• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

srtrestre

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,987
Since no one has been threadmarking Cerium's follow up posts, I took the liberty of consolidating all his answers up to this point in one place for you all:
 

Nepenthe

When the music hits, you feel no pain.
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
21,072
Come on. We're at page 79.
Don't quote me only to not to answer my question.

Also, a general note to the thread: knock it off with the negative insinuations about staff relationships. It's obvious most of the members know little about Cerium, so there's no need to try and armchair diagnose any potential of abuse.
 

PJV3

Member
Oct 25, 2017
25,676
London
I don't mind the owner wanting out, selling up and making even 10 million out of it, i still think there should have been some discussion about where the forum would end up, given how it started. Probably better for a buyer to see a happier(well slightly happier given it's us lot) community than what this looks like now.
 

jtb

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,065
A person can be a nice person and have made a series of shameless, scummy decisions. I don't see these as two contradictory ideas.

So Cerium's a nice person. So what?
 

rochellepaws

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,473
Ireland
Which specific concerns do you want him to answer?
Two questions mainly.

1)There's a general perception that that site was owned by several stakeholders, what was the timeline of ownership and how did he became the solo owner. Who were the other stakeholders, what offers were made to them and for what reason?

2) Why did he choose to sell it to corporations as opposed to seeking a successor within the community? His initial introduction message to us was "Everything we do begins and ends with the community.", how does selling to an investor group achieve this?
 

Nepenthe

When the music hits, you feel no pain.
Administrator
Oct 25, 2017
21,072
Two questions mainly.

1)There's a general perception that that site was owned by several stakeholders, what was the timeline of ownership and how did he became the solo owner. Who were the other stakeholders, what offers were made to them and for what reason?

2) Why did he choose to sell it to corporations as opposed to seeking a successor within the community? His initial introduction message to us was "Everything we do begins and ends with the community.", how does selling to an investor group achieve this?
I will agree wholeheartedly that these two are fair questions for him to address. Staff cannot guarantee when or if he'll come in though, and that's not me putting up for him. It's saying we ain't got control of the man's will.
 

Ferrio

Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,126
It evolved from what it started out but no one planned this from scratch.

Money was always planned, maybe it wasn't planned to sell it (cause who buys forums in 2021) but $ was always a big factor. And it should have been, cause why deal with a headache of this place if it doesn't have a chance to recoup costs. Also you don't buy out partners unless you think you're going to score big at the end.
 

construct

Saw the truth behind the copied door
Member
Jun 5, 2020
8,087
東京
LOL, dude has 4.5m, he doesn't need anyone to protect him, especially from some nerds asking questions on a forum.

Honestly, just coming into the thread telling us to fuck off and give the middle finger would be better than nothing IMO. Least that'd put an end to it.
on the same hand, I would never talk to any of you again if I got paid 4.5m
 
Oct 25, 2017
3,122
LOL, dude has 4.5m, he doesn't need anyone to protect him, especially from some nerds asking questions on a forum.

Honestly, just coming into the thread telling us to fuck off and give the middle finger would be better than nothing IMO. Least that'd put an end to it.
If I were him the only thing I'd do is contact former/current mods and break em off a thousand each for their troubles. Why in the world would I come in this thread if people see me as the ultimate evil?
 

Cats

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,929
on the same hand, I would never talk to any of you again if I got paid 4.5m
I'd totally sell out this site for 4.5m. Absolutely. But I'd also give some to charity to at least try to help perpetuate the ideals of the community. I don't nearly need that much money to set myself, my family, and my friends all up for life so it can help others out. I'd definitely give all the mods and former mods a nice gift for their hard volunteer work.
 

Mr. RPG

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,054
LOL, dude has 4.5m, he doesn't need anyone to protect him, especially from some nerds asking questions on a forum.

Honestly, just coming into the thread telling us to fuck off and give the middle finger would be better than nothing IMO. Least that'd put an end to it.

I get that and I appreciate staffs patience but I really hope get answers.

We're never going to hear from him again.

I think lie is being too harsh.

It evolved from what it started out but no one planned this from scratch.

Not at all. Many people thought this would happen from the very beginning of the site's founding.
 

construct

Saw the truth behind the copied door
Member
Jun 5, 2020
8,087
東京
I'd totally sell out this site for 4.5m. Absolutely. But I'd also give some to charity to at least try to help perpetuate the ideals of the community. I don't nearly need that much money to set myself, my family, and my friends all up for life so it can help others out. I'd definitely give all the mods and former mods a nice gift for their hard volunteer work.
same, but I also wouldn't reply to a single person because binch im rich
 

srtrestre

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,987
BREAKING: first footage of Cerium absconding with the dough and abandoning staff and community to contend with the fallout:


tenor.gif
 

Buttchin-n-Bones

Actually knows the TOS
Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,651
That anyone could think this place is "under-moderated" is preposterous. It's something I've wanted to express but consequently (due to the OVER moderation) have been afraid to do. Perhaps more moderators are needed to lighten the load but throwing bans around every time a dissenting opinion is presented ain't it.
Dunno what to tell you. Casual bigotry is very much a situation of "the axe forgets but the tree remembers." Any time a minority poster sees someone be lightly punished (from their perspective) for saying something hurtful to them, they're likely to think that the mods aren't doing enough. Conversely, anybody who's literally just asking questions (from their perspective) may or may not be engaging in bad faith, but if their post gets actioned, they're going to think the mods are going too far.
 

Deleted member 3010

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,974
LOL, dude has 4.5m, he doesn't need anyone to protect him, especially from some nerds asking questions on a forum.

Honestly, just coming into the thread telling us to fuck off and give the middle finger would be better than nothing IMO. Least that'd put an end to it.

LOL you got me in stitches, and I would actually take that lmao.

"Suck my diiiiiiiick!!! I'm rich bitches! Suck my diiii---

*Ferrari roaring away*"
 

SirDante

Alt-Account
Banned
Sep 20, 2020
972
Two questions mainly.

1)There's a general perception that that site was owned by several stakeholders, what was the timeline of ownership and how did he became the solo owner. Who were the other stakeholders, what offers were made to them and for what reason?

2) Why did he choose to sell it to corporations as opposed to seeking a successor within the community? His initial introduction message to us was "Everything we do begins and ends with the community.", how does selling to an investor group achieve this?
I always believed Zhuge and Shinobi and the all the admins that were here at the start owned a stake. I always believed every decision that affected the board was done in good faith.

I had no idea a single person owned the site, in fact, once I saw a post mention "the owner is Cerium", I thought it was the name of a company that is paid to maintain the site "on behalf of the community" by the original founders.

I had no idea it was a user name of a single person.
I also had no idea the site made any money outside of "keeping the lights on"

I'd hate to think I was ignorant of the truth, I just thought everything regarding ownership was done in good faith. Now, I just don't know anymore.

I'm so afraid that if numbers fall in the site, because people stop coming here because of new ownership, and realising it's not community run, the new owners will shut the whole place down.

Like Cerium said.. it's an investment to them. The importance of the site in our daily and gaming lives is irrelevant to them.

I feel we are all just numbers to Cerium. Numbers to the new owners. This whole thing makes me very sad.
 

Aminga

Member
Oct 27, 2017
913
I can't believe a thread like this has devolved to users taking pops at each other and the mods, while mods ban people for making pretty harmless jokes. A dude just made $4.5 million off of your collective asses, and you're still going after each other! Jaysus.

Normally when an OP bails out of a backfire thread this place has the decorum to direct it's ire in the appropriate direction: At the dipshit OP.



Hey OP, just checking if you were planning on coming back and answering any of the other questions that have come up since?


People are very curious about why MOBA Network were the "best fit", given the state of their other message boards and their ties to online casinos? The fact that "Any post regarding sexuality, gender identity, ethnicity or women's rights to bodily autonomy is regardless of context considered a "forbidden topic" on an equal level with posting graphic violence gore images and is encouraged to be reported immediately for moderation." is stated policy for them wasn't a problem for you?

There are also questions around why a sale was the "best way to secure the future of the site", since it seems like no investment was needed or will be made given the massive profitability of the existing model. Couldn't the ownership have been transferred in a way that took the burden off of you without placing the forum in the hands of a for-profit business? Were alternative arrangements even considered?

Then we come to GDPR compliance, and whether the handling of user's data has met the standards required when a sale like this occurs? I mean I'm sure all the due diligence required was done, right?

Of course there's also the question of what sort of person you have to be to take this kind of massive payday while leaving the engineers who helped you to make it in the lurch, without even hooking them up with contracts to work for the new owners? I mean what kind of shit is that, really?


Maybe you could also add some additional details to your first post, like the press release from MOBA Network, or any of the news articles that have covered this. Just little things like the price tag, and the ongoing profits, and the plans to make more money from more ads in the future, just those little bits.
 

Bandage

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,626
The Internet
I always believed Zhuge and Shinobi and the all the admins that were here at the start owned a stake. I always believed every decision that affected the board was done in good faith.

I had no idea a single person owned the site, in fact, once I saw a post mention "the owner is Cerium", I thought it was the name of a company that is paid to maintain the site "on behalf of the community" by the original founders.

I had no idea it was a user name of a single person.
I also had no idea the site made any money outside of "keeping the lights on"

I'd hate to think I was ignorant of the truth, I just thought everything regarding ownership was done in good faith. Now, I just don't know anymore.

I'm so afraid that if numbers fall in the site, because people stop coming here because of new ownership, and realising it's not community run, the new owners will shut the whole place down.

Like Cerium said.. it's an investment to them. The importance of the site in our daily and gaming lives is irrelevant to them.

I feel we are all just numbers to Cerium. Numbers to the new owners. This whole thing makes me very sad.
The site shutting down would be the best thing to happen, honestly.
 

B-Dubs

That's some catch, that catch-22
General Manager
Oct 25, 2017
33,043
About Era Clear, it was offered early on when the site was new and ad revenue was just getting off the ground. The only time it was given any real push was after the 2.0 redesign, which cost a lot and I recall the hope was that subscriptions could help offset that, so the plug was added at the bottom of the site. After that it kind of became an afterthought and went untouched until now.

Honestly I don't think anyone remembered the wording on the subscription page and that was definitely a mistake and should have been changed. It's been adjusted.
 

amc

Member
Nov 2, 2017
241
United Kingdom
This place was supposedly born from the ashes of a pretty large scandal. Born with the promise of being of the community for the community. But it turns out that was a lie. It was born of a want of ownership by an individual/individuals.

Maybe that very ownership fact was obfuscated because if truth be known people wouldn't have so easily been lead or been as trusting in congregating and enabling of such financial endeavour. Maybe, just maybe, if the truth was known from the start this place would never have gained the mass to enable such a financially rewarding deal for an individual/individuals. Maybe if that fact had been placed on the table from the off somewhere else could have grown that fit the spec of said 'product'. Hmm people or product, which one would this community have chosen. I wonder?

As someone who only lurks and posts sporadically but who has been here several years, I (and many others according to posts in this thread) understandably, and in hindsight rather naively, thought this place was ran as a non profit and for the posters benefit. It was certainly hinted to be ran that way. The spirit that this place so strives to have seems to have been built on shady hush speak in back spaces and what the prols don't need to know won't hurt them.

Would this place have gathered the momentum and lets call it what it is, product's critical mass/numbers, if it was clear, clear etc, was actually benefiting individuals instead of what seemingly the whole ethos of its creation was imagined to be.

"For the community by the community"

Pretty heart-breaking that one of the sites major ideals was just smoke.
 

Deleted member 3010

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,974
Oh, like the massive one on the 1st page with 3k responses? Trust me, we're all laughing. Everyone is, really.

Have a blessed day!
Every freaking place that's discussing what's happening here is fucking folded on the ground laughing hard and rightfully so. The move pretty much betrays every single values this forum standed on, behind the back of EVERYONE. :lol

The grift was felt all around the internet.
 

Sirpopopop

_ _ _ w _ _ _
Member
Oct 23, 2017
794
That bold section seems to be communicating that moderation will be applied equally to all members regardless of paying for Era Clear; it is not a free pass to be an ass or a get out of jail free card. "Giving back" has a strong implication of providing this option as a means to support the site.

If giving back was the clear message to take, then it would have been highlighted. The reason why the line about the only thing you were getting were going to be "no ads" was highlighted is because that was the takeaway you should have taken.
 

echoshifting

very salt heavy
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
14,960
The Negative Zone
Two questions mainly.

1)There's a general perception that that site was owned by several stakeholders, what was the timeline of ownership and how did he became the solo owner. Who were the other stakeholders, what offers were made to them and for what reason?

2) Why did he choose to sell it to corporations as opposed to seeking a successor within the community? His initial introduction message to us was "Everything we do begins and ends with the community.", how does selling to an investor group achieve this?

These are good questions.

I would also like to know what makes MOBA Network such a good fit. Reading the terms of use for some of their other boards is gutting.
 

Aminga

Member
Oct 27, 2017
913
Shit...and to think i made Era logo for free because it was a community effort to get everybody together under one organized place again.
Seeing those numbers is not a good look for sure, i can't imagine volunteering for years.

In my humble opinion grabbing the bag alone is not a classy move.
Your logo is amazing and you heart was in the right place, just the old adage "no good deed goes unpunished" is once again proven right. Sick of good charitable people being taken advantage of. I want to know how the hell did cerium become the sole owner and we all ended up not with a community run forum WHICH THIS WAS WHEN WE JOINED to just him, hands off collecting 700k a year.
 

Sabin

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,685
Gotta respect Cerium for making 700k per year with the board and selling it later for 4.5m while letting the board run by pretty much by only volunters asides from the the techstaff.

True capitalist exploiting the work force for pretty much nothing.

Edit: Oh and selling it to mobafire that hosts some of the most toxic gamergate videogame forums in the internet is also :chefkiss:

Perfect fit my ass.
 

echoshifting

very salt heavy
The Fallen
Oct 25, 2017
14,960
The Negative Zone
They were willing to pay him 4.5 million dollar, the perfect fit

I'm having a lot of trouble swallowing that even though it seems obvious. I mean some of the mods and admins I respect the most are still in his corner here, right now, surely there has to be...something, right? :/

Because some of those policies literally outlaw what has always made this community safe and special for a lot of people here.
 

Sirpopopop

_ _ _ w _ _ _
Member
Oct 23, 2017
794
I always believed Zhuge and Shinobi and the all the admins that were here at the start owned a stake. I always believed every decision that affected the board was done in good faith.

I don't remember if Zhuge owned a stake. Someone should ask him on twitter, he'd probably respond. Other admins in general all owning a stake is 100% untrue. We had the opportunity to own a stake, but a lot of us decided against it.
 

Ferrio

Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,126
These are good questions.

I would also like to know what makes MOBA Network such a good fit. Reading the terms of use for some of their other boards is gutting.

Even overlooking that it's hilarious. Good portion of the forum hates the companies that make MOBA games. Even if they didn't, MOBA/multiplayer games might as well for how little they're talked about here.
 

Deleted member 3010

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,974
I'm having a lot of trouble swallowing that even though it seems obvious. I mean some of the mods and admins I respect the most are still in his corner here, surely there has to be...something, right? :/
Everyone has a price. The problem here is that there shouldn't have been a single owner. This place should've been owned by a community as a non-profit org, not an LLC. This oversight will probably be how this place will lose whatever cachet it had because the facade all fell off.
 

F34R

Member
Oct 27, 2017
12,024
I just checked, 1st time in four freaking years and there is a thread of them eating popcorn screenshoting everything and loving every minute of this with all their alt right fake bravado. I don't care about the old cesspool, I care<d> about this forum. This whole thread is crazy with defenders for Moba and cerium < MOST OF US DIDNT REALIZE HE WAS THE SOLE OWNER, when we joined it was a community run board no profit no agenda etc.> and trying to obfuscate the fact that at the middle of a night one of the best forums, most of us, our favorite forum has been sold to a company that is SURPRISE again alt right transphobic, Hate filled etc.
Yeah, I found it now. My posts are up there in screen caps as well. :(
 

Bandage

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,626
The Internet
I'm having a lot of trouble swallowing that even though it seems obvious. I mean some of the mods and admins I respect the most are still in his corner here, right now, surely there has to be...something, right? :/

Because some of those policies literally outlaw what has always made this community safe and special for a lot of people here.
This board hasn't been safe for a lot of communities for years and the new corporate masters will only make those problems worse.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.