• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

ShapeGSX

Member
Nov 13, 2017
5,231
Bought a E7 55-inch for $1400. After playing with it and testing out multiple 24fps content, the microstuttering is absolutely killing me. I'm coming up from the Panasonic VIERA TC-P50GT50 plasma TV which I absolutely love. I've babied it for 5 years and have no burn-in problems so I bet I can manage OLED just fine. However, the microstuttering is making it extremely difficult to tell what's happening on the screen. My question is does the black-interpolation on the C8 make this stuttering more bearable? The screen itself looks amazing on the OLED but the motion clarity is a dealbreaker for me. Would a Q9F be more right for me? Or am I going to have to just wait until few more years for the tech to catch up?

stutter-0-ms-vs-40-ms.gif

That is what killed OLED for me too. The 24fps content stuttering was horrible due to the instantaneous response time.
 

Bumrush

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,770
So some people say the 24fps content is unbearable. Is that one of those affects some doesn't affect other deals?
 

ShapeGSX

Member
Nov 13, 2017
5,231
As a plasma owner this scares me. Shouldn't BFI be a good measure against it though?

Plasmas "flicker" at something like 600Hz, so it is very difficult to see the flickering. It is what helps mask the stuttering.

BFI should help. But current OLED displays can only insert a black frame at a much lower frequency since the panels are only 120Hz. So you can see the flicker, particularly with 24fps.

LCDs with LED backlighting can actually flicker the backlight a lot more quickly than OLEDs because it's easier and faster to address the larger backlight blocks. You don't have to blank the LCD, you just have to blank the backlight. In fact, I read that current Samsung QLEDs actually use PWM to adjust the backlight intensity, which essentially amounts to high frequency BFI (although the frequency would depend on the brightness of the region).
 

Armoured_Bear

Banned
Nov 17, 2017
1,140
I was planning on waiting for a HDMI 2.1 set to replace my Panasonic 65VT50 but my mate just got an LG C7 OLED and it's blown my tiny brain.
I want one now :(
 

SpartyCrunch

Xbox
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
2,500
Seattle, WA
I got my 55" LG OLED B7 last Friday and spent all weekend playing with it - such an incredible TV! Everything from 1080p content to 4k to HDR content looks stunning.

I understand that I should use the TV's apps instead of the Xbox apps since the TV supports Dolby Vision. Is there any Dolby Vision content I can try outside of Netflix? I haven't (yet) upgraded my Netflix plan so for Netflix I only get 1080p / SDR for now. What about on Amazon Prime or YouTube?
 

Deleted member 14649

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,524
Same. Although, admittedly, I'm also one of the people who's more prone to want to preserve the way images look in theater, and there's plenty of judder when you watch movies in the theater, so maybe I just don't notice it as much since I take for granted that it's supposed to look that way?

Exactly. I've never used any motion smoothing or interpolation before, even on the plasma, so my eye is trained and accustomed to it.
 

ShapeGSX

Member
Nov 13, 2017
5,231
Same. Although, admittedly, I'm also one of the people who's more prone to want to preserve the way images look in theater, and there's plenty of judder when you watch movies in the theater, so maybe I just don't notice it as much since I take for granted that it's supposed to look that way?

Actually, judder in the theater isn't as bad as as sample and hold OLEDs without BFI because they flicker the film projection (well, they used to flicker the film, not sure of the digital solution, if there is one, currently) at either 48Hz (2x the frame rate) or 72Hz (3x the frame rate) by literally putting a black plate (on a wheel) in front of the film. :)
 

Vlaphor

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,202
Topeka, KS
So, I just got called back from LG, who says they wont cover the burn in on my OLED TV and that I'd have to pay a service technician to fix it. I declined, as I can only see it in certain rare conditions, and then only barely.
 

SOLDIER

One Winged Slayer
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
11,339
dallow_bg did you find the instructions to rollback LG firmware yet?

I at least want to update to see if the Dolby Vision issues I've been having with my Apple TV would get fixed with the update, then decide whether to rollback or not depending.
 

Deleted member 14649

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,524
dallow_bg did you find the instructions to rollback LG firmware yet?

I at least want to update to see if the Dolby Vision issues I've been having with my Apple TV would get fixed with the update, then decide whether to rollback or not depending.

What TV do you have again? No current firmware has fixed this issue on the B6 so not worth updating if you own that set.
 

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
Actually, judder in the theater isn't as bad as as sample and hold OLEDs without BFI because they flicker the film projection (well, they used to flicker the film, not sure of the digital solution, if there is one, currently) at either 48Hz (2x the frame rate) or 72Hz (3x the frame rate) by literally putting a black plate (on a wheel) in front of the film. :)
Interesting.

Back when Pioneer's had the magic 72hz refresh for 24p, that was probably about as good as I've seen on any TV. Looked perfectly filmic. Panasonic did 48 and 96 and they both looked terrible (48 felt like it was practically going to give you a stroke).

With most theaters having converted to digital awhile back, to your point, I wonder what the solution is there? (if there is one at all).

Thankfully i guess i don't notice much difference between 24p on my OLED and what I've seen in theaters.
 

MazeHaze

Member
Nov 1, 2017
8,584
I got my 55" LG OLED B7 last Friday and spent all weekend playing with it - such an incredible TV! Everything from 1080p content to 4k to HDR content looks stunning.

I understand that I should use the TV's apps instead of the Xbox apps since the TV supports Dolby Vision. Is there any Dolby Vision content I can try outside of Netflix? I haven't (yet) upgraded my Netflix plan so for Netflix I only get 1080p / SDR for now. What about on Amazon Prime or YouTube?
Rent a dolby vision movie on vudu and give it a whirl. You really should probably upgrade to 4k netflix though. It's like 3 dollars more.
 

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
THX Launches New TV And Audio Rating System - And, Well, It's A Bit Controversial

Acclaimed independent AV product testing and standards brand THX has launched a new product rating system aimed at giving consumers an at a glance guide to the very best kit money can buy.

Called THX Standard, the new ratings system is designed, in THX's own words, to 'give you data-driven comparisons of popular electronics to make informed purchase decisions unbiased by an editorial perspective.'

https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnar...ting-system-and-well-its-a-bit-controversial/
 

Chamber

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,279
THX Launches New TV And Audio Rating System - And, Well, It's A Bit Controversial


https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnar...ting-system-and-well-its-a-bit-controversial/

The next surprise is that the Sony 55X900E (55XE9005 in Europe) that currently sits at the top of the THX Standard rating list scores three marks higher than the LG OLED55B7 OLED TV; 73 versus 70.

Didn't know TeKFaN was running THX, congrats fam.
 
May 3, 2018
390
I thought this was known / recognized? Dark scenes with bright highlights (OLED), bright scenes with brighter highlights (flagship LED).

It is totally known by now but if you havent noticed DOTSLASHDOT must assert his OLED dominance any chance he gets. It's almost like he's just yelling at the sky. We get it bruh, you like your OLED!

On a quasi related note I've been waiting to see how low prices on the B7 get in Canada and it's still hovering around $2000 for the 55". That's still so ridiculous, what are the chances they could go lower now that the 8 series is out? Or am I playing with fire and stock will run out soon and I'll be hooped?
 
Oct 28, 2017
1,383
So, I just got called back from LG, who says they wont cover the burn in on my OLED TV and that I'd have to pay a service technician to fix it. I declined, as I can only see it in certain rare conditions, and then only barely.

Bust their balls harder. Threaten (in a nice way) to never buy an LG product again etc. There's been reports of this working if you don't take no for an answer.
 

Teiresias

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,227
As a plasma owner this scares me. Shouldn't BFI be a good measure against it though?

I mean, is the issue with 24fps content, particularly if the complaint is microstutter, because OLEDs are doing 3:2 pulldown on the image, whereas quite a few plasmas (including my Kuro) could natively display 24fps with even frame multiples? That doesn't really have anything to do with the image blur part of the equation. Of course, 24fps motion is going to be juttery anyway due to the low framerate, but that's why films look the way they do right now versus playing a game at 60fps.
 

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
I mean, is the issue with 24fps content, particularly if the complaint is microstutter, because OLEDs are doing 3:2 pulldown on the image, whereas quite a few plasmas (including my Kuro) could natively display 24fps with even frame multiples? That doesn't really have anything to do with the image blur part of the equation. Of course, 24fps motion is going to be juttery anyway due to the low framerate, but that's why films look the way they do right now versus playing a game at 60fps.
There's no 3:2 pulldown. 24 is an even multiple of 120
 

SpartyCrunch

Xbox
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
2,500
Seattle, WA
Rent a dolby vision movie on vudu and give it a whirl. You really should probably upgrade to 4k netflix though. It's like 3 dollars more.
Well no, it's not $3 more, it's $36 more per year, and right now all I'm watching on Netflix is Friends and various comedy stand-up specials. I'll upgrade when there's a new show I want to watch that truly benefits from 4K / HDR. For now I just want to test things out for a couple of minutes.
 

Deleted member 14649

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,524
I mean, is the issue with 24fps content, particularly if the complaint is microstutter, because OLEDs are doing 3:2 pulldown on the image, whereas quite a few plasmas (including my Kuro) could natively display 24fps with even frame multiples? That doesn't really have anything to do with the image blur part of the equation. Of course, 24fps motion is going to be juttery anyway due to the low framerate, but that's why films look the way they do right now versus playing a game at 60fps.

Microstutter isn't the correct term. It is judder. It is there on all OLEDs but whether you are susceptible is another thing. Probably worth trying in a store before buying.
 

Teiresias

Member
Oct 27, 2017
8,227
There's no 3:2 pulldown. 24 is an even multiple of 120

According to a series of posts at AVSforum, the LG OLEDs this year force 3:2 pulldown when using BFI:

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/40-ol...-c8p-versus-samsung-q9fn-12.html#post56073692

FYI, on the 2018 LG OLEDs, BFI disables "Real Cinema" (it becomes grayed out). All 24p signals get converted to 60p with 3:2 judder and black frames are inserted every other 120Hz frame. In summary, BFI always strobes at 60Hz regardless of signal.

Confirmed with 1000 fps camera I recorded myself. Maybe if I'm bored this weekend I'll make another animated gif.
Each original 24fps frame is displayed like this:

Frame1:Black:Frame1:Black:Frame2:Black:Frame2:Blac k:Frame2:Black,Frame3 etc.

The Sony A1E did support a different mode which strobed at what looked like 48Hz or lower with 24p HDMI signals. The flicker was unbearable so not really useful. If you set your disc player to 60p HDMI output, it looked identical to what LG is now doing.
 

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
Well no, it's not $3 more, it's $36 more per year, and right now all I'm watching on Netflix is Friends and various comedy stand-up specials. I'll upgrade when there's a new show I want to watch that truly benefits from 4K / HDR. For now I just want to test things out for a couple of minutes.
Amazon Prime has 4K/HDR content. Look for the "UHD" banners in the upper corners of the show/movie images. They also have a "4K" section; some is 4K w/ no HDR however. (And I'd second the Netflix recommendation. It's got some of the best 4K HDR picture quality available, short of UHD disc.)

According to a series of posts at AVSforum, the LG OLEDs this year force 3:2 pulldown when using BFI:

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/40-ol...-c8p-versus-samsung-q9fn-12.html#post56073692

Wow. I'm not a video engineer, but that seems like a bad way to go about that...

Pioneer had 72hz figured out 10 yrs ago. Idk why that is so hard to implement now.
 

SpartyCrunch

Xbox
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
2,500
Seattle, WA
Amazon Prime has 4K/HDR content. Look for the "UHD" banners in the upper corners of the show/movie images. They also have a "4K" section; some is 4K w/ no HDR however. (And I'd second the Netflix recommendation. It's got some of the best 4K HDR picture quality available, short of UHD disc.)
Yeah I found some of that - is their HDR all Dolby Vision though? Or is some of it HDR10?
 

MazeHaze

Member
Nov 1, 2017
8,584
Well no, it's not $3 more, it's $36 more per year, and right now all I'm watching on Netflix is Friends and various comedy stand-up specials. I'll upgrade when there's a new show I want to watch that truly benefits from 4K / HDR. For now I just want to test things out for a couple of minutes.
Obviously I meant 3 dollars more per month. There's a decent amount of great Dolby Vision content on Netflix, that's why I suggested it. Altered Carbon and Lost in Space are visually stunning, as is Chef's Table, the Marvel shows, and a bunch of other stuff. Aside from UHD discs and VUDU rentals it's pretty much the only option.

Edit: Amazon and Youtube are 100 percent HDR10 afaik.
 

MazeHaze

Member
Nov 1, 2017
8,584
You can tell what's HDR10 and what's Dolby Vision by the pop up in the right corner. If it's DV is pops up the Dolby logo and says VISION, for HDR10 it says HDR. I'm fairly certain the only Dolby Vision streaming is on Netflix and Vudu. And movies on AppleTV 4k.
 

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
You can tell what's HDR10 and what's Dolby Vision by the pop up in the right corner. If it's DV is pops up the Dolby logo and says VISION, for HDR10 it says HDR. I'm fairly certain the only Dolby Vision streaming is on Netflix and Vudu. And movies on AppleTV 4k.
I thought similarly. Google yielded this:

https://hdguru.com/amazon-begins-dolby-vision-content-support/

(Can i also mention how much i cannot stand when news outlets don't timestamp their articles. I have no idea when that article was written, but last fall, Amazon didn't have anything in DV iirc)
 

Velasco

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,096
I think that the only DV content Prime Video has (excluding paid movies) is the second season of Bosch (U.S only).DV support was added in 2016.
 

DOTDASHDOT

Helios Abandoned. Atropos Conquered.
Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,076
It is totally known by now but if you havent noticed DOTSLASHDOT must assert his OLED dominance any chance he gets. It's almost like he's just yelling at the sky. We get it bruh, you like your OLED!

On a quasi related note I've been waiting to see how low prices on the B7 get in Canada and it's still hovering around $2000 for the 55". That's still so ridiculous, what are the chances they could go lower now that the 8 series is out? Or am I playing with fire and stock will run out soon and I'll be hooped?

It's not DOTSLASHDOT's fault, you are angry about not owning the best is it? Stop being cheap and buy one, instead of whinging :)
 

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
lol

totally missed that the THX page rates the P607 TCL above the 930E.

mkay.

I had a Panasonic x800u that had thx certification which meant nothing. I imagine this will be the same.
Yep, my 55ST60 had the mode as well. Had an odd green hue to it.

My broader opinion, esp on the audio side, is that THX has been meaningless, even at the height of it's popularity (even tho Tomlinson Holman has written a couple decent books)
 
Last edited:

RedlineRonin

Member
Oct 30, 2017
2,620
Minneapolis
THX hasn't been relevant for a decade or longer.
It's honestly so weird to follow them on Twitter. Because, for all intents and purposes, they have nothing to contribute. No audio standard or object based audio codec. No contribution to any picture quality standard; e.g. Dolby Vision, HDR10, Technicolor etc.

They sort of seem like they just sat back and let 4K/HDR/object-based audio happen, without any planning of where they would fit into the mix.
 
OP
OP
Jeremiah

Jeremiah

Member
Oct 25, 2017
774
After THX was acquired by Razer, it really cemented to me how they've become a shell of their former self over the years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.