• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Should we move to a new OT?

  • Yes

    Votes: 86 21.9%
  • No

    Votes: 80 20.4%
  • Wait until a couple weeks before E3

    Votes: 226 57.7%

  • Total voters
    392
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Klobrille

Member
Oct 27, 2017
9,360
Germany
That's fine. Play what you want. I'm just puzzled by NOT wanting a new Conker game when you have an avatar of Conker and correct me if im wrong but isn't Conker your favorite game/mascot/character?
Yes, of course he is. The game made my childhood.

Again, I already stated my opinion on a sequel:
On the topic about a possible sequel ... Yeah. That's a mixed bag really. I mean to be honest - I would shit my pants due to happiness if we really get another full Conker game. It would be insane. But then again ... Maybe Conker BFD doesn't even really need a sequel. BFD is more of a once-in-a-lifetime game. It's a really unique experience. I imagine it would be really, really difficult to meet both expectations from fans by respecting the roots while still moving the next game forward. I doubt MS will ever touch Conker again. It's somehow sad to see it this way - but maybe that's the best thing to do.

I keep the "I don't want a new Conker" stance since this way I simply won't be disappointed if we never see anything Conker again. I just accepted it.
 
Oct 25, 2017
3,595
Doesn't have gap?

MS have released:

- Ori (Great, but not really big AAA-cinematic experience)
- Cuphead not MS game, but console exclusive
- Quantum Break was "just" good
- Gears 4 is good
- Sunset Overdrive is good/decent
- Halo 5 campaign was pretty meh when you compare it to previous Halos.
- Forzas?
- And in the future for next 2 years we have Halo 6, Crackdown 3 and more Forza?

And that's pretty much it? Meanwhile Sony has released

- The Last of Us remastered (GOTY material)
- Shadow of The Colossus great game
- Ratchet and Clank was good

- Horizon: Zero Dawn (GOTY)
- Bloodborne (GOTY)
- Uncharted 4 (GOTY)
- Uncharted: Lost legacy was good
- God of War (GOTY or even GOTG contender)
- The Last Guardian was good
- Nioh was good
- Nier: Automata was good
- Persona 5 is one of the highest rated game of this generation
- GTS have campaign now?
- Driveclub was decent
- And for the next two years we have atleast TLOU2, Days Gone, Spiderman, Ghosts of Thushima and Death Stranding

My point is not to start console war, but closing your eyes and saying to yourself there isnt gap, is not really helping. If you don't see gap between Sony and Microsoft exclusives, specially AAA-singleplayer games, you are lying. Microsoft have edge when we compare multiplayer games.

Why you put remasters os PS4 and dont on XB1?
 

EdgeXL

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,789
California
Microsoft did not develop it, they did not publish it and they don't own the IP.
Still a good game that's console exclusive to Xbox One.

I never claimed they developed, published or owned the IP. I said Microsoft invested in Cuphead. They provided funding for the development and marketing support.

By investing in Cuphead I maintain that Microsoft has invested in single player content (along with the other games I listed).
 
Apr 6, 2018
1,859
Doesn't have gap?

MS have released:

- Ori (Great, but not really big AAA-cinematic experience)
- Cuphead not MS game, but console exclusive
- Quantum Break was "just" good
- Gears 4 is good
- Sunset Overdrive is good/decent
- Halo 5 campaign was pretty meh when you compare it to previous Halos.
- Forzas?
- And in the future for next 2 years we have Halo 6, Crackdown 3 and more Forza?

And that's pretty much it? Meanwhile Sony has released

- The Last of Us remastered (GOTY material)
- Shadow of The Colossus great game
- Ratchet and Clank was good

- Horizon: Zero Dawn (GOTY)
- Bloodborne (GOTY)
- Uncharted 4 (GOTY)
- Uncharted: Lost legacy was good
- God of War (GOTY or even GOTG contender)
- The Last Guardian was good
- Nioh was good
- Nier: Automata was good
- Persona 5 is one of the highest rated game of this generation
- GTS have campaign now?
- Driveclub was decent
- And for the next two years we have atleast TLOU2, Days Gone, Spiderman, Ghosts of Thushima and Death Stranding

My point is not to start console war, but closing your eyes and saying to yourself there isnt gap, is not really helping. If you don't see gap between Sony and Microsoft exclusives, specially AAA-singleplayer games, you are lying. Microsoft have edge when we compare multiplayer games.
i don't undertand why counting games like nier, persona or niho as sony games, they are exclusive just for the demography of their pubblic, example given Ni No Kuni 2 according to SteamSpy sold less than 80k copies on steam, it's just a matter of pubblic
 

daniel77733

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,639
The games were beautiful but weren't as great as claimed to be almost like brainwashing people into liking the games

Horizon is simply amazing. My 2017 goty. The biggest positive in regards to Horizon is the studio that developed the game - Guerrilla Games. They went from a four game FPS franchise in Killzone to something a hell of a lot better and far more successful in their first attempt at an action/RPG. Uncharted 4 was a great 8.5/10 for me but Lost Legacy blows it away in my opinion.
 

Panic Freak

Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,590
I think that Microsoft needs to give its developers more time to make masterpieces in the Halo and Gears universe. An extra year or two ought to do the trick.
 

Zeta Ori

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,102
NY
We back at list wars and bad analogies again in this thread?

ouroboros.gif
 

SpinlyLimbs

Banned
Feb 1, 2018
914
And that's pretty much it? Meanwhile Sony has released

- The Last of Us remastered (GOTY material)
- Shadow of The Colossus great game
- Ratchet and Clank was good

- Horizon: Zero Dawn (GOTY)
- Bloodborne (GOTY)
- Uncharted 4 (GOTY)
- Uncharted: Lost legacy was good
- God of War (GOTY or even GOTG contender)
- The Last Guardian was good
- Nioh was good
- Nier: Automata was good
- Persona 5 is one of the highest rated game of this generation
- GTS have campaign now?
- Driveclub was decent
- And for the next two years we have atleast TLOU2, Days Gone, Spiderman, Ghosts of Thushima and Death Stranding

My point is not to start console war, but closing your eyes and saying to yourself there isnt gap, is not really helping. If you don't see gap between Sony and Microsoft exclusives, specially AAA-singleplayer games, you are lying. Microsoft have edge when we compare multiplayer games.

Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.
 
Apr 6, 2018
1,859
Horizon is simply amazing. My 2017 goty. The biggest positive in regards to Horizon is the studio that developed the game - Guerrilla Games. They went from a four game FPS franchise in Killzone to something a hell of a lot better and far more successful in their first attempt at an action/RPG. Uncharted 4 was a great 8.5/10 for me but Lost Legacy blows it away in my opinion.
I agree on lost legacy, it has a better campaign than U4 which still remains a 8/8,5 rock solid game, but I had to disagree on horizon. It was a too static game with few and bad subquest, if you exclude the dinosaurs, which are obviusly a huge selling point , it's one of the most boring open world of this generation.

And graphics are that good due too magic tricks like the extremly low FOV if you compares it to similar games like the ubisoft ones
 
Last edited:

X Wi77iaM X

Banned
Nov 25, 2017
818
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their criteria focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.

you have my vote for next boss of xbox division.
 

Klobrille

Member
Oct 27, 2017
9,360
Germany
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.
Well said.
 

daniel77733

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,639
I agree on lost legacy, it has a better campaign than U4 which still remains a 8/8,5 rock solid game, but I had to disagree on horizon. It was a too static game and few and bad subquest, if you exclude the dinosaurs, which are obviusly a huge selling point , it's one of the most boring open world of this generation

Not for me. Second best game of the gen after The Witcher 3. The side quests are worse than ACO/TW3 but that's to be expected since it was GG's first action RPG. For their first shot, they put Bioware, Bethesda and many other developers/publishers to shame.

I loved the open world and the gameplay is a perfect ten. From stealth to using bows and arrows to melee to traps to bombs, it all works so fluid and responsive. The machines were awesome and had more animations in some of them that some entire games have total. LOL. The main story and characters were also great and should be even better with the eventual sequel.

For this gen, I have The Witcher 3 (9.5/10, my 2015 goty), Horizon (9.5/10, my 2017 goty) and Uncharted Lost Legacy (9.5/10) as my top three games for the generation. Out of 63 completed games and including the above three, only 11 games total have hit my 9 or 9.5 rating. Also enjoyed The Frozen Wilds as well.

To each their own though. :)
 

ElBoxy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,258
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.
Different games require a different approach to reviewing. The games you're complaining about are mainly story driven. Your playing them solely for the story so if it does that well then of course it'll get high scores, even if other elements are flawed. That's what it was made for. And also you have to look at it more closely than on a subjective level. Yes, there's no denying Sony is putting a lot of money on these narrative experiences. This is what they want to excel at and they're good at it the same way Microsoft is really good at building an eco system. I don't think there's some conspiracy to give them automatic high praise. Reviews are trying to explore games than on a surface level.
 

Dyashen

Member
Dec 20, 2017
5,191
Belgium
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.

This.
 
Mar 10, 2018
431
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.

What the hell.....
 
Oct 25, 2017
3,595
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.

giphy.gif
 

FelipeMGM

#Skate4
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
3,012
I'm gonna politely ask that people don't come to this thread posting game lists and enticing system wars battles

This is a discussion thread about Microsoft first-party games, let's try to keep it civil and focusing on that as much as possible
 
Last edited:

Panic Freak

Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,590
Different games require a different approach to reviewing. The games you're complaining about are mainly story driven. Your playing them solely for the story so if it does that well then of course it'll get high scores, even if other elements are flawed. That's what it was made for. And also you have to look at it more closely than on a subjective level. Yes, there's no denying Sony is putting a lot of money on these narrative experiences. This is what they want to excel at and they're good at it the same way Microsoft is really good at building an eco system. I don't think there's some conspiracy to give them automatic high praise. Reviews are trying to explore games than on a surface level.

No one plays games "solely" for the story. They are video games and are meant to be played. I'd argue that Brothers does a better job at telling a story in a video game than pretty much any AAA game you could think of because it does so through a game mechanic that really pulls at your heart strings.
 

francium87

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,045
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.

I do find that, for games with metacritic scores above 80 (at least indicating some level of polish), my enjoyment don't really correlate with scores all that well. As long as Xbox keeps pumping out 80ish games (which the past two years have been a bit lacking, and recore should have launched as the DE version), I am very happy.

It's great GoW exists, and competition is a great thing for gamers.

Also, list wars often forget Halo Wars 2, one of the best RTS console experience, exists. It might not be for everyone, but that can be said for any genre/game.
 

SpinlyLimbs

Banned
Feb 1, 2018
914
Different games require a different approach to reviewing. The games you're complaining about are mainly story driven. Your playing them solely for the story so if it does that well then of course it'll get high scores, even if other elements are flawed. That's what it was made for. And also you have to look at it more closely than on a subjective level. Yes, there's no denying Sony is putting a lot of money on these narrative experiences. This is what they want to excel at and they're good at it the same way Microsoft is really good at building an eco system. I don't think there's some conspiracy to give them automatic high praise. Reviews are trying to explore games than on a surface level.
I'm not saying singleplayer games or even cinematic games can't be good, I just wish their were more focus on the things that make games unique. Max Payne 1-3 all have an incredibly cinematic flair but also manage to be massively replayable and fun games with interesting mechanics and I see that being lost in alot of modern games. Everything is punching with locked on animations and "emotional" storytelling now. I just want more games like the modern Doom, entirely focused on tight and responsive gameplay. You can weave a story around that, or even better have the player interact with the world you've created and make their own story, I just don't see that happening as much. I can remember the story of me fighting Alma in Ninja Gaiden, trying desperately to survive a scrappy confrontation only to come out on top much more than I remember any of the scripted sequences in Uncharted or Quantum Break where I merely pressed some buttons on command to get to the next scripted trigger. Games should be celebrated and revered for their use of the unique options only afforded by games as a medium instead of how pretty they look or how jaw dropping the setpiece. Alot of whether gameplay focused games succeed or not is based on critical response and from my perspective alot of critics don't seem to weigh gameplay as heavily as they should in comparison to presentation and story.
 

ElBoxy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,258
No one plays games "solely" for the story. They are video games and are meant to be played. I'd argue that Brothers does a better job at telling a story in a video game than pretty much any AAA game you could think of because it does so through a game mechanic that really pulls at your heart strings.
Not every reviewer is the same and not every reviewer played Brothers nor is every narrative game trying to tell the same story as that.
 
OP
OP
Figments

Figments

Spencer’s little helper
Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,292
California
I really hope Microsoft takes a look at the Shadowrun IP at some point in the future. I'd love a third person WRPG set in that universe, as a complement to the CRPGs on PC.
 

JaggedSac

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,988
Burbs of Atlanta
I've played over 9 days(216 hours) of Halo 5. I need more in my veins 343, be that 6 or a spin-off. I played the SP for 10 hours. Take your time on the SP, but it's worth about 5% of the mp to me, lol.
 

Kiekura

Member
Mar 23, 2018
4,074
Again, not to start a console war but a massive portion of these I could describe as garbage by my own personal view, including things that are coming just based on my views of the creators/teams associated with them. To reiterate, my view, as in listing games is pointless and adds nothing. Could publishers do with more diversity in genre/design/ideas? Yes, absolutely. However, alot of Sonys first party are in my mind specifically designed to be media darlings. The media loves a story about emotions, gameplay be damned so you have stuff like The Last Guardian be given 10/10 reviews by the likes of EZA despite in their very review stating the game is deeply flawed. Not to mention stuff like Nier and Ni-Oh getting basically home field advantage when it comes to busines deals, as stupid as that may sound Japanese culture isn't exactly the most flexible or foreign friendly. The media is a big problem here in my opinion, in both perception and results. You have a game with "emotional storytelling" 90 on metacritic. You have a game with incredibly tight, incredibly polished and addictive gameplay like Thumper? 80 on metacritic. Not even pointing to some type of conspiratorial corporate bias but so many critical publications very clearly have their priorities focused on what will make games seem like "art" instead of what actually plays well.

This is also you go wrong. Are those games heavily relying on story? Yes they are.

But their gameplay is still suberb.

Bloodborne was praised because of its combat

Horizon was praised because of its combat and how gorgeous it is with rich open world. Some people even disliked it's story

God of War have been praised to have best combat any game have ever made and how well made the world is.

Last of Us and Uncharted are games what are most story heavy, but even those games had AWESOME gunplay and it was fun.

Just because Sony games are story heavy, doesn't mean they don't have great gameplay and mechanics.
 

daniel77733

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,639
It's all based on personal preference. At 39, I want a total, complete and overall package. Visuals, audio, gameplay, story and characters in a single player third person perspective. Sony simply gives me what I want and they do it better than everyone else. So again, it's simply all about personal preference.
 

RF Switch

Banned
Oct 31, 2017
4,118
No one plays games "solely" for the story. They are video games and are meant to be played. I'd argue that Brothers does a better job at telling a story in a video game than pretty much any AAA game you could think of because it does so through a game mechanic that really pulls at your heart strings.

i love love LOVED The Last Guardian up to that last second of the story i was hooked, on the edge of my seat and deeply moved. The music, atmosphere and story arch was pure brilliance i just couldn't believe video games reached this kind of connection with me. So far everyone ive told they ABSOLUTELY had to play it didnt finish it and complained about how clunky and annoying the game is. I brute forced my way through because of how entranced i was with the story and didn't care that it was a disaster trying to make precision jumps or getting trico to listen to me. The Last Guardian gameplay wise gets a 4.5/10 for me but a 10/10 for story. I played Last Guardian for its story and i have no regrets
 

daniel77733

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,639
I really hope Microsoft takes a look at the Shadowrun IP at some point in the future. I'd love a third person WRPG set in that universe, as a complement to the CRPGs on PC.

Doesn't Microsoft own the Shadowrun IP and licensed it out to Harebrained Schemes? Still baffles me that Microsoft didn't pay them to port over the game to Xbox One.
 

Deleted member 18951

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
5,531
For the sake of everyone's sanity can we please stop talking about Sony vs Xbox and Xbox vs Sony in this thread. Pretty please.....
 

SpinlyLimbs

Banned
Feb 1, 2018
914
This is also you go wrong. Are those games heavily relying on story? Yes they are.

But their gameplay is still suberb.

Bloodborne was praised because of its combat

Horizon was praised because of its combat and how gorgeous it is with rich open world. Some people even disliked it's story

God of War have been praised to have best combat any game have ever made and how well made the world is.

Last of Us and Uncharted are games what are most story heavy, but even those games had AWESOME gunplay and it was fun.

Just because Sony games are story heavy, doesn't mean they don't have great gameplay and mechanics.

I dissagree with most of your points. I'm a tad bit too drunk at the moment to state why, even if I weren't drunk I'd still probably be on the outside of popular opinion. I just don't get the praise for most of those games is what I am saying. Most of them just seem like slightly polished versions of mediocre ideas outside of Bloodborne which is just Ninja Gaiden 2 combat but much worse and can't rest on the variety and flexibility of DaS. Again, sorry I am drunk and probably sound like a buffoon.
 

Zukkoyaki

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,515
So...

What would you all specifically want the rumored Halo and Gears spin-offs to be?

I'd like a squad-based, tactical Halo and a Gears that's like XCOM.
 

Kiekura

Member
Mar 23, 2018
4,074
I dissagree with most of your points. I'm a tad bit too drunk at the moment to state why, even if I weren't drunk I'd still probably be on the outside of popular opinion. I just don't get the praise for most of those games is what I am saying. Most of them just seem like slightly polished versions of mediocre ideas outside of Bloodborne which is just Ninja Gaiden 2 combat but much worse and can't rest on the variety and flexibility of DaS. Again, sorry I am drunk and probably sound like a buffoon.

Well that's your opinion and I don't wanna start fighting here. Let's just leave this matter here and focus on Xbox alone and leave PlayStation alone
 

francium87

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,045
Doesn't Microsoft own the Shadowrun IP and licensed it out to Harebrained Schemes? Still baffles me that Microsoft didn't pay them to port over the game to Xbox One.
Yep, MS also licensed battletech to them. That new game is coming out soon, again PC only.
In interviews Harebrained stated that there's no stipulation of Xbox port/exclusive/anything. Who knows.
 
Apr 6, 2018
1,859
https://pursuenews.com/showtimes-halo-tv-series-starts-filming-in-october-filming-location/

ok this is the only way I know to shift the discussion on something less "hot".


Showtime is a huge network with a high quality standard (like Twin peaks 3 last year)

Not for me. Second best game of the gen after The Witcher 3. The side quests are worse than ACO/TW3 but that's to be expected since it was GG's first action RPG. For their first shot, they put Bioware, Bethesda and many other developers/publishers to shame.

I loved the open world and the gameplay is a perfect ten. From stealth to using bows and arrows to melee to traps to bombs, it all works so fluid and responsive. The machines were awesome and had more animations in some of them that some entire games have total. LOL. The main story and characters were also great and should be even better with the eventual sequel.

For this gen, I have The Witcher 3 (9.5/10, my 2015 goty), Horizon (9.5/10, my 2017 goty) and Uncharted Lost Legacy (9.5/10) as my top three games for the generation. Out of 63 completed games and including the above three, only 11 games total have hit my 9 or 9.5 rating. Also enjoyed The Frozen Wilds as well.

To each their own though. :)

I've met only one game that I thought was worth the 9,5 status, planescape: torment :lol:
But maybe it's just our personal tastes, like once said one of the masterminds of italian literature, Torquato Tasso, "s'ei piace ei lice: if you like it, you could enjoy without regret"
 

daniel77733

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,639
I've met only one game that I thought was worth the 9,5 status, planescape: torment :lol: But maybe it's just our personal tastes, like once said one of the masterminds of italian literature "s'ei piace ei lice: if you like it, you could enjoy without regret"

Definitely personal tastes. I have zero interest in Planescape. LOL. :)

Yall bored.
MS gonna drop bombs on yall, Halo 6 spring 2019. Kiss my ass. :)

October 2019. Book it. :)
 

Deleted member 5764

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
6,574
So...

What would you all specifically want the rumored Halo and Gears spin-offs to be?

I'd like a squad-based, tactical Halo and a Gears that's like XCOM.

I said it yesterday, but I'd actually like for them to not be full spin-offs. Instead, just take the multiplayer modes of Halo/Gears and make them into their own titles. Then, do something different for the story of Halo/Gears.

Episodic chapters that release once a month via Game Pass would be pretty darn cool. A story-based horde/firefight game ALA Payday and Overwatch Uprising/Retribution would be cool too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.