Sorry that it has taken me so long to chime in on recent Feedback "discussions," but I was away on vacation last week and then got sick right before I left to come home. Here are my thoughts on each case:
digitalrelic: After speaking to both DigitalRelic and Noren about the situation, I can definitely see both sides. I think Noren should have definitely been more more willing to communicate, but I also think the bulk of the blame belongs to DigitalRelic. That being said, due to the circumstances, I tend to think that Neutral is more appropriate in this situation. It appears that the majority of other posters believe so as well, as I believe the final tally was:
Change to Neutral: 10
Either One: 2
Stay Negative: 1
Even if we combine the latter two categories, it's still 3-to-1 for changing the feedback to Neutral, so that is what is going to happen. If anyone has any further comments on this situation, feel free to post them here or PM me directly.
battousai: Based on what both users posted regarding the situation, and also the feedback of other users commenting on the situation, the Neutral feedback left for
battousai will not be counted.
chronic_archaic: From speaking to other users, it would appear that you gave at least one other user the same excuse as
battousai. I still don't really think what you did was malicious, but could you maybe clear up exactly what happened during this transaction? With all parties. It's really hard to get everything lined up with what has been said so far.