It's not a ridiculous take. The person I was replying to literally said "I'd rather have the best" over people who are "crappy." There's a huge gap between people who are like Troy Baker, Laura Bailey, etc. and people who are garbage voice actors and it's dumb to act like it's them or someone who's not a good VA at all.That's a ridiculous take. Maybe they are cast in "everything" because they're considered the best. No casting director in the world is casting people because they think they'll do a worse job than someone else.
I don't personally have an issue with any of the voice actors OP mentioned, but I think it's just a silly opinion to have that just because they're in everything, they're "the best" and better than every other possible voice actor.