-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Manga |OT2| TenOT
- Thread starter LaunchpadMcQ
- Start date
- Anime/Manga OT
This is completely fair, I had a list of series that were officially simulpubbed awhile ago. I'll try and update it with a schedule of when stuff releases and see if I can work with LaunchpadMcQ to make sure it stays up to date in the OP.
Edit here is a copy paste of my old list, I'll work on updating it later this weekend and trying to get dates and regions for people
Last edited:
I'll just say that I'm still surprised by the general laxism regarding illegal scans considering the amount of artists saying they're definitely not happy people read them (even more when official releases are available/on their way) but whatever, too tired to argue about this.
Last edited:
that seems to do the job
now i just need to try and figure out where i watched up to with seven deadly sins and the black hair guy appearing just before the end
Red Hood 17
Destroy the world. Please do it. What do you have to lose.
Neru 16
Whaaaa, mom from outta nowhere, what even.
Destroy the world. Please do it. What do you have to lose.
Neru 16
Whaaaa, mom from outta nowhere, what even.
Sakamoto Days
This arc has been hype as hell. I almost thought that his wife was also badass, but it was a disguise. Still a great scene though.
Spy X Family
Seems the cruise arc is wrapping up now. The last two assassins unknowingly getting blown up was hilarious.
This arc has been hype as hell. I almost thought that his wife was also badass, but it was a disguise. Still a great scene though.
Spy X Family
Seems the cruise arc is wrapping up now. The last two assassins unknowingly getting blown up was hilarious.
Magu Chan 65
Big Brother Izuma, cute.
What nefarious plot is afoot if the holy knights are sending people to his location. Worrying.
Big Brother Izuma, cute.
What nefarious plot is afoot if the holy knights are sending people to his location. Worrying.
Can't imagine Red Hood lasting more then 1-2 more chapters at the rate it was going.
BLue Box
what would this manga be without HaryuTaiki. Best.
Elusive Samurai
Best page of the week?!
what would this manga be without HaryuTaiki. Best.
Elusive Samurai
Best page of the week?!
Last edited:
OP
OP
So I'm coming into the spoiler conversation a bit late now. I appreciate the input and help from the mod team with the recent incident.
There's been some talk around it, but regarding the spoiler rule in the OP - I had considered revising it before posting the OT earlier this year and decided against trying to overcomplicate the rules surrounding spoilers, but I definitely agree it could be better. Rereading it now, I specifically think it was intended around written spoilers rather than image spoilers, and that's definitely something that I hadn't considered at the time, either. It is much easier to scroll through a page and accidentally absorb a piece of information from an image than it is from text, even if they are labeled correctly with the work and chapter numbers.
The two points of discussion I see are whether a licensed work has not been officially published in English can be discussed without tags (simulpub fits that, but keeping in mind other works that maybe readers are waiting for an official release on), and whether we need to specify spoiler tags need only apply to images. Keeping in mind actual thread traffic, I'll use Kaguya as an example - most of the thread is reading chapters that have not been officially published in English and sometimes posting images. While I understand that its not a series that is heavily rooted in event discussion, sometimes things are not tagged even though some readers may be waiting for the Viz releases. It is, in fact, something I personally have to avoid when I check in on the thread and a new chapter is out.
Keeping that kind of thing in mind, I feel like the rule should take these two factors into consideration and be something like - "You are welcome to post words and images on works that have been officially published in English freely (i.e. through Shonen Jump app, Viz, Kodansha, etc.). However, if posting words and images on a chapter or work that has not been officially released in English as of the post date, please use spoiler tags in your post. Please check Baka-Updates and official publisher if you have questions on whether or how much of a work has been published in English."
Those are my rough thoughts on the matter and I'd like to get some input before doing anything further. I don't really want to put something in that's half-baked and the rest of the thread isn't on board with, so please let me know if I'm totally off-base here.
There's been some talk around it, but regarding the spoiler rule in the OP - I had considered revising it before posting the OT earlier this year and decided against trying to overcomplicate the rules surrounding spoilers, but I definitely agree it could be better. Rereading it now, I specifically think it was intended around written spoilers rather than image spoilers, and that's definitely something that I hadn't considered at the time, either. It is much easier to scroll through a page and accidentally absorb a piece of information from an image than it is from text, even if they are labeled correctly with the work and chapter numbers.
The two points of discussion I see are whether a licensed work has not been officially published in English can be discussed without tags (simulpub fits that, but keeping in mind other works that maybe readers are waiting for an official release on), and whether we need to specify spoiler tags need only apply to images. Keeping in mind actual thread traffic, I'll use Kaguya as an example - most of the thread is reading chapters that have not been officially published in English and sometimes posting images. While I understand that its not a series that is heavily rooted in event discussion, sometimes things are not tagged even though some readers may be waiting for the Viz releases. It is, in fact, something I personally have to avoid when I check in on the thread and a new chapter is out.
Keeping that kind of thing in mind, I feel like the rule should take these two factors into consideration and be something like - "You are welcome to post words and images on works that have been officially published in English freely (i.e. through Shonen Jump app, Viz, Kodansha, etc.). However, if posting words and images on a chapter or work that has not been officially released in English as of the post date, please use spoiler tags in your post. Please check Baka-Updates and official publisher if you have questions on whether or how much of a work has been published in English."
Those are my rough thoughts on the matter and I'd like to get some input before doing anything further. I don't really want to put something in that's half-baked and the rest of the thread isn't on board with, so please let me know if I'm totally off-base here.
P^6 8
I love each and every chapter, theres just something really compelling about it.
Also loved Clara's line about being for discovery, guess Lucky got this.
I love each and every chapter, theres just something really compelling about it.
Also loved Clara's line about being for discovery, guess Lucky got this.
Drifting Classroom vol 1 (Dropped)
Picked this up at the library this week, and while there are some aspects of this I really like, i'm not going to go back and get the remaining volumes. The whole supernatural psychic/time travel communication aspect of the plot is really dumb, and I don't particularly feel compelled to see how this ends
Picked this up at the library this week, and while there are some aspects of this I really like, i'm not going to go back and get the remaining volumes. The whole supernatural psychic/time travel communication aspect of the plot is really dumb, and I don't particularly feel compelled to see how this ends
Look, nobody wants to make it too complicated. There's a lot of stuff that comes out when the volumes hit that people want to talk about weekly and they should be given a space to do so.
If someone wants to wait on the volume to have discussion then that's on them to do so. I don't want people getting driven out to accommodate maybe 2 people's preferences. Especially when release dates across the world can vary so wildly. Keep in mind, we are an international forum, it's not just US readers here.
If you want to wait for the volumes, I made a thread for that a long time ago. Go talk in there. Making things too complicated will just drive people off and in all honesty it's way too hard to moderate given we're an international forum.
So my suggestion would be to just go with what I outlined the other day for now. That's what we're going to enforce and what we'll be holding everyone to.
Edit: I also want to note there's people from Japan on the forum and this would basically be telling them they can't talk about stuff once it's out legally.
All of you need to understand that this is an international forum, with people who live all over the world and it has to have rules that reflect this.
Last edited:
The last page of the chapter is so freaking cool!
So hyped for what comes next.
in the context of one piece, no one from jpn was talking about one piece before it was even on sell in jpn, I dont understand your point for bringing jpn people up for this.
also unsure why you want to be the sole decider for something that clearly affects multiple people. multiple people should be able to share their voice and view on this and come to an agreement, not put it in the hand of a single person to decide for us all
It's not about talking about One Piece before it's on sale in Japan, it's about talking about any number of manga that're published in Japan long before they get official releases elsewhere. People read translations of those series and wanna discuss them. Such is life!
Spoiler tags for stuff that simulpubs is a fair middle point, and it's where the rule's gonna stay. If you only want to discuss official releases, that's what the other thread is for; insisting that people only talk about stuff that lacks official releases is a confusing headache given the forum's international audience. It's easy enough to say "well, it's just a tag," but IME as a staff member, people have a tendency to flip right out when they think spoiler rules are being violated, regardless of whether or not that's true, so it's in everybody's best interest to try and keep things generous.
LaunchpadMcQ , you mind adding that to the OP?
?
no one ever had any issue with people talking about series published in jpn with no int'l releases. Those posts even generated discussion and interest and are still available in the thread. They even had images embedded. I feel the admins and mods are missing the point of why this (for simulpubs like OP) was even brought up in the first place and escalating this much greater than it needs to be. (fears of people piling on other people, what?)
I didn't say no international releases, lol.
And, like, yeah, that's one of the concerns. Any new rule we implement has to consider a) can we stick to this universally? and b) what're the knock-on effects of this rule going to be? Like, for example, in a thread last year I basically told people to knock it off with the doomposting, and to this day people are still yelling at and reporting each other for doomposting. Spoiler tags for leaked simulpub chapters is a reasonable middle point, but given how long it can take between release and localization even for works that *have* confirmed official volume releases, and how much discussion is made of stuff like e.g. Kaguya, we're gonna stick with drawing the line there.
OP
OP
Just so we're on the same page here, B-Dubs and Poodlestrike, what's the other thread you're referencing?
Manga Spoiler-Free |OT| The Digital Future OT
Talking about a non-Viz release - Apothecary Diaries has an official release now, so go check that out if you like mystery/medical/romcom/historical stories
www.resetera.com
Part of what happened the last time this question came up was the making of this thread. Idea was to basically introduce the kind of distinction people use for leaks for popular games: one (or many) threads to talk about officially released material, and a thread for spoilers, which is the one we're in now. Well, at the time it was OT1, but you get the idea.
Back then, the ask was more "don't have discussion of translations for series that're getting official releases, period." Which is not really the case here, but it's reminiscent, thus the initial confusion.
Try being a fan of BL manga that usually gets released in French, Spanish, and German, and then you have to cross your fingers that a year or two after that, someone will pick it up for an English language release….
OP
OP
I think there were good intentions for that Spoiler-Free thread, but the reality is it hasn't been used in months and a large portion of the use that it was getting then is just the normal discussion that happens here when simulpub chapters are released. I understand not wanting to scare people off, this thread isn't super active as it is, but I feel having a whole different thread and telling people to go post there instead creates the same problem.Manga Spoiler-Free |OT| The Digital Future OT
Talking about a non-Viz release - Apothecary Diaries has an official release now, so go check that out if you like mystery/medical/romcom/historical stories
Part of what happened the last time this question came up was the making of this thread. Idea was to basically introduce the kind of distinction people use for leaks for popular games: one (or many) threads to talk about officially released material, and a thread for spoilers, which is the one we're in now. Well, at the time it was OT1, but you get the idea.
Back then, the ask was more "don't have discussion of translations for series that're getting official releases, period." Which is not really the case here, but it's reminiscent, thus the initial confusion.
What I'm realizing, however, is that there's not going to be a perfect solution to this problem. I would love to have that right now, but I feel like there are 20 different ways of cutting this up, and it's going to make some folks happy and others not so much. To B-Dubs' earlier point of this being an international forum, that idea would actually better suggest we need to pull back on regulating the spoilers in the first place. I feel even pushing to have tags on simulpub series might be encroaching on that, but I think given the stature of those series and the way they are discussed here, it's a fair measure if the users in the thread can live with it.
Also, I do want to say, I meant no offense to anyone with the earlier suggestion of tagging anything that has not had an official english releases. That was only suggested on the basis of this being a primarily english speaking forum. I read manga in other languages that have not been published in english, so I would have had to tag my thoughts on those based on what I suggested earlier, as well.
Yeah. Nobody's ever really 100% happy with rules, or rule changes. Just trying to find an acceptable middle ground, is all.
IMO, posts about more popular series that have dedicated threads should go in those threads. For example, the Kaguya OT only has 4 pages (and hasn't been posted in since April). It seems there are more posts about the series here than in the OT, for some strange reason.
It's kind of just a gravitational problem. If there's enough people reading the series to sustain a thread, they'll do it on their own, and in so doing, become a community unto itself. If there's not, they'll drift back to whatever the central place for discussion is. Trying to over-regulate these things rarely goes well, so we mostly only do it when it's a genuine problem for discussion.
In my mind, if the chapters haven't even hit store shelves/online services even in Japan, those (stolen) leaks should be spoiler-tagged. That's where I'm at. Back when I first walked in here, people were posting full pages of Chainsawman on Fridays... Stuff like that.
It's not strange, how many of us even knew/remembered there was an OT for it lol
Whats there to be spoiled in manga anyways? Luffy punch good? Naruto is bad dad? Da boi is still in da Abyss?
I am dying about it became such a fascinating train wreck, I just read the latest chapter, this series is officially Time Paradox Ghostwriter tier for me now
omg futekiya getting something i really wanted to read, nice. (guess i missed this way back on august 1, or maybe I did mention it and forgot, oh well)
We are pleased to announce the license acquisition of the following titles* from Libre Inc.:
We are pleased to announce the license acquisition of the following titles* from Libre Inc.:
- Dakaretai Otoko No.1 ni Odosareteimasu. Volumes 1-7 by Hashigo Sakurabi
- Toshi****a Kareshi no Renai Kanriheki Volumes 1-2 by Hashigo Sakurabi
- Secret Flight by Ren Tamaki
- Secret Flight -Business Class- by Ren Tamaki
- Executive Flight by Ren Tamaki
- Romantic Flight by Ren Tamaki
- sweep! by Momoko Tenzen
- doggerel by Momoko Tenzen
- Konna Koto ni Naru nante
by Tomomi Sakana
- Itsumo 3nin Issho dene? by Tomomi Sakana
- Sekuhara Brothers by Tomomi Sakana
- Sekuhara Brothers Aisaresugi hen by Tomomi Sakana
- Yarisugi Brothers by Tomomi Sakana
- Sexy Cool Voice by Kou Fujisaki
- King and Prince by Kou Fujisaki
- King and Prince plus Kaiser by Kou Fujisaki
- Ii Kankei de Komatteru by Hatoko Machiya
- SWEET -Kare no Amai Amai Aji- by Haruka Minami
- BITTER -Kare no Hisoyaka na Kuchizuke- by Haruka Minami
- LOVE
AROMA
BODY by Haruka Minami
- SEXY
AROMA
NIGHT by Haruka Minami
I'd applaud the author for the absolute balls they must have if they take this to the logical conclusion and make it so the villain wins because the series was cancelled lol
I suppose the conversation has drifted, but it literally started because of someone talking about this week's One Piece chapter before it even came out in Japan.
Honestly I kinda like that these new manga have been getting canned quickly. That means the 6/10 manga that I like(Magu and Robocco) won't be axed that soon. Please Jump keep giving us more fodder
Now I want fanart of Fuuko hugging every protagonist of those axed series while doing her best "just as planned" face
Absolutely, those first 6-7ish chapters are rough, really rough, but once you get past that it just flips a switch and becomes phenomenal.