So rereading Hedin and there's not too much here. His day 1 stuff is pretty light, and he dislikes day 1 apparently which is fair. He has 1 post that's a read list of every player and it's kind of a bunch of nothing that I'm not a huge fan of.
This I can do.
jman - There was an occasional role we had when I played (I tried looking through the mafia wiki on the name and nothing jumped out at me) where your win objective was to get someone else lunched. Jman against Sorian that first day felt like newbie trying to accomplish that. That might be too harsh of a reading but that's what it felt like.
Then he has this which I'm not a huge fan of. This would be fine on day 1, but this isn't actually a read. Like it doesn't really conclude with anything. Do you still think he's a neutral? Has anything changed for you now?
He's got a couple of posts about Fanto, nin, Hagi, and Sparks that do look like he's more engaged, but there's not much follow through.
Leaning scum here, but it's not a confident scum read. Wish I had a bit more to go on.