• Light/Dark

Heroes VS Villains Mafia - The Greatest Battle In History

Status
Not open for further replies.
*Splinter

*Splinter

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,104
nin said:
This Fandorin train sure smells
latest
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Why don't you like it nin?
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,356
Crimson said:
Looking over the least active posters.

Assuming Grizzly is inactive and will be replaced,

Lifeline has nothing but shitposts, vote included, and has already said they won't be around any more.

Lone_Prodigy hasn't really said much, don't really agree with his voting justification, but at least he has a vote with a reasoning

Tearablepuns seems evasive about voting, guess they might be around a bit more, but a couple of comments talking about how off something seems, but avoiding committing on a vote stood out.

Rynam doesn't appear to have said anything of value at all
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Crimson, will you keep your vote on me? You put it down way back then, anything to add to it?
 
*Splinter

*Splinter

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,104
Grizzly has gotten a stupid amount of mentions today. His absence is 100% NAI and as a player I trust him to show up or sub out.
 
Fran

Fran

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,167
*Splinter said:
Grizzly has gotten a stupid amount of mentions today. His absence is 100% NAI and as a player I trust him to show up or sub out.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

And the problem with that is....?

People are just saying that Grizzly is absent but I don't see anyone tunnelling him or wasting a vote there so I don't see the problem.
 
Include

Include

Member
Oct 25, 2017
836
Fandorin said:
I'll gladly vote for you, but I tried to push a wagon against you and it really didn't click, so I'll abstain for today and join one of the wagons, not leave my single vote on you and ignore the rest of the discussion today. I guess that's something you still haven't leaned, since Fran just called you out for leaving a nothing vote on Kalor till now.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

What push did you make?You mean your Freudian personality read from my first mafia game?

Unlike you I probed Kalor rightfully so and to which even he ended up admitting that his posts may have looked strange and while I have a scum lean on him I didn't dub him as my strongest most powerful scum read unlike you.

Ironically your argument against me fit perfectly the definition of a straw man argument hence why Vere's simple push back made you lay off of your strongest most suspicious read.

As it stands brazil only has Monkey vote and yours where is the wagon you speak of?

off-topic:
I just took pain killers for my wound, you better post quickly before I fall asleep
/off-topic
 
Brazil

Brazil

Actual Brazilian
Member
Oct 24, 2017
18,586
São Paulo, Brazil
*Splinter said:
Hold up

1. Brazil was saying the opposite (Brazil why didn't you correct this post?

2. I had three pages to catch up on, far from a quiet game.

3. Oh look the vote is shifting away from both Swifty and Nicole.

4. Regardless of all the above, it's way too early to be crying DADV.

Your extremely underhanded defense of Nicole and/or Swifty is duly noted.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I think her "now this I can get on board" was directed at the line of questioning itself, and not an agreement with my angle.

I think I only had one page of posts to read between going to bed last night and my first post today. It was a little quiet.
 
nin

nin

Asked Politely
Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
7,159
Verelios said:
Still, knowing she claimed PR you still want her off the island?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

The thing is , everyone can claim it and being in a pretty insane game i think means that almost everyone could have a role. i mean in HP it was the case, since this is more "insane than HP" i think yeah pr =/ Town
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

The Old Guard
Member
Oct 24, 2017
6,544
In the interests of shorting ourselves down to two trains, I will probably be changing my vote back to Silky shortly.

I'm fine with lynching either of the top two (Fandorian or Silky) today. I'd prefer Ryman, but there doesn't seem to be anyone else who wants to put him on the train other than Kalor despite the fact his only contributes was some role fishing and favor discussion.
 
nin

nin

Asked Politely
Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
7,159
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

fandorin
(5 votes)
crimson - #229
verelios - #471
dr. monkey - #492
#687
fran - #910
hecht - #926
include - #939

silky
(4 votes)
kalor - #96
#535
terraforce - #491
#567
*splinter - #497
sweetnicole - #510
#859
brazil - #767
stanleypalmtree - #808
muffin - #908

sweetnicole
(3 votes)
hecht - #94
#756
faircure - #526
#592
lifeline - #545
terraforce - #567
kitsunelaine - #584
hecht - #757
#912

brazil
(2 votes)
fandorin - #132
#423
terraforce - #329
#491
dr. monkey - #760
fandorin - #882
hecht - #912
#926

rynam
(2 votes)
terraforce - #194
#329
sorian - #220
#409
sweetnicole - #859
kalor - #868

muffin
(2 votes)
lone_prodigy - #582
sorian - #632
nin - #766
#790

kitsunelaine
(1 votes)
brazil - #246
#283
silky - #290

sorian
(0 votes)
crimson - #83
#229
sorian - #87
#220
silky - #99
#103
silky - #103
#188

*splinter
(0 votes)
verelios - #98
#471

dr. monkey
(0 votes)
grizzly - #119
#126

hecht
(0 votes)
muffin - #120
#427
faircure - #592
#769

terraforce
(0 votes)
rynam - #197
#426
dr. monkey - #687
#721

n/a
(0 votes)
kitsunelaine - #203
#584

lifeline
(0 votes)
sweetnicole - #266
#505

kalor
(0 votes)
include - #306
#939

nin1000
(0 votes)
sorian - #409
#434

grizzly
(0 votes)
fran - #415
#910
kalor - #535
#868

nin
(0 votes)
sorian - #434
#632

crimson
(0 votes)
lifeline - #527
#545

no lynch
(0 votes)
hecht - #756
#757

Post Counts:
fran: 71 sweetnicole: 71 sorian: 66 nin: 66 dr. monkey: 63 *splinter: 51 hecht: 49 terraforce: 48 fandorin: 47 kitsunelaine: 46brazil: 43 muffin: 41 silky: 36 kalor: 26 crimson: 25 faircure: 20 include: 17 stanleypalmtree: 16 verelios: 15 rynam: 12tearablepuns: 10 lone_prodigy: 9 grizzly: 6 geno: 5 lifeline: 5 retromg: 2



Total Accumulated Post Counts:

fran: 71 sweetnicole: 71 sorian: 66 nin: 66 dr. monkey: 63 *splinter: 51 hecht: 49 terraforce: 48 fandorin: 47 kitsunelaine: 46 brazil: 43 muffin: 41 silky: 36 kalor: 26 crimson: 25 faircure: 20 include: 17 stanleypalmtree: 16 verelios: 15 rynam: 12 tearablepuns: 10 lone_prodigy: 9 grizzly: 6 geno: 5 lifeline: 5
bla_1519765200.png
 
*Splinter

*Splinter

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,104
Fran said:
And the problem with that is....?

People are just saying that Grizzly is absent but I don't see anyone tunnelling him or wasting a vote there so I don't see the problem.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
A) it's pointless noise
B)
Dr. Monkey said:
I knew it was quite a few. Thanks for pulling that together.

I don't feel great voting Muffin today because I'm a softie. Grizzly's absence is NAI but if it keeps up I'd vote on principal. Fandorin I lean scum on so if I had to choose between those three it would be him, but it's a light lean.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
This one stood out to me as probably the worst.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Actual Brazilian
Member
Oct 24, 2017
18,586
São Paulo, Brazil
Silky admitted to role-fishing in a weirdly specific way, refuses to vote against anyone other than Kit despite scumreading Nicole, basically everyone has admitted to suspecting him at some point, and Fandorin is leading?

Nicole's frustration last night is WIFOM to me, but even that looks way worse than anything that's been said against Fandorin so far.
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,356
Include said:
What push did you make?You mean your Freudian personality read from my first mafia game?

Unlike you I probed Kalor rightfully so and to which even he ended up admitting that his posts may have looked strange and while I have a scum lean on him I didn't dub him as my strongest most powerful scum read unlike you.

Ironically your argument against me fit perfectly the definition of a straw man argument hence why Vere's simple push back made you lay off of your strongest most suspicious read.

As it stands brazil only has Monkey vote and yours where is the wagon you speak of?

off-topic:
I just took pain killers for my wound, you better post quickly before I fall asleep
/off-topic
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Sorry that I'm not willing to spend the entire phase tunneling on you. Vere didn't push me out of my read, since here I am still arguing with you. I made my point and no one joined in on it, most seem to town read you, so I won't keep pushing that angle since it's pointless today.

And yes, Brazil now has only 2 votes. I will probably change my vote now, but he was a topic at the time of my vote, reaching 4 votes along with me.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

The Old Guard
Member
Oct 24, 2017
6,544
nin said:
The thing is , everyone can claim it and being in a pretty insane game i think means that almost everyone could have a role. i mean in HP it was the case, since this is more "insane than HP" i think yeah pr =/ Town
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

I said this before, but I don't think this game is role madness. Bastard and role madness have different connotations. A game can be bastard but not role madness, role madness but not bastard, or both. IDK, maybe that's something can be clarified for the future.
 
nin

nin

Asked Politely
Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
7,159
SweetNicole said:
I said this before, but I don't think this game is role madness. Bastard and role madness have different connotations. A game can be bastard but not role madness, role madness but not bastard, or both. IDK, maybe that's something can be clarified for the future.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

thats the thing. i think otherwise :)
 
Fandorin

Fandorin

The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
2,356
I'll obviously vote for self preservation, so Silky might get my vote right now. Other than him, I see a Rynam wagon building up which I'm also willing. Wouldn't vote for Muffin and Nicole though.
 
Kalor

Kalor

Resettlement Advisor
Member
Oct 25, 2017
19,814
I was going to switch back to Silky eventually but may as well do it now, just so we have a better idea where the votes are at since the leading candidates are narrowing down.

Vote: Silky
 
*Splinter

*Splinter

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,104
I had forgotten about it until Include's recent post, but Fandorin's early read of her was really overdeveloped. Have you two played together before?
 
Brazil

Brazil

Actual Brazilian
Member
Oct 24, 2017
18,586
São Paulo, Brazil
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

sweetnicole (5 votes)
hecht - #94 #756
faircure - #526 #592
lifeline - #545
terraforce - #567
kitsunelaine - #584
hecht - #757 #912
hecht - #967
*splinter - #970

silky (3 votes)
kalor - #96 #535
terraforce - #491 #567
*splinter - #497 #970
sweetnicole - #510 #859
brazil - #767
stanleypalmtree - #808
muffin - #908

rynam (3 votes)
terraforce - #194 #329
sorian - #220 #409
sweetnicole - #859
kalor - #868
crimson - #965

fandorin (3 votes)
crimson - #229 #965
verelios - #471
dr. monkey - #492 #687
fran - #910
hecht - #926 #967
include - #939

brazil (2 votes)
fandorin - #132 #423
terraforce - #329 #491
dr. monkey - #760
fandorin - #882
hecht - #912 #926

muffin (2 votes)
lone_prodigy - #582
sorian - #632
nin - #766 #790

kitsunelaine (1 votes)
brazil - #246 #283
silky - #290

ryman (1 votes)
nin - #969

sorian (0 votes)
crimson - #83 #229
sorian - #87 #220
silky - #99 #103
silky - #103 #188

*splinter (0 votes)
verelios - #98 #471

dr. monkey (0 votes)
grizzly - #119 #126

hecht (0 votes)
muffin - #120 #427
faircure - #592 #769

terraforce (0 votes)
rynam - #197 #426
dr. monkey - #687 #721

n/a (0 votes)
kitsunelaine - #203 #584

lifeline (0 votes)
sweetnicole - #266 #505

kalor (0 votes)
include - #306 #939

nin1000 (0 votes)
sorian - #409 #434

grizzly (0 votes)
fran - #415 #910
kalor - #535 #868

nin (0 votes)
sorian - #434 #632

crimson (0 votes)
lifeline - #527 #545

no lynch (0 votes)
hecht - #756 #757

Post Counts:
sweetnicole: 73 fran: 72 nin: 71 sorian: 66 dr. monkey: 63 *splinter: 57 hecht: 51 fandorin: 49 terraforce: 48 kitsunelaine: 46 brazil: 45 muffin: 42 silky: 36 crimson: 28 kalor: 26 faircure: 20 include: 18 verelios: 17 stanleypalmtree: 16 rynam: 12 tearablepuns: 10 lone_prodigy: 9 grizzly: 6 geno: 5 lifeline: 5 retromg: 2



Total Accumulated Post Counts:

sweetnicole: 73
fran: 72
nin: 71
sorian: 66
dr. monkey: 63
*splinter: 57
hecht: 51
fandorin: 49
terraforce: 48
kitsunelaine: 46
brazil: 45
muffin: 42
silky: 36
crimson: 28
kalor: 26
faircure: 20
include: 18
verelios: 17
stanleypalmtree: 16
rynam: 12
tearablepuns: 10
lone_prodigy: 9
grizzly: 6
geno: 5
lifeline: 5
retromg: 2
 
nin

nin

Asked Politely
Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
7,159
there i thought you had my back on that vote Kalor.
Now i just look stupid
 
nin

nin

Asked Politely
Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
7,159
Well, going back to my 50/50 thing i might aswell drop the vote now

Vote: silky
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
18,978
I have stated several times before that I'm not against a good Rynam vote, but it seems pretty clear he likely isn't posting before EoD so I'm not sure I like how many people are just piling on him. Very easy push that tells us nothing.
 
nin

nin

Asked Politely
Avenger
Oct 26, 2017
7,159
With silky moving his vote probably to Sweetnicole, there might be a tie incoming.
 
Muffin

Muffin

Member
Oct 26, 2017
10,362
Fran said:
Muffin explain to SweetNicole why this is a scum move please.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Oh, you.

SweetNicole There is not really a need to consolidate lynch trains with one and a half hours to go. It can look scummy, as if you wanna narrow down on two candidates as early as possible, which is something scum would benefit from when the right people (read: town) are leading. It can look like you're trying to shut down discussion around other candidates.

I did the same thing in my last game and got blasted for it, it's really only necessary when there's not much time left.

That about right Fran?
 
faircure

faircure

Member
Oct 27, 2017
631
Okay. For future reference I'm always in uni or working until about 1.5 hours until day end, and I really didn't have time to do much in the morning besides unvote before going to class.

So, I think Fandorin, Nicole and Muffin are townish so far. Silky and Rynam both feel like alright lynches. I'll buy Brazil saying he's having trouble because he's never been super active in a D1. I kinda don't like that he called me out for not having anything hardhitting and shifting votes, especially when I'm also completely unexperienced in D1 play (have only played a game as a sub) and he agreed with the reason for me moving my Nicole vote. (Can dig up the posts if needed. On mobile rn) It's valid criticism of my play, though. If it comes down to him versus any of the people I named first, I'll vote him.

For now, I don't like that Rynam kinda came outta nowhere and won't be able to claim. So:
VOTE: Silky
 
Status
Not open for further replies.