Calls for an apology
University of Queensland lecturer and Indigenous broadcaster Chelsea Bond said she had at first hoped it was a doctored video designed to spur outrage.
"I had bought tickets to his show and was very excited about seeing him," Dr Bond said.
"Typically black people want to see that the world will treat us fairly so it's a real slap in the face and a reminder of our place in the world.
"He's talked about black women and the strength of his mother, but he just doesn't seem to see Aboriginal women as being part of this.
"That's a real kick in the guts."
She said his words were even more hurtful because the South African's sophisticated and clever comedy on race had made Indigenous women believe they were included and had a voice.
"It's that disappointment, he really let us down," she said.
Dr Bond said she was now going to run a segment on her radio show asking what to do with the tickets to the sold out performance in Brisbane — sell them or burn them?
But she said no matter what, there would be protests.
"He didn't say sorry — there was no apology, it was a defence," she said.
"Having the video removed was redemptive to him but not to Aboriginal women.
"He's not sorry — he just wants this to disappear before his show."
Former rugby league player Joe Williams, who first shared the clip on Twitter, said Noah needed to release an official statement apologising to Indigenous women across Australia.
"It doesn't affect me, but it does affect my fiancee, my sisters, my mum, my cousins," he said.
"This is about me supporting women and standing in solidarity with them.
"All women should be standing up."