I think it's actually worth something.
That doesn't answer my question, with swapping tokens and no board updates you have to have an established way to determine who you could have scanned and who you could not scan. These gamerunners are better than that.
Comrade Xbro, the "last thing Geno said toward Kyan", is it referring Geno's comment about #311? Because if it is, I have a problem with that...
...because in this case, your comment about how your Geno vote was independent from the opinions of other workers seems odd. You got a coherent communist read of comrade Kyan via #311. When comrade Geno did not respond to #311 in the same manner, you seem to have used that as a major reason for voting for him. In other words, your mentioned reason for voting comrade Geno was that your reads of me differed, not that he felt like a capitalist to you.
So in your reads, what's the difference between the two coasting reads? Other than the fact that one is only a lean? Is it just that my vote is easier to hang?Scum:
Xbro: Coasting. Not even at 10 posts hours before the deadline
Nin: Already explained
Kalor: Gut feeling
Fandorin: Not been too active. Drops in periodically to seem active. Hasn't contributed much at all.
Lean Scum:
empressdonna: Coasting. Weak votes and weak reasoning
geno: Gut feeling again. His activity during this day phase just makes him feel scummy.
Apollo: Not been too active but active enough I can't say full on scum
Zipped: I don't even remember any posts from him. He's been that forgetful that I'm just leaning scum with him.
Neutral:
Kyan: Posting style throws me off but I'm enjoying it enough that I'm willing to put him on neutral. Nothing scummy out of him but nothing too towny I think.
dcpat: No read still on him. Might do a reread if I'm still around after today
Lean Town:
Ketkat: Feels towny enough but my gut tells me not to put them in full Town
Town:
Brazil: Every post has felt towny to me
Sweetnicole: Not as active as others but when she is active, she usually makes good informative posts and is good at pressuring people including myself. Feels very town to me.
Grizzly: Again, every post has felt towny to me. Good at scum hunting and good at challenging people.
There we go.
- Xbro; Is also somebody I have no problem lynching. His day 1 started out with the mechanics talks. I don't see that as a big problem. He was also on the people suspecting Kyan for the way he was posting. Which is a thing I disliked. His unvote was easy, but understandable from a scum and town pov. Don't like his unvote at day end to avoid a tie. If I was in that position with the same concern I would change my vote from Geno to Fish, not unvote. One switch from Fish to Geno would've made it a tie with 6-4. Also he contributed to a fish lynch this way without committing to it. Coasting today.
I couldn't afford not to make this, due to easter and time zones I won't be here the final hour, thus I won't see if he survives or not and the chances of him surviving are high. I'm sorry guys but I had to.
That doesn't answer my question, with swapping tokens and no board updates you have to have an established way to determine who you could have scanned and who you could not scan. These gamerunners are better than that.
I have a range and I target players and not tokens.Do you have a range limit or target tokens? I'd understand if you didn't want to answer but as long as you don't reveal your own token, I think it's okay to confirm this.
So in your reads, what's the difference between the two coasting reads? Other than the fact that one is only a lean? Is it just that my vote is easier to hang?
I don't believe Stuart's claim at all, even without Geno coming in.
I don't believe it either on the simple basis of what are the odds (1/17, I know).I don't believe Stuart's claim at all, even without Geno coming in.
This does put that Kalor/Donna votes to interesting light now. Were one or both of them set up in advance, so that Xbro train would be viable option if everyone believed Stuart's claim?
I went easy on empressdonna. I watched her during sneakers and her play style is similar. I assume it's very very unlikely that she would get scum 2 games in a row so I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt but I won't discount the possibility of her being scum so I put her under lean.
What would be the point of an assignment cop where you can't see who it is you're targeting?Since I still seem to be on the chopping block. I'll claim the role I am
I am an alignment cop. I am able to check a token who is either 12 spaces behind me or 12 spaces in front of me. It returns to me the alignment of the token.
On Night 1, I checked Rocking Horse. It revealed to me that they were town. I had no idea it was RF until the day started and he was dead.
I will also reveal my token upon request though you can understand why I would rather not as it would make me an easy target.
Believe what you will. Once dead, my role will be laid bare for all to see.
What would be the point of an assignment cop where you can't see who it is you're targeting?
Didn't geno say he targets players?So, both of them are claiming a range and that they target tokens. I was hoping for a difference to try to figure this out.
So, both of them are claiming a range and that they target tokens. I was hoping for a difference to try to figure this out.
Your defeatist attitude does not exactly make you seem more town.
Geno's post made me uncerrtain regarding this. I couldn't tell if he was correcting himself, or saying wtf at Stuart's claim.
I don't think that makes me seem town or scum. When half or more suspect you or have voted for you and you can see that nothing will change their mind. Having a defeatist attitude is natural for some people.
Others hide their defeatist attitude by not posting.
I am not one of those people. I shall post until the end!
But you targetted a token, right? not a space.Nope, I had no way of knowing if my scan would be a success. I had to use the map from the start of D1. Pick a token and scan it that was within my range.
I mean, if you were town, surely you would have called out the person who was counter claiming you. Now you just ignored all that in all of your posts.
I couldn't afford not to make this, due to easter and time zones I won't be here the final hour, thus I won't see if he survives or not and the chances of him surviving are high. I'm sorry guys but I had to.
No need to do that. He wasn't giving much info at all. Not even who he scanned.
by any stretch of the imagination, if he was town, he should have said who he scanned. He didn't. Thus people should be skeptical of him regardless of what happens to me.
That's not really how we're seeing it. Geno had no reason to come forward with that because people were already doubting your claim, and if you end up lynched and innocent it just puts him in the spotlight. Its a massive risk for him, while your claim was to save yourself
He had one strong reason to come forward. If I got lynched and he tried to claim cop later on. He would look far more suspicious than he wants to be.
Comrade Stuart. Why would comrade Geno counterclaim you if he is a capitalist and you are what you claim to be?
He had one strong reason to come forward. If I got lynched and he tried to claim cop later on. He would look far more suspicious than he wants to be.
No, cop has a very good reason not to claim.For the reason posted above. He wants to make sure his cop claim is put down earlier otherwise people would be asking "Why didn't you claim cop or use your cop power to help town earlier in the game, especially when Stuart claimed cop?"
or something like that.