Some early first impressions.
Played for a few hours and have enjoyed it so far but have also come across some annoyances and issues.
1. Playing solo is a hassle in multiple ways. Not being able to hold more than one thing at once, for example, makes repeat trips very necessary.
2. Coordinates on treasure maps don't actually relate to the ship's map. This one is incredibly annoying, probably 25 minutes of my playtime has been me scrolling through the ship's match looking for an island that matches the treasure map I have. I just find it incredibly difficult and it's annoying that it doesn't give accurate coordinates.
3. The player respawning system. Just got burned on this one. Spent the last 30 mins or so sailing to an island and looking for some buried treasure but part way through another solo ship turned up and tried to sink mine whilst I was on the island. I boarded his ship and killed him but he just respawned on his ship and sank mine whilst I was heading back to the island. That meant when I did find the treasure I couldn't do anything with it because I was respawned in a completely different location after getting my ship back. This is the biggest issue tbh and I think it's just a case of no matter what they do, dying to or killing another player will always be a hassle.
4. Combat isn't good. Not bad either, serviceable but not good. Doesn't help that the game seemingly only has skeletons as the only NPC enemy.
5. Little variation in ships. It would be nice if you could buy new ships and upgrade your ship over time to improve it's speed, durability, cannon types, amount of cannons and things like that. Would be a nice form of progression but sadly it seems like there's just the big and small ships that are based on how many are in your crew and the only progression is cosmetic.
6. No third person. Looking through the clothing and hair shop it seems like you can get a bunch of really cool things but since you can't go third person you won't actually be able to appreciate them yourself. I know you can do certain gestures and emotes that will put you in third person but that's not really a solution.
7. Seeming lack of mission content? Correct me if I'm wrong but my early impression is that the 3 main quest types won't change much. The core of the game seems to be focused on sailing to an island and either killing skeletons, delivering something or looking for buried treasure. I could be wrong but that's just not enough variation. I want to be solving riddles and exploring through cave systems, plundering towns and doing actual pirate stuff. Why aren't there any towns or places for me to raid? For a pirate I seem like an incredibly agreeable person who just does little fetch quests for people. A proper core questline would do a lot to make the game feel like it has more substantial content.
8. Seemingly not enough variation in the sea. I know we have the kraken but there is potential for so much more, again maybe I just haven't seen it yet but I want fierce storms, tsunami's, ghost ships and the like. Even npc merchant ships that you can board and raid for gold and other treasures. Again to make you feel like more of a pirate
9. No NPC crewmates. Not a problem if you're not playing solo but almost all of my friends are PS4 so being able to hire NPC crew mates who can be commanded to do things would be useful and would also let solo players experience the bigger ships without having to deal with the majority of randoms just putting you in the brig.
So yeah, I could probably come up with more but I feel like I've said enough. The game has a lot of potential but I feel like it's really lacking and tbh even if I was playing with friends I don't think it would have too much longevity. Will continue to play for now and see if things improve but I'm not that hopeful. I honestly think the multiplayer focus really limited what they could do with the game and if they had focused on single player with more pirating content the game would have been a lot better.#
Would appreciate some corrections if I've gotten anything in my impressions wrong.