I was the one that resurrected it tho. I also don't think it's useless to see who people put in the Inv slot.
Greed Island Mafia |OT|: *Insert joke here*
- Thread starter Fran
- Start date
I do apologise ^^; I really should have done it as two separate posts or in spoilers because yeah my post was rather long oops.
Oh what Fran confirmed Dubs can post his identity? I probably missed you mentioning that before. This sounds like it seals the case.
Glad you're happy to be back, Gorlak. Salva was pretty townread with some oh-no-deepwolf reads so we may all turn on you eventually. We're building that goodwill now, haha.
It depends on which phase you look, she was doing her hardest to actually scumhunt when she tried to defend her absurdly clownish claim. But nobody wanted to listen to me... and scum were too afraid to go after monkey in that game :(
Ah and for the win: you're welcome Dr. Monkey
Was he, though? I remember quite a few people accusing him of flip-flopping. Interestingly I think he was neither on a lot of Top-Scum-lists nor on a lot of Top-Town-lists. But then, we ave several confirmed or semi-confirmed Town at this point, so it's kinda hard to make it onto a Top-Town-List...
I'll surely go all crazy conspiracy theory before long as well :D
And erh... I'm a bit embarressed to ask, but what is a deepwolf? Just somebody townread who turns out to be scum?
Yeah, someone most people assume is pure town who is definitely not.
Donna shot Blarg first. Of course Blarg shoots back. It's Blarg. That's pretty NAI in all regards (doesn't even rule out w/w).
Sorry no, I meant Fran confirmed B-Dubs could post today, in the game thread. That means there is no power preventing him from posting which makes the possibility that someone faked B-Dubs lesser in my mind as inevitably we would have revealed what occurred and B-Dubs would have just said "nuh uh" and claimed whatever his actual role would be in this theoretical scenario.
It's okay buddy, you tried your hardest. There's only so much a single Big Ass Ladder can do.
Stay tuned for Metal Gear Solid Mafia Redux coming soon* to a mafia thread near you.
*Soon being contingent on if I can get enough players to run it or if I need to chop my beautiful creation down to a more manageable size :(
Fine, I get the hint :P
P: Verelios
I: Gorlak
K: Blargonaut
Contrary to Natiko's read I have to say that I currently lean Scum on Blarg. I thought for some time during D2 that he was on track to be useful (Blarg-style), but that pretty much evaporated today.
What's the current size? asking for a google sheet full of roles sitting in my google drive...
I'd probably put B-Dubs as more likely Scum than Kyan and Muffin tbh. Not sure about Zipped.
B-Dubs playstyle reminds me of me when I don't have much time to play (at least pre D3 B-Dubs did). Give some quick reads based on gut feelings, since deep reading players takes too much time. Him not showing up is definitely not a good look though, but I already said I'd be fine with removing him if he doesn't show up.
So you're going to ignore that question as well?
That's fair. It was a pretty cinematic post too, very on brand. The thing with Blarg for me is nothing he has done seems remotely out of the realm of possibility for him to do as town. If my reads are wrong somewhere, he's at the top of the list of people I would consider as the piece I was wrong on. He's like the true definition of a null. He's chaos incarnate as a player.
28 beautiful, beautiful roles of fun. 28 is a tall order for games not called HvV at this stage.
Then we loop back to the question of B-Dubs and Blarg as scum, who could the partners be? Muffin and Zipped you can make the argument for. I don't see how any other combo works without me being WILDLY wrong on someone town read or scum just really decided they wanted to kill one of their own. I probably need to take a look at the D1 votes again as well just to see where that matches up with everything that I'm not thinking.
I just answered this earlier :P But I had already progressed to town reading him D2 by the EOD. The lack of a vote isn't great, and that automatically puts him in the pile of potential scum. That his reads today are similar to mine though leads me to believe he's approaching the game with a similar mindset as I. He's not someone I feel much urgency to press today, but would need to evaluate based on the flips we see and where that leads me.
empressdonna It is nice to see you doing work. Might we see you diversifying your reads even more today?
Yeah, I wanted to see if I could mindmeld you. brb concentrating
I'll do my best, I do believe in some of my reads quite strongly admittedly but I'm not against rereading people in order to see if that changes now.
Why did you town read him at that point, especially if his vote record placed him in the possible scum pool. To be exact, I am talking about your past self here, today, whatever, yesterday, what.
You're talking about different things. Yesterday I initially was leaning scum on Zipped for the way his vote shifted at day end D1. I had some discussion with Saw on it, and when I went back and ISOed Zipped:
It led to me re-evaluating and considering what reason scum would have to draw attention to themselves like that when all the wagons were non-mafia. His lack of a vote D2 came after this, and puts him in the pool to consider as of today. But as I said before, his mindset aligns with mine in a way that builds town equity. Monkey made a great point about the ITA phase shots as well.
Too bad, I'm already there
I'm still of the mind that it would have to be A and Donna together if so. If we're wrong on B-Dubs tomorrow will be a day of reckoning lol
After Geno died, was I supposed to keep my mouth shut? Especially on a day where I could get shot anytime? Also, thats what Geno said. Monkey or Nat can confirm that for you since they had access to our chat logs last night.
That's grade-A bullshit. I took the blame openly and want to get it over with since then. Do I need to keep repeating it? Lynch or shoot me, it's completely on me this time.
I dont really care at this point.
I don't like this. Not funny. But even if scum has been sitting on an extra kill we should be okay regardless.
Everyone has agreed, no one seems upset about a turbo anymore, yet no one is voting... so let's wagon up then, see what happens.
vote: Muffin
vote: Muffin
Fine, let's play a game. Except I'll go with the one who apparently can't discern a hard-confirmed Town from a "strong Town lean":
vote: Zippedpinhead
Ok. My desire is to get you cooperating with us all, to get you to play the game. You are now fully ignoring my point and just clenching on to your own false viewpoint. I care still, but shall back off since I don't there is much progress to be had here today.
Did I miss something, how are you hard conformed town? I Think you have been playing a very town forward game, but I must have clearly missed something.
Kyanrute, since my desire to investigate you yesterday your posts have swayed me to believe that you are more town than not.
I don't want to swap my vote, b-dubs is clearly scum.
However, if we are looking at alternate wagons I want to vote
vote: Malus
However, i would also vote for muffin as all three of B-dubs, malus and muffin are in my scum view
However, if we are looking at alternate wagons I want to vote
vote: Malus
However, i would also vote for muffin as all three of B-dubs, malus and muffin are in my scum view
Lmao false viewpoint. It's completely accurate, and your "youre not taking the blame" was simply 100% wrong.
You want me to play the game? I goddamn said who I want to lynch today. It's 99% clear that Dubs is scum, what do I need to add to it so youre content? There is nothing else today from me. Spare me the fake concern that I could help the game by making up some reads that dont help. If I have actual mattering reads to share, I do it. It reads like you want to do your best to appear v e r y concerned for the sake of town.
At least someone here who is acting instead of only talking crap.
uhhhh go look at Sneeks' flip? apparently you missed something, yeah.
Sigh, deflection. The argument was about there being more than just your role and you just deflect that with your needless angst.
Take a chill pill. Go afk if you can't handle the game. See you tomorrow, something. My honest opinion is that you are no longer fun to talk to. And I don't want to ruin yet another game by being a bickering bastard.
Because I sure as hell like being one.
Completely missed that line about Sawneeks knowing a random player is town aligned.
My bad Royal_Flush, for what it's worth, you have played a very town focused game.
You're not allowed to steal my patented 'rage self-vote as scum' move.
I can handle the game very well, thank you very much, Mr. Concern.
So you want me to address the other points instead of my role you made for a scumread of me? It's easily summed up: Admitting fault and asking to be lynched in favor of getting someone out who's going to be nuisance for town later due to the inherent alignment doubt in his role is not how I play either scum or neutral. Neither is low activity. My activity is entirely tied to how much time and interest I have and how much useful reads I have to give.
We havent played many games together Kyan, so that doesnt matter to you, obviously. It shouldnt. So put your money where your mouth is and vote.
I disagree mightily. Mid-game, with this many confirmed town and assumed town? These wagons say we got scum somewhere, my dude.
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start
B-Dubs (3 votes)
Natiko - #2,609
empressdonna - #2,648
Kyanrute - #2,993
Muffin (2 votes)
Dr. Monkey - #2,980
Muffin - #2,988
malus (1 votes)
Zippedpinhead - #2,984
Blargonaut (1 votes)
malus - #2,997
Zippedpinhead (1 votes)
Royal_Flush - #2,981
Natiko (0 votes)
Not voting: Blargonaut, Aeleus, Gorlak, Verelios, B-Dubs
Post Counts:
Dr. Monkey: 100 Blargonaut: 37 Natiko: 34 Royal_Flush: 30 Verelios: 29 Kyanrute: 27 empressdonna: 27 Zippedpinhead: 26 malus: 22 Muffin: 21 Aeleus: 13 SalvaPot: 11 Gorlak: 11
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!