The prospect of an independent Scotland is very exciting to me as a EU citizen. Here's hoping it happens and it wins this time. In Edinburgh I've heard countless people say they voted "no" and would change to "yes" this time because Brexit opened their eyes, so I think with a good campaign that ensures that Scotland would be part of the EU, that shouldn't too hard to win.
I don't think it's that simple. Brexit itself is showing to be a good cautionary tale of how independence would go. Replace the EU with rUK and UK with Scotland.
We've all seen how tribal the Tories will go, if they are in power for an independence vote, then they will grant no favours and it'll be a bad split. A solid case to remain can be made highlighting the above as well as emphasizing that Scotland does the majority of its trade with rUK.
The inherent problem is immigration. Scotland needs it, and it isn't getting enough from rUK moving into the country. So it is a choice of shorter term painful hits (rUK trade being fucked) vs long term gains (immigration control that suits the country's needs and changing the country's economy to work outwith the rUK).
Immigration is of course required by the rUK as well, but we still live with a party who like to put their head in the sand and pretend it's the cause of all bad things in the country, not the symptom of gutting the services to handle immigration well in local communities. No sir.
The hunger for a referendum isn't there currently either, hence why Sturgeon has given a pretty vague commitment to it with Brexit flavoured strings. The Tories got a massive return in the 2017 election from selling themselves as the party of the union and the polls haven't shifted to a consistent and strong yes result.
Salmond was all about making the referendum happen and working from there to raise the yes vote. Sturgeon is much more cautious generally, and is aware that a second No vote locks the debate out for a really fuckin' long time. I think it may be her downfall, the SNP base are still pretty hungry for indyref2.
My stance tends to fall with Sturgeon, it's not the right time to seek independence, and trying to do it now will only damage the chances of it ever happening.