Great thread. Love good, interesting takes.
BUT --
Disagree and I've played pretty much every basketball series made since ~1992.
I wouldn't have even though to put NBA Hangtime in my top 10 of basketball games. Might not make my top 20 or top 30. The game was fine, but it was an also-ran at the time, without a lot of improvements from NBA Jam and NBA Jam TE. Importantly, too, is that these console ports of NBA Jam/Hangtime cost usually $70-$80. It was a lot of money to spent on an iterative game that really didn't add much from NBA Jam TE and the basic formula was the same. There was also a lot of confusion at the time between what the right NBA Jam game was, with NBA Jam Extreme launching a few months before. The game also came out in, what 96 or 97 on home consoles, and a lot had changed since 1993 and 1994. In 93/94, you didn't have a lot of decent sim basketball games... but by 96/97 you had a ton of solid 5 on 5 home console games, NBA Live 95/96/97 (genesis, SNES, PC) , NBA Shootout 97 on PSX, Coach K 95, etc. We were entering the golden age of 5 on 5 basketball games from about 1997 to 2003, it's a crowded field and NBA Hangtime doesn't do enough to stand out then.
It's always hard saying one game is "the best" of anything. With a gun to my head if I *had* to come up with a list...
- NBA Street Vol 2 (Playstation 2)
- NBA 2K11 (PS2/Xbox)
- NBA Live 96 (Genesis)
- NBA Jam TE (SNES or Arcade)
- College Hoops 2K8 (Xbox 360/PS3)
- NBA 2K2 (PS2/Xbox)
- NCAA Basketball (March Madness) 2010 (Xbox 360/PS3)
- Jordan v. Bird One on One (NES)
- Lakers v. Celtics and the NBA Playoffs (Genesis)
- Double Dribble (NES)
Honorable mentions:
- NBA Shootout 98
- NBA In the Zone 2
- NBA Run and Gun 2
- NBA Live 2000 or NBA Live 2003
I also think NBA Street and NBA Jam deserve to be on a top 10 list but picked their "best" in the series. I picked 2K2 over 2K1 and 2K because I think going multiplat makes that one better than 2K1 or 2K, while still generally having all of the best features of NBA 2K.