I have got to stop refreshing every hour to see if there is news on the new 2018 models. Surely it won't be until next month.
What about roku apps or something to get it done? It seems like it should be achievable...
I have got to stop refreshing every hour to see if there is news on the new 2018 models. Surely it won't be until next month.
This isn't meant to be snarky, but when it's said that these TVs have a "good picture quality thanks to their black levels", is this only in comparison to other LEDs within a similar price range? A good friend of mine ended up taking his out of the box yesterday, and after spending a few hours messing with the options, could only get a picture that looked OK at best, and not actually all that much better than his four year old, cheapy Samsung that he had in the living room. Maybe it's just having spent the better part of the last decade on a plasma and then going to an OLED, but almost nothing about it actually looked good to me. We tried various games on the Pro that had HDR as well as a few UHDs, and either the screen looked entirely washed out, or if we had it at an acceptable brightness, the black levels looked OK, but some things were crushed and even though it was displaying that HDR was active, you couldn't tell.
On top of that, a few games that were supposed to be 4Kina through checkerboard looked blurry, like it was 1080p, with or without game mode (which made the local dimming awful and halos abound). I also read that these TVs have good motion handling, yet in any action scene in a movie, there are some really bad artifacts/ghosting going on like I haven't seen on a TV or monitor since 2006.
He primarily bought the TV for gaming, and to have something to take with him for his gaming service, but he was also hoping for something that would at least show off the potential of movies. For gaming at least, I guess it's fine for most, but for movies it doesn't really demonstrate anything.
edit: So it looks like the gamma can only be adjusted from your phone, and even though the TV is displaying an HDR mode, if you don't manually set the HDMI inputs to 2.0, they aren't actually going to be using WCG/HDR or even outputting at 4K?
He got the TCL 605p
I just got back from his house too after rechecking some things, and I think the only other thing left to do is to bring my Oppo over to his house. We played a few movies via One S, and while the black bars were obviously not going to be like on an OLED, they weren't even close to plasma, or even some older LCDs I've seen either and all glowed pretty badly. I thought this TV had local dimming? Worse than that though, many of the scenes still looked quite blurry for some reason, almost like it was either displaying in 1080p, or it had a double dose of chromatic aberration (which is impossible, that's just what it looked like).
Also, as it turns out, the TV was actually set to auto by default and it was already correctly displaying WCG/HDR. I switched them to 2.0 to see if there was any difference, but there wasn't. It looked identical, and having it manually set to 2.0 or auto produced the same results with the HDR notification appearing on the upper right hand corner. My issues it seems are just the way the TV looks. We also setup the Roku app to change the gamma, but 2.2 is was already the default, and good for where he was viewing it. I told him that he would want to lower it for events in brighter conditions, or if it looked like too many details were missing in dark areas for his liking. I also actually had all of the settings matching what Rtings.com recommended before even reading theirs, other than remembering the HDMI input might need to be adjusted (I did that for my TV a year and a half ago then forgot about it)too. I don't know. Maybe he just got unlucky with the panel, or it really is just an issue with the panel technology. Maybe this seems extra nitpicky, and it's not even my TV, but IMO just watching 1080p movies on his 2010 plasma looked nicer.
He got the TCL 605p
I just got back from his house too after rechecking some things, and I think the only other thing left to do is to bring my Oppo over to his house. We played a few movies via One S, and while the black bars were obviously not going to be like on an OLED, they weren't even close to plasma, or even some older LCDs I've seen either and all glowed pretty badly. I thought this TV had local dimming? Worse than that though, many of the scenes still looked quite blurry for some reason, almost like it was either displaying in 1080p, or it had a double dose of chromatic aberration (which is impossible, that's just what it looked like).
Also, as it turns out, the TV was actually set to auto by default and it was already correctly displaying WCG/HDR. I switched them to 2.0 to see if there was any difference, but there wasn't. It looked identical, and having it manually set to 2.0 or auto produced the same results with the HDR notification appearing on the upper right hand corner. My issues it seems are just the way the TV looks. We also setup the Roku app to change the gamma, but 2.2 is was already the default, and good for where he was viewing it. I told him that he would want to lower it for events in brighter conditions, or if it looked like too many details were missing in dark areas for his liking. I also actually had all of the settings matching what Rtings.com recommended before even reading theirs, other than remembering the HDMI input might need to be adjusted (I did that for my TV a year and a half ago then forgot about it)too. I don't know. Maybe he just got unlucky with the panel, or it really is just an issue with the panel technology. Maybe this seems extra nitpicky, and it's not even my TV, but IMO just watching 1080p movies on his 2010 plasma looked nicer. I'd even argue most games looked better too.
edit: Game mode absolutely makes a difference in the black levels. It's a cloudy mess with it on. The intros for both TLOU and Uncharted 4 with the ND logo are pure black (which was really surprising) outside of game mode. Inside game mode it almost looks like the brightness was raised to 55-60 and there are areas all over the screen that look like pockets of major backlight bleed. It's awful. Because of the way the intro looked outside of game mode, I expected movies to look similar, but they don't even come close.
Are you sure you're not confusing local contrast with dynamic contrast setting?
Dynamic Contrast isn't on in any mode. It's also locked out in game mode. I set Local Contrast to High, and yes, the firmware is updated. It's the very first thing I did before messing with any of the other settings.
Try going back to advanced settings to turn local contrast back on when turning on game mode then, it turns if off by default the first time you switch to it. If local contrast is turning off in game mode and you can't fix it, there's something wrong with the set (if it's updated to current firmware) that should not be happening. There is only backlight bleed when local dimming is off and it turning on game mode should not elevate black levels unless it's earlier firmware and thus deactivating local contrast.
It's set to High. Turning on Game Mode doesn't turn it off either. Or rather, if it ever did, it hasn't since the first time.
I would reset the TV something is off/wrong cause what you're describing sounds like it's deactivating the local dimming when it should NOT be doing that.
I can load up a game/movie get to a really dark scene and switch between game mode on/off it does not effect the local dimming or black levels at all.
Turning off the local contrast does make it look kinda shitty though, introducing back light bleed and blacks that are no better than an average LCD.
The way you're describing it does sound more and more like something is either faulty, or we're missing something obvious. I dunno what to tell ya
Nope, if you turn game mode back off, it (local dimming) will go back to the setting it was on before Game Mode was enabled (on) in your case. You/he has to go turn on local dimming after enabling game mode the first time.
You're right in that it basically acts like a separate picture setting for local dimming. And it will be like this for the different picture settings as well.
Thanks. I won't actually be able to check for another week, but I'll let him know over the phone and try to convince him to look (he's ridiculously lazy in that regard). It very well might be an issue with Game Mode turning off Local Contrast and we just aren't noticing the option shutting off, since when we shut Game Mode off and scroll back up, it's on. I would think that if Game Mode was turning it off that you would have to manually turn it back on once outside of Game Mode. Unless Game Mode is literally acting like a seperate picture mode for picture options, specifically for Local Contrast alone, since everything else stays the same as the previous mode. I read that it didn't even work at all inside of Game Mode before the firmware update, and that after it should be working the same in any mode. It has the latest update.
Are you saying we should set it to 2.2?The P series according to Rtings gamma 2.2 tracks at closer when set to 2.0. Its been a game changer for me. I don't get black crush and HDR is brighter. Sea of Thieves looks beautiful! On Netflix Altered Carbon w/ Dolby Vision is stunning. As a previous high end Sony TV owner and Im still surprised by the value of this TV.
Oh ok. Their guide still says 2.2Opposite. RTINGS suggests using 2.0 setting as it measures closer to the ideal gamma when using their settings.
Yeah I think it's a recent re-look at the TV video they posted where they mention it. I haven't seen it myself yet though but someone else mentioned it.
see my response above. : )
Backlight to 4? I have mine at 100 which they also say to do in their guideNo. Rtings never updated their site but published a new video, watch it. Set gamma to 2.0. That actually tracks at 2.2, strange I know. : ) Also set your backlight to 4.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buSiu_l6tFw&t=7s
No. Rtings never updated their site but published a new video, watch it. Set gamma to 2.0. That actually tracks at 2.2, strange I know. : ) Also set your backlight to 4.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buSiu_l6tFw&t=7s
Should I get the tcl s 605? I need a 43 incher for the room.. only 299 on amazon
Backlight to 4? Is this for SDR or HDR? If I remember correctly they had SDR backlight at 0 for SDR and 100 for HDR in their review.
Does the video say to drop it down from 100 when HDR now? That's a big difference if so.
Edit: sorry can't view video right now but curious
In the video, for HDR they recommend 100 (which is how it is on OLED as well), and said that it doesn't matter for SDR and to just adjust it to whatever suits your room. The video starts out with them having theirs set to 4. I have no idea what kind of a difference 4 is going to make over 0 though.
I only do it once a week. My TV has been failing since October, and my money for a 4K TV is sitting my account since I got my tax return. I decided that if I could wait from October until now, I could wait for the new model especially since they are going to be 65". Got my PS4 Pro at least, so 1 upgrade down. (My dad is enjoying how much faster Netflix is on his PS4 is over the PS3 he had, he also got and upgrade via hand me down)I have got to stop refreshing every hour to see if there is news on the new 2018 models. Surely it won't be until next month.
No. Rtings never updated their site but published a new video, watch it. Set gamma to 2.0. That actually tracks at 2.2, strange I know. : ) Also set your backlight to 4.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buSiu_l6tFw&t=7s
Did you watch Altered Carbon, it looks great w/ HDR. Regarding those who question the backlight set to 4, thats just for SDR. When watching HDR content all you need to do is set "TV Brightness" to "Brighter". The TCL P automatically goes into torch mode by maxing out the backlight.I tried changing to 2.0 last night while watching the first ep of Jessica Jones season 2. Was an immediate improvement.
He got the TCL 605p
I just got back from his house too after rechecking some things, and I think the only other thing left to do is to bring my Oppo over to his house. We played a few movies via One S, and while the black bars were obviously not going to be like on an OLED, they weren't even close to plasma, or even some older LCDs I've seen either and all glowed pretty badly. I thought this TV had local dimming? Worse than that though, many of the scenes still looked quite blurry for some reason, almost like it was either displaying in 1080p, or it had a double dose of chromatic aberration (which is impossible, that's just what it looked like).
Also, as it turns out, the TV was actually set to auto by default and it was already correctly displaying WCG/HDR. I switched them to 2.0 to see if there was any difference, but there wasn't. It looked identical, and having it manually set to 2.0 or auto produced the same results with the HDR notification appearing on the upper right hand corner. My issues it seems are just the way the TV looks. We also setup the Roku app to change the gamma, but 2.2 is was already the default, and good for where he was viewing it. I told him that he would want to lower it for events in brighter conditions, or if it looked like too many details were missing in dark areas for his liking. I also actually had all of the settings matching what Rtings.com recommended before even reading theirs, other than remembering the HDMI input might need to be adjusted (I did that for my TV a year and a half ago then forgot about it)too. I don't know. Maybe he just got unlucky with the panel, or it really is just an issue with the panel technology. Maybe this seems extra nitpicky, and it's not even my TV, but IMO just watching 1080p movies on his 2010 plasma looked nicer. I'd even argue most games looked better too.
edit: Game mode absolutely makes a difference in the black levels. It's a cloudy mess with it on. The intros for both TLOU and Uncharted 4 with the ND logo are pure black (which was really surprising) outside of game mode. Inside game mode it almost looks like the brightness was raised to 55-60 and there are areas all over the screen that look like pockets of major backlight bleed. It's awful. Because of the way the intro looked outside of game mode, I expected movies to look similar, but they don't even come close.
I've never really known how trusty the distances are, but a guide on google says that for 55", distance should be 6.9-11.5 feet.From where my head rests on my recliner, how many feet should I be from this 55" tv for best viewing?
no offense but it sounds like you guys didn't know what to expect the tv to look like, and you haven't done your research on settings. either that or he got a set with all kinds of problems.
I've never really known how trusty the distances are, but a guide on google says that for 55", distance should be 6.9-11.5 feet.
If you had read my posts, the settings were all correct, other than maybe Local Contrast within Game Mode, which has nothing to do with movies or the way games look outside of Game Mode. It also should have zero effect on artifacts/ghosting or the games looking like 1080p when they aren't supposed to be. Maybe he did get a bad set, although without doing a random side by side comparison with another 605, I don't know how he's supposed to know, since everything appears to work. As for expectations, when pretty much everyone is claiming these are the sets to get if for the cost, and some even saying to get them if you cannot afford an OLED, I would at least expect a good looking picture; and maybe they are if you're just coming from years of other LCD/LEDs. Which was explained in my first post.
i mean, you were talking about the black bars in movies. it should have been obvious right then that local dimming wasn't on. the complaint about things looking blurry i sn't something i've seen about this tv, so i don't know what's going on there. also, saying it looked like an IPS panel tells me that somethings off. regardless of hdr, the contrast of this panel is extremely good for an lcd/led. it should not look like an ips panel. you haven't posted the full settings you're using, so i don't know what's going on.
if the black bars weren't completely black, then the local dimming wasn't on.
It should have "been obvious" that the Local Dimming wasn't on? Except it was on, and it has the same glow/shimmer that a cheap IPS TV has.
Whatever man. I'm done debating this with you, because it was very much ON.
okay, but i'm not debating anyhing. i'm telling you that you're wrong. if the black bars were illuminated like that, then the FALD wasn't on and working.
there is low, medium, high, and off. high is recommended and makes the biggest difference, but even on low it should keep the bars from being lit up too much.
Good to know. So there are then three levels of dimming then, and I've only been experiencing two. One is with Local Contrast OFF, the other is with it ON, but apparently it's only partially working, and then there's ON with it actually working, which I guess we aren't seeing.
/shrug
If you had read my posts, the settings were all correct, other than maybe Local Contrast within Game Mode, which has nothing to do with movies or the way games look outside of Game Mode. It also should have zero effect on artifacts/ghosting or the games looking like 1080p when they aren't supposed to be. Maybe he did get a bad set, although without doing a random side by side comparison with another 605, I don't know how he's supposed to know, since everything appears to work. As for expectations, when pretty much everyone is claiming these are the sets to get for the cost, and some even saying to get them if you cannot afford an OLED, I would at least expect a good looking picture; and maybe they have one if you're just coming from years of other LCD/LEDs. Which was explained in my first post.
The whole "it didn't even look like 1080p it was blurry" thing you keep mentioning is kinda worrying that the set might be defective.
How was everything hooked up? Was his devices going through the TV itself or through a soundbar or AVR via passthrough?
I ask cause I have a Bose ST300 system that has an HDMI in with 4K/HDR pass through so I tried hooking up one of my 4K/HDR devices through it cause the TV has an ARC HDMI, but it causes issues with the TV (I think the TV's ARC HDMI is the issue since it doesn't happen with the other HDMIs). Sometimes it works but often it struggles and displays artifacts OR it makes 4K/HDR look super pixelated and blurry.
It's like the TVs ARC HDMI (HDMI 3) has issues receiving the signal from the Bose while having to still do its ARC duties for the other devices. I thought it was the Bose but I swapped it out and bought new high speed certified cables and the issues remained. Issue TOTALLY went away if I plugged the Bose into the other TV HDMI inputs but then I would lose the audio from from the other devices plugged into the TV going to the Bose since it's not plugged into the ARC HDMI. In the end it was a non issue since the Switch isn't 4K/HDR so it works fine in the Bose HDMI in while leaving the Bose plugged into the TVs ARC HDMI and having my other two 4K/HDR devices plugged into the TV.
But yeah, moral of the story is at least for me, I had issue with the TVs ARC HDMI displaying correctly when going through another device passthrough. Might just be my TV though being defective but it's a non issue for me and my setup luckily.
We simply ran two Twisted Veins "4K" specced cables directly from the systems to the TV, although I told him that he might be pushing it with fifteen feet, since it's recommended right now to not go beyond six if you can help it if you're trying to hit 4K/60 with anything. Even then, at least the systems were showing that they were outputting in 2160p/HDR, although I couldn't find an option anywhere for the TV itself to display what's being shown. The TV would at least give the HDR notification though.
What's going on with movies sounds like the same issue the Xbox One S had near launch, but his system has been updated to the most recent update, so that shouldn't actually be the problem, but like I previously said, the only thing left for me to do is to bring over my Oppo. We were only using the first and second inputs too. I'm also wondering what the lightning conditions most people are using are. The room we were in wasn't completely black, but it was fairly dark with no lights on.
Double edit: as far as settings, I have most of the settings as Rtings had it but I have a spyder Pro colorimeter that I use to calibrate my gray scale and also a DVE with color filter to calibrate the color and tint (for SDR) so I have customer advanced settings for the colorspace (no one should be copying rtings colorspace settings as they're per panel specific) and stuff. But the basic settings are mostly the same.
The only thing that differs for me is the TV Brightness I basically never have as Darkest since Rtings calibrates it to a pitch black theater room. I switch between normal and brighter depending on daylight or night but usually I'll leave it on one and forget it mostly.
If this was my TV, I would dive deeper into it, since I'd have all the time I needed before making a decision. I have the DVE HD basics disc with the filter, Spears & Munsil version 2, tons of contrast, brightness slides and a few for gamma as well as the more recently released HDR disc from Diversified. I didn't have all day to mess around with the set and read forums, get the perfect lightning conditions (which would be hard since he's going to be using it in multiple lightning conditions anyway, and I would have basically had to double the settings, with the second being a "best guess"). Didn't have time to use the i1, but I know my friend wouldn't care anyway since most of what he's been viewing over the last decade has been pretty crummy, aside from his plasma that he infrequently uses since it's not in the family room.
He's also unfortunately the kind of person that would think he was getting an amazing picture out of the box, regardless of what it actually looks like just because it's a 4K TV that can display HDR content and also because he's also not used to playing anything at higher resolutions on PC. He can't even seem to tell the difference between the IQ of an OLED and other panel types either. He also can't seem to tell the difference between an improperly calibrated 3D projector at the theater (they destroy the overall contrast and color saturation) compared to projectors that are actually set to the necessary lumens. Although he once commented on how much more detailed an episode of Game of Thrones seemed to look on my TV than what he watched at home. This was comparing an episode from the Blu-ray at six and a half feet from a 55'' and one from cable on a 42'' at over twelve feet though...
Despite that, I actually did do a good job of dialing in the settings, other than maybe the already discussed Local Contrast within Game Mode, if that's actually even a factor right now, because it very well could still be on as I thought it was. Yet again, that would still have no bearing with what I'm seeing outside of Game Mode, since I know the TV is very capable at displaying what looks like a pure black screen.
Since he's going to be using it in variable settings, "Movie" is just too dark, so I had his set to "Normal", although I did switch it back to Movie just to see if it made any difference from the issues I was noticing. It's more a "me" thing than anything though. He's too lazy to do his own research and relies on my input more than he should, and since I was the one who recommended this set, I feel obligated towards getting it to look good. I don't know that I could convince him into exchanging it though if this is just another panel lottery issue either. I even noticed some really bad uniformity issues on just the PS4 dashboard, which led to an exaggerated DSE. He didn't seem to be able to see what I was seeing when I mentioned it. Reading up after the fact, these sets scored very low in that regard. Actually the worst on Rtings.