to the Haikus, and it feels bad to just make it "Survive, having made 3 people do haikus" or something.
 

The Bear

Forest Animal
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
4,211
Town bear doesn't vote
Allows scum faddy to choose
Logic is bad here

I mean, the options for me were:

1. Most likely town protective role
2. Myself

---

As for that idea about framing, I'm not going to even entertain that thought. My thought was hopefully shared with any member of town with some brain cells.
 

*Splinter

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,089
I'm not sure what assumptions you're making here regarding the scum team's view of our town ensemble and what said scum team can do. Do you think any scum team without Faddy in it should want him dead before anyone else, after yesterday? Didn't you claim to be dosed last night, which was (presumably) the scum team's (only?) means of "attacking" last night? Maybe you can break down some of those thoughts for me, maybe I'm reading too much into this.


That's lame if his wincon isn't connected to the Haikus, and it feels bad to just make it "Survive, having made 3 people do haikus" or something.
Faddy has more control of the game than anyone, if I were scum he'd be dead by now.

They probably did see my breadcrumb though, it wasn't exactly subtle.

Haiku survivor is lame? Sure but it wouldn't be the first time we've seen one would it?
 

The Bear

Forest Animal
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
4,211
But regardless, if you are scum reading me Faddy, why aren't you voting for me? Like Fire said, it would be good for everyone to put at least their initial votes down.
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
Didn't believe Lone
Claim was so late, badly done
lacked credibility
I know what your reasons are. You don't think scum LP would have fake claimed something not as unlikely as a second protective role? I agree he played badly, but I see where Grizz is coming from.

Also, I thought that post of yours I quoted was sort of written from Bear's "Faddy is scum" perspective, to which your reply doesn't follow.
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
*Splinter , who would you vote for rn between Faddy and Grizzly?

I think I'd vote for Faddy, myself. Also, isn't your Oliver vote very outdated? You pretty much have no vote down atm.
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
I know what your reasons are. You don't think scum LP would have fake claimed something not as unlikely as a second protective role? I agree he played badly, but I see where Grizz is coming from.

Also, I thought that post of yours I quoted was sort of written from Bear's "Faddy is scum" perspective, to which your reply doesn't follow.

If Bear likes LP
And thinks I am scum Faddy
Why let me control?
 

The Bear

Forest Animal
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
4,211
You're acting like I had all the time in the world to make my decision of letting you "control". Those moments did not last for very long.
 

DCPat

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,170
Grizzly, you are giving Faddy slack for his D2 end. What did you want Faddy to do?

Without help from you he couldn't go further than a tie? He had to vote for a third player? Who?
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
You're acting like I had all the time in the world to make my decision of letting you "control". Those moments did not last for very long.

No time for me too
Here are last few minutes lol
See my thoughts make sense

I hope town is stacked because we'll be down another PR tonight.

Full claim now

UNVOTE

LP claims PR
I unvote to stop hammer
ask him for his claim

If scum I know real
Why even unvote like that
Being a good town

FULL claim, no dribbling it out

Kevin Costner and Whitney Houston.

I'm sure that means something to someone.

LP is dumb here
No time to act fancy lol
Kalor watch movies!!

Who did you protect night 1 LP

I didn't move last night.

Two protective roles makes the possibility of a second killer more likely.

L_P flubs night 1
Makes up two killers, ok
Looks scummy to me

No it wasn't. Ty's role says Once per night.

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

Kalor misreads Ty
Minutes to deadline I choose
L_P is my scum
 

Kalor

Resettlement Advisor
Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,671
I'm oddly split on Faddy and Grizzly. I was confident about Grizzly yesterday but I've started to doubt that over the night. Faddys move yesterday is questionable but I felt good about them prior to that.

We'll see how the day goes but I don't want to see FEP in the end game with how much they're posting. It helps that they're one of my scum picks.

Vote: flatearthpandas
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
Personally I'm now tempted to switch my vote to Faddy. It feels like a Grizz-Faddy showdown is the course of action we need to solve this game. I think FEP is a good lynch candidate, but I'm too afraid of a mislynch again and getting almost no info back.

I do want FEP to show up and take a stand, though.
 

DCPat

Member
Oct 28, 2017
1,170
I just recalculated btw. At first I thought he could make it 4-4, but missed LP vote.
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
Making it 5-4 on you so you could tie it at 5-5. You didn't vote yet.

For me I am between Grizzly, Terra and L_P. And that could be the mafia team.

I'm town on Splinter, DCPat, Fireblend, Oliver.
Probable towns are Coolest, FEP and if I believe Kalor, he goes here too.

Now who to actually lynch.

L_P can be with anyone. He hasn't put himself against anyone or argued strongly for anything. Perhaps you could say he is not with Coolest but that is a stretch from whats the votes are at the time. He hasn't offered any insight into the game or given any strong reads. He has put by far the least amount of information into the thread.

Right now I think Grizzly as a voting pattern read is looking for something that isn't there.

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

L_P, Bear both scum?
Bear not voting, big concern
Was in my mind too
 

Zippedpinhead

Fallen Guardian
Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,803
I think we should stop talking about the Haikus. It's still possible to post anything you want so it doesn't really matter who gets it. I agree with Fireblend we should focus on the lynch.

In hindsight, yesterday was a shitshow. We just eased into that mislynch.

I'm going to reread, but I can already say I do not want to lynch Kalor, OJ and Splinter. Feeling pretty good about Fireblend either.

I do not know how to handle Zipped as replacement of Coolest. Zipped could you maybe give us some thoughts on Coolest D1 & D2? I know he hasn't done much. But you probably have an opinion on it.

I think yesterday was a shit show as well. It's almost like really frustrating roll over. Coolest was decent day one, had good discussions but the whole thing with geno really shrugged me the wrong way. I still can't really follow why geno votes for coolestspot, and terraforce's vote seemed bandwagony but he never unvoted so that's something.

I'm wondering what happened with the votes day 1, it was geno/coolest/Kalor, and then it flipped to just geno/Kalor. Geno dies and then Kalor is no even considered for day 2. Day 1 doesn't mean much. It's frankly why I shitpost most day 1s. But the end of day matters, probably the only 2 hours that does.
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
Fireblend fast on Lone
Pushing for votes again today
Repeat winning strat?
Yet the day went for the entirety of the phase duration, with myself making 0 attempts to detract from other vote targets. The meta here makes it impossible to end a day early even when it'd be favorable for town, that wouldn't ever be my "scum strat". What I want now is people voting to show where their head's at and make that be traceable and retrievable through the vote count and vote tool links. Like I've been saying since yesterday. Right now the vote is between my strong scum read FEP and my leaning-scum, high-info read Faddy, so I'm happy content all things considered.
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
Yet the day went for the entirety of the phase duration, with myself making 0 attempts to detract from other vote targets. The meta here makes it impossible to end a day early even when it'd be favorable for town, that wouldn't ever be my "scum strat". What I want now is people voting to show where their head's at and make that be traceable and retrievable through the vote count and vote tool links. Like I've been saying since yesterday. Right now the vote is between my strong scum read FEP and my leaning-scum, high-info read Faddy, so I'm happy content all things considered.

high info faddy!
i will flip vanilla town
who are my scum mates?
 

Zippedpinhead

Fallen Guardian
Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,803
LP is dumb here
No time to act fancy lol
Kalor watch movies!
Kalor didn't get the bodygaurd reference? It looks like most only sorta got it. I mean it's not that big of a movie anymore, but it's worth a google. Would likely have saved a mislynch if all of us knew it. Unfortunate I wasn't here, movies are my jam!

I keep coming back to Kalor. But I'm not sure why? Is it post frequency, a read, or just he has incite everyone is talkin about?

Still new, working through everything. Thank you all for being patient
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
high info faddy!
i will flip vanilla town
who are my scum mates?
If you flip scum, then that's already a win but it will also mostly clear Grizzly, and make me town-read FEP a bit more. I'd probably go after Zipped next.
If you flip town, that makes my read of Grizzly shift to scum, and I'll also push towards a FEP lynch since he threw shade on you yesterday.

That sounds good to me.
 

Pedro

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
1,967
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

flatearthpandas (2 votes)
terraforce - #898
fireblend - #916 #974
kalor - #972

faddy (2 votes)
grizzly - #933
fireblend - #974

kalor (1 votes)
oliver james - #867

grizzly (1 votes)
*splinter - #970

oliver james (0 votes)
*splinter - #842 #969

Post Counts:
faddy: 41 *splinter: 29 grizzly: 26 oliver james: 24 fireblend: 22 kalor: 9 dcpat: 9 zippedpinhead: 6 terraforce: 2 sawneeks: 1

You can find the current vote count here

Majority is 6

Day 3 ends in

gra_1519074000.png
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
If you flip scum, then that's already a win but it will also mostly clear Grizzly, and make me town-read FEP a bit more. I'd probably go after Zipped next.
If you flip town, that makes my read of Grizzly shift to scum, and I'll also push towards a FEP lynch since he threw shade on you yesterday.

That sounds good to me.

Do you have a case
say why i am scum at least
info lynch now? weird.
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
Do you have a case
say why i am scum at least
info lynch now? weird.
I agree with Grizz that your late hammer request on LP made you look bad. I was also swayed in believing the curse giver is scum, something you yourself believe, unless I misread thatand this, and in that case I find it hard to believe they'd target 2 townies in a row. You've posted enough that I'm convinced you're a good player regardless of alignment. And you didn't refute my previous post so even you concede I'm onto something.
 

Faddy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,186
Vote: Faddy

Why are you scum?

You would think I would eventually roll scum, matter of probabilities but it hasn't happened yet.

TY are you town? Do you want to be in my town circle with Geno?

I agree with Grizz that your late hammer request on LP made you look bad. I was also swayed in believing the curse giver is scum, something you yourself believe, unless I misread thatand this, and in that case I find it hard to believe they'd target 2 townies in a row. You've posted enough that I'm convinced you're a good player regardless of alignment. And you didn't refute my previous post so even you concede I'm onto something.
 

Fireblend

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,454
Costa Rica
I don't have much to say other than that I find it funny that out of the reasons I gave for thinking you might be scum, the compliment was the one you went for :P
 
Status
Not open for further replies.