A chance for what, he had plenty of time to post?
Sweet, love backhand compliments
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Nier: Gestalt Mafia IOTI: Weiss you dumbass! Start making sense and play mafia!!!
- Thread starter lokiduck
- Start date
So rereading Hedin and there's not too much here. His day 1 stuff is pretty light, and he dislikes day 1 apparently which is fair. He has 1 post that's a read list of every player and it's kind of a bunch of nothing that I'm not a huge fan of.
Then he has this which I'm not a huge fan of. This would be fine on day 1, but this isn't actually a read. Like it doesn't really conclude with anything. Do you still think he's a neutral? Has anything changed for you now?
He's got a couple of posts about Fanto, nin, Hagi, and Sparks that do look like he's more engaged, but there's not much follow through.
Leaning scum here, but it's not a confident scum read. Wish I had a bit more to go on.
Then he has this which I'm not a huge fan of. This would be fine on day 1, but this isn't actually a read. Like it doesn't really conclude with anything. Do you still think he's a neutral? Has anything changed for you now?
He's got a couple of posts about Fanto, nin, Hagi, and Sparks that do look like he's more engaged, but there's not much follow through.
Leaning scum here, but it's not a confident scum read. Wish I had a bit more to go on.
Okay, wow Hagi is rough on reread. Seems like you're typical nervous townie, but then it keeps going and there's just nothing there.
There's a vote he placed on Turmoil where he said he wasn't a fan of killing me or Fanto, but I have no idea why he wasn't a fan of it. Like there's very little in way of reads at all
There's a vote he placed on Turmoil where he said he wasn't a fan of killing me or Fanto, but I have no idea why he wasn't a fan of it. Like there's very little in way of reads at all
Jman is giving me weird vibes. The sudden shift to "Wait we should kill Sparks" was some whiplash that felt like scum realized opposing the Sparks kill wasn't doing it for them. He feels the most genuine of the three on reread, but I don't think he feels much better.
Leaning scum on all of them I guess lol. If I had to pick a newbie to kill today it would be Hagi
Leaning scum on all of them I guess lol. If I had to pick a newbie to kill today it would be Hagi
OP
OP
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start
SalvaPot (1 votes)
Fanto - #1,347
Hagi (1 votes)
TheChuggernaut - #1,355
Lone_Prodigy (0 votes)
Fanto - #1,336 #1,347
Not voting: Reki, Kalor, Vincent Alexander, Lone_Prodigy, jman1954goat, nin, MrHedin, Aeleus, Hagi, SalvaPot, Stantastic, Razmos, Stove
Post Counts:
TheChuggernaut: 5 Fanto: 3 Lone_Prodigy: 3 Vincent Alexander: 2 SalvaPot: 2 Razmos: 2 Hagi: 1 MrHedin: 1 jman1954goat: 1 Stantastic: 1 Reki: 1
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
SalvaPot (1 votes)
Fanto - #1,347
Hagi (1 votes)
TheChuggernaut - #1,355
Lone_Prodigy (0 votes)
Not voting: Reki, Kalor, Vincent Alexander, Lone_Prodigy, jman1954goat, nin, MrHedin, Aeleus, Hagi, SalvaPot, Stantastic, Razmos, Stove
Post Counts:
TheChuggernaut: 5 Fanto: 3 Lone_Prodigy: 3 Vincent Alexander: 2 SalvaPot: 2 Razmos: 2 Hagi: 1 MrHedin: 1 jman1954goat: 1 Stantastic: 1 Reki: 1
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Your wish is my command:
TOWN
Fanto
Reki
Razmos
Stantastic
jman1954goat
TheChuggernaut
Aeleus
Stove
Hagi
Kalor
SalvaPot
Vincent Alexander
Lone_Prodigy
nin
SCUM
In fact I feel strong enough about that last one to:
Vote: nin
Yeah my activity could be better but D1 was one of the more forgettable ones I've been in and D2 was wrapped up in a turbo. That's not a lot to go on and sure it's hindsight because what if Sparks was lying scum that claimed neutral out of nowhere. But he was neutral and he's dead and were pretty much back at D2 but with one less town.
I was teetering on a Jman vote, but I have to put them on my lean town list. What finally made me lean town:
Not only because it was right, but because why the hell would scum push to keep hunting scum---town cred? Perhaps throw out a quick throwaway line, then let it fade because you know Sparks is a good train to keep scum safe on? Except Jman gets into an argument about this very post and drags it out for 5+ posts. However, what kills me is that when Jman does fold on the subject, it's simply because Sparks got the hours wrong:
Which feels like flimsy reasoning to turn on Sparks. But the iffyness of this vote on Sparks doesn't outweigh the towniness of pushing for more scum hunting outside of Sparks.
I'm going to sheep this opinion and say I lean town on Salva. I can't argue with any of the reasoning here from Chuggs. I think it's a solid enough post that I might as well quote it and bump it.
I wanted scum dead more than a neutral and I wanted to give sparks a chance to cooperate for a couple of days and stay alive while we search for juicier prey. sparks stoped responding and went silent then I read that he was already told the correct end of day. the fact that sparks was possibly lying about details and in general acting sketchy ment it was way to risky to leave him alive. sparks gave us no choice but to kill him immediately. plus he ruined a full day of scum hunting really wish he had his outburst later in the day.
I don't feel 100% on much of these reads, though some I'm more comfortable with than others.
Vote: Hagi
Town:
-Reki
-Salva
-Chuggs
-Jman
-Aeleus
-Razmos
-Kalor
Neutral to Suspicious Of (In no particular order):
-Fanto
-Stove
-Stantastic
-Hagi
-Lone_Prodigy
-nin
Vote: Hagi
Town:
-Reki
-Salva
-Chuggs
-Jman
-Aeleus
-Razmos
-Kalor
Neutral to Suspicious Of (In no particular order):
-Fanto
-Stove
-Stantastic
-Hagi
-Lone_Prodigy
-nin
Welcome, Stove. First time Mafia player, or simply first time here on Reset?
my first vote neat!
couple of questions Stove I see new next to your name have you ever played mafia somewhere else what's your history
second anyone else you read scum? is there anyone you think is town?
Thanks friends. I've played Mafia before but never in this format and never on Reset. It's hard to keep track of everything and everyone when you cant see their faces. :P
Still formulating my thoughts so some of these are less confident compared to others.
I am sus about:
You. jman ;)
Fanto
Hagi
At the moment I think townies are:
Vincent_Alexander
Salvapot
Maybe Chuggs.
How could it be forgettable with 2 claims, ample debate and a close ending? Are you really paying attention?
It's not like anyone else was voting, why not vote for both of the people I want to call out the most? :P
I'm definitely interested in hearing about the Scum read on Nin, I feel like he hasn't been talked about much and like I'm giving him too much of a pass here.
You too, give me your thoughts on Nin, what made you put him in this list?
Hi, Stove! What do you find suspicious about me so far?
Yeah, I'm not giving anyone town points for wanting to "Scum hunt" on a day where Sparks was obviously going to get killed.
I'm not really sure were the nin scum reads are coming from
I'm not really sure were the nin scum reads are coming from
What does it matter if Sparks was going to get lunched? And if you don't give town points for wanting to scum hunt, how about scum points for folks not wanting to hunt?
I'll pull out some quotes tomorrow once I am back on my computer.
Hi, Fanto! Purely hunches at the moment. I'm going to pull the newbie card someone else in this chat overused way too much earlier. On that note, my thinking Vincent and Salva are also just hunches.
I'm sticking with my vote on jman however because he seems a bit all over the place.
i see nins the new easy target for today, well i think ill counter that by continuing with an easy target of my own!
vote: Vincent Alexander
but really any explaination at all for the nin votes would be nice.
why leaning town of Slava and VA?
vote: Vincent Alexander
but really any explaination at all for the nin votes would be nice.
first of all welcome to the game, love the avatar.
why leaning town of Slava and VA?
I'm curious why you switched from Hagi to Nin here? What was it about Hagi that made you want to vote there at first over the others on your Suspect list, and then what made you want to suddenly switch it to Nin instead?
My vote on Hagi was because they were on my scum list and already had a vote. I want some real pressure on people this day. I could've gone either/or with Hagi or Nin. My initial reason for being suspicious of Nin I'll quote tomorrow. My reason for switching tonight though...gonna keep that one to myself for now.
I guess I'd just like to know what's informing those hunches then haha. I just like seeing how people formulate their opinions, even it's just a hunch or not based on much, helps everyone to see the thought process still I think.
I do agree Jman has been a bit all over, but part of that is what's making me lean Town on him instead actually, just based on the assumption that Mafia wouldn't want to draw too much unnecessary attention to themselves I guess.
"That I've been in." Context.
Claims were boring (and one was unnecessary), debate was over trivial things, and the ending was close only because someone decided to tie it late just to see what would happen.
You can keep baiting but like I said, I don't lunch for bad town play. Go bother someone else.
there shouldn't be any players with the exact same role, but in role madness you can tend to get a bit of overlap in role functionality, there only so many role types out there.
lets try to think through a mystery what kinda role do you think killed the second player night 1
Night 1 Sorian unlocked a 1-shot vigilante kill and used it to murder stu.
boom im a regular Dick Tracy.
boom im a regular Dick Tracy.
Oh and since no one picked up my message on Day 2 i am going to spell it out.
I have been given lovingly a rainbow bass.
Not sure what that meant and it does not seem that i can use it in someway.
I can admire it though, thats what i have been said to
I have been given lovingly a rainbow bass.
Not sure what that meant and it does not seem that i can use it in someway.
I can admire it though, thats what i have been said to
You can't be a Vigilante so i will go with Bus driver ?
Town lost an entire day of
I'm writing my roleclaim now it will take me a bit but your welcome to keep guessing
I base my assumptions on facts my man.
I cant wait for the juicy Roleclaim though
Town lost an entire day of killing mafia thanks to sparks neutral reveal but don't worry your King aims to correct this. I believe it's vital to hit a scam today at all cost so why take one shot at it when you can take two?