Unintentionally torturing thousands of people, so much so that they wish for death, still makes you a terrible person, yes.
All our actions every day have knock on effects that contribute to the suffering of others and animals including what products we buy, including technology where the miners for the elements used for the microchips are children, and the people assembling them have committed suicide. Yet we still buy an iPhone, PS5, Xbox and a Switch. We are terrible people, all of us for contributing to that.
Yes Wanda is more in direct control, and she shouldn't go unpunished.
However one her defence whenever Wanda gets told what she's doing is wrong Agnes distracts her from stopping the Hex. However when Agnes isn't the issue and the townspeople tell her what's happening she immediately attempts to help them escape the Hex.
IMO she's still a good person, not that there shouldn't be consequences for her.
Unfortunately this time there's gonna be consequences for all Mutants and super powered beings in that a strong vocal minority won't trust them after this incident.