Too many options to make a poll for. Do you prefer Medieval era? Are you a sucker for stuff in the future? Is outer space your fancy? Are you a bore and like games that take place in our current time/place?
This.
This is probably my least favourite setting in any medium.
It's the worst in every form of media. Except for Army of Darkness.
Yeah, this. I like fantasy settings well enough, but they are really overdone in most forms of media, especially video games.
Yup, the same for me. It doesn't hurt that the games usually aren't very long either (sub 25 hours).I like reasonably confined settings, like buildings, ships, complexes or space stations. Especially if they have an interior and exterior.
Talos 1 from Prey is so tangible, so well realised that it feels like an actual place in many ways. Discovering what happened in some place that's gone horribly wrong is such a compelling set-up for me.
Rapture from Bioshock is another shout, though perhaps more linear.
RPD from Remake2 is another.
Yeah. medieval/high fantasy/medieval fantasy are the worst, most oversaturated genres to me. My favorites are hard sci-fi, post apocalyptic, historical fantasy, (think of like, God of War) and westerns (which we only really get out of Red Dead unfortunately). I also love pirates but pirates really isn't a setting as much as a thing in a setting.