Shutting down any conversation on a slow day 1 seems counterproductive to me.
I do not remember playing with him (sorry if we did though comrade) - so he gets a free pass because you don't expect anything from him... that's just grea.. eh, not useful?
What about rac makes you itching to see more?
(I mean of course I see the whole point of purposely singling out one player and generating discussion this way, but I don't know if that's what you intended)
We'll have to agree to disagree. Trash conversation actively detracts from scum hunting, that's literally how I fool a lot of you most of the time.
For Comrade, you can policy lynch him if you want but that's about the best you'll get. It doesn't matter if you want to give him a free pass or not. He's going to pop in, say some nonsensical stuff, throw out a non commital accusation, then disappear for a day. I haven't had to lynch him as scum yet but I assume it's like anyone else that doesn't give me much to read (Star, lp, Kyan, etc.), finding him out will be through connections, not as a first point of contact.
I chose rac in particular because I know that he clams up when he's scum and is usually a middling presence otherwise. I'm not seeing a presence at all.
Also, I'll bait the next question by saying, yes, I am purposely voting turmoil over rac right now and am aware of it. Turmoil is the honey trap I want to watch, I'm not convinced he isn't just town that made a stupid error but I still want to see how his situation develops with pressure votes.
Digging into the why on that with nothing to compare it to may not get us far yet, but it's certainly something that will need to be discussed. I agree with you that ferreting out what drove that suggestion is a larger concern but I'm not sure what conclusions we can draw at present. It's also such an easy thing to say no to that responses may not be particularly helpful either. Not interested in shutting down this inquiry, just not sure what we can do with it right now.
I don't actually see FEP's thing as that huge of a deal. It's something that's been punished heavily so many times in our community (role fishing) that anyone with even passing meta trying to hide won't bring it up and this setup is deceivingly complex in that it looks like it's easy to solve but there is so much overlap that it is near impossible until end game. So his mass claim idea isn't particularly offensive or shocking.
