if we are talking strictly about the PC version, im inclined to agree. The PS1 version was totally different (like most other NFS games, but in other cases the different versions were equally good) and imo much worse.
The PC version though.... some of the best tracks ever put in a racing game, amazing scenery, fantastic blend of sim and arcade, 2 amazing career modes, the music, dashboard view, great damage model.... just all around a fantastic game.
Racing on the alps map is particularly fond memory of mine, the first time I drove on it - the way the track goes from dry & sunny to snowy & dark with everything covered in thick snow and ice really blew my mind at the time. And yeah, in 2000 it was one of the best looking games available.
The only downside of the game is that its limited to Porsches only. That being said, the game pays such a fantastic homage to them through the 2 career modes that I ended up really appreciating it.