• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

Pitchfork

Member
Oct 28, 2017
3,687
England
So my Xbox One X fan spins up quite fast and loud while playing graphically intensive games. It sounds like wind blowing through a cracked open window. In fact, I thought it was a sound effect in the game I was playing for a while.

Does anyone have an Xbox One X that does NOT do this?


Don't pay attention to the overall noise since the camera is quite close to the system. I can't hear the normal drone during gameplay. Listen for the "whoosh" of air at 1:18 and at 3:20.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqCozmM-Ako

Mine does this too during heavy loads? system is whisper quiet otherwise so I'm hoping its just venting, its not really noticeable over the game volume, but I do notice when i'm up late gaming and have the volume really low
 

Pitchfork

Member
Oct 28, 2017
3,687
England
Mine sounds like that too when playing Gears 4. There's also a very slight rattle.

I did send a PM to one of the verified Xbox engineering team over on reddit when they were taking questions the other day and he replied that's its normal under heavy load

We have logic in the console to determine when to spin the fan faster to provide the cooling needed.

Yes, it's normal
 
OP
OP
nihilence

nihilence

nøthing but silence
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
15,961
From 'quake area to big OH.
Mine does weird things during Gears of War. I can't tell if it's fans or coil at first. At first there is a variable sound. Eventually there is a constant whoosh that's more pleasant sounding.
 

Soony Xbone Uhh

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,156
So my Xbox One X fan spins up quite fast and loud while playing graphically intensive games. It sounds like wind blowing through a cracked open window. In fact, I thought it was a sound effect in the game I was playing for a while.

Does anyone have an Xbox One X that does NOT do this?


Don't pay attention to the overall noise since the camera is quite close to the system. I can't hear the normal drone during gameplay. Listen for the "whoosh" of air at 1:18 and at 3:20.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqCozmM-Ako

That is exactly what a cooling solution should do. Be whisper quiet during idle, but transport warm air out of the system under heavy load.

You want to hear the moving air and not the fan. You can make a fan noiseless, but you cant make moving air noisless when it has to move around obstacles
 

gabdeg

Member
Oct 26, 2017
5,973
🐝
My X is loud for the first minute or so, then the fan noise gets more consistent to the point where it's mostly inaudible under the game audio.
 

D BATCH

Member
Nov 15, 2017
148
You need to extract the metadata from the file that is there and insert it in a format that youtube recognises. As the content is already graded, you should be able to use the YouTube HDR tools.
If you can just inbox me how to extract the metadata from the file I think I know how using Davinci but not 100% sure.. Man gunna need a step by step on this one lol BTW where is youtube HDR tools a link please thanks.
 

IOnEI Falcon

Member
Oct 27, 2017
140
Tempe, AZ
It has been discussed about before in this thread but is the big discrepancy between people saying their system is whisper quite during demanding games and other people saying there is a noticeable fan noise just opinion on sound? What would cause some systems manufactured to be quieter than others? I am no hardware wiz.
 

AlexFlame116

Prophet of Truth - One Winged Slayer
Member
Nov 17, 2017
23,182
Utah
So far my Scorpio Edition has been great. I've been playing it almost every day and have seen no issues apart from just one random controller disconnect when playing Cuphead (seriously I was fighting the Dragon and out of nowhere it gives me the disconnection notification). I do hear sound coming from the system more often than before but I think that's okay.

The 1TB size sucks for me though. Especially since my previous Xbox console had a 2TB hard drive.
 

dicetrain

Member
Oct 25, 2017
813
I realized I made a really dumb mistake... or not so much? I think when I bought it, instead of putting my receipt in my jacket, I put it in the bag, which I then threw away.

But then again, since I got it launch day, my warranty period is a logically deduced and it shouldn't matter?
 

Maynerd

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,528
Redmond, WA
I realized I made a really dumb mistake... or not so much? I think when I bought it, instead of putting my receipt in my jacket, I put it in the bag, which I then threw away.

But then again, since I got it launch day, my warranty period is a logically deduced and it shouldn't matter?

In theory Microsoft COULD ask you to provide proof of purchase. That being said you should feel comfortable that Microsoft will give you at the very least 1 year of warranty (assuming you are in the USA) from launch day.
 

sangreal

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,890
I realized I made a really dumb mistake... or not so much? I think when I bought it, instead of putting my receipt in my jacket, I put it in the bag, which I then threw away.

But then again, since I got it launch day, my warranty period is a logically deduced and it shouldn't matter?

they track that shit automatically. if you're worried, just go register it:

https://support.xbox.com/en-US/my-account/warranty-and-service/register-your-product
 

EvilBoris

Prophet of Truth - HDTVtest
Verified
Oct 29, 2017
16,687
It has been discussed about before in this thread but is the big discrepancy between people saying their system is whisper quite during demanding games and other people saying there is a noticeable fan noise just opinion on sound? What would cause some systems manufactured to be quieter than others? I am no hardware wiz.

Each machine is tuned different, some may produce more heat so the fans kick in more?
 

Theorry

Member
Oct 27, 2017
61,060
This game on the X. Everytime i start it up i am blown away. And thats even on a 1080p screen.

ImmediateDrearyGrebe-max-14mb.gif
 

Hawk269

Member
Oct 26, 2017
6,051
So far my Scorpio Edition has been great. I've been playing it almost every day and have seen no issues apart from just one random controller disconnect when playing Cuphead (seriously I was fighting the Dragon and out of nowhere it gives me the disconnection notification). I do hear sound coming from the system more often than before but I think that's okay.

The 1TB size sucks for me though. Especially since my previous Xbox console had a 2TB hard drive.

Mine has been perfect, also a Scorpio and getting daily use. I actually hear my external HDD more than my Scorpio. But no issues with noise at all.
 

Hawk269

Member
Oct 26, 2017
6,051
This game on the X. Everytime i start it up i am blown away. And thats even on a 1080p screen.

ImmediateDrearyGrebe-max-14mb.gif

I really hope that patch lands sometime next week. I was informed that we are off on Friday, so with the Thanksgiving holiday I have a 4 day weekend and diving into this would be great. Come on CD team...give me a great thanksgiving treat!
 

dicetrain

Member
Oct 25, 2017
813
Yup, quite a bit of story and characters talking during missions, it also has some amazing story based cutscenes, worth playing through the game just for those.
I did end up getting it and it's wonderful. There is so much personality in all the little dudes and the sound is superb to match the visuals. I was a bit worried about 30fps when the whole screen is panning constantly, but everything is so clear that it's not bad. It's great to get something so high quality in the "diversification" selections of the Xbox library.

Each machine is tuned different, some may produce more heat so the fans kick in more?
People also have wildly different preferred room temperatures, and some store it in a little entertainment center slot while others leave it in open air, and some use an external hard drive so the one inside the Xbox would generate less heat.
 
Last edited:

Angel DvA

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,232
I'm confused about the sound option, which is better between Bitstream and Uncompressed 5.1 audio ? I have a good receiver so should I let the Xbox do is thing or send everything to the receiver ?
 

AlexFlame116

Prophet of Truth - One Winged Slayer
Member
Nov 17, 2017
23,182
Utah
Mine has been perfect, also a Scorpio and getting daily use. I actually hear my external HDD more than my Scorpio. But no issues with noise at all.
I'm pretty sure that the noise issue that I was mentioning is just a hard drive being a hard drive and reading data like it's supposed to. It was night time and there was no other noise so that might have explained why I could hear it this time rather than in the daytime when there is a lot more noise going on. It's a very soft noise.
 

dicetrain

Member
Oct 25, 2017
813
I'm confused about the sound option, which is better between Bitstream and Uncompressed 5.1 audio ? I have a good receiver so should I let the Xbox do is thing or send everything to the receiver ?
They are different ways of decoding audio digitally, so which is better would depend on the chipset in your receiver. Bitstream is kind of an old workaround of some issues that was also tied to some audio processing effects like room settings on 5.1 systems or virtual surround on 2.1 systems, but now technology is far advanced so uncompressed is a natural choice if your receiver is anywhere near new.

Realistically, unless you shelled out an obscene about of money for your speakers AND very deliberately placed them for ideal sound field casting, it's likely you wouldn't be able to hear a difference anyway because audio technology is so good/accessible/standardized these days that taking it next level is only really utilized when you do that in a room well designed for it. It's such a pain in the ass to do that most would probably be better off using headphones and a tactile transducer or a higher end 2.1 option for the same money they'd drop on a 5.1.

Even then, there is a massive range of audio quality between different games. Sound hasn't become as important as visuals to the gaming industry the way it has been for the film industry.
 

Angel DvA

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
1,232
They are different ways of decoding audio digitally, so which is better would depend on the chipset in your receiver. Bitstream is kind of an old workaround of some issues that was also tied to some audio processing effects like room settings on 5.1 systems or virtual surround on 2.1 systems, but now technology is far advanced so uncompressed is a natural choice if your receiver is anywhere near new.

Realistically, unless you shelled out an obscene about of money for your speakers AND very deliberately placed them for ideal sound field casting, it's likely you wouldn't be able to hear a difference anyway because audio technology is so good/accessible/standardized these days that taking it next level is only really utilized when you do that in a room well designed for it. It's such a pain in the ass to do that most would probably be better off using headphones and a tactile transducer or a higher end 2.1 option for the same money they'd drop on a 5.1.

Even then, there is a massive range of audio quality between different games. Sound hasn't become as important as visuals to the gaming industry the way it has been for the film industry.

I have a Marantz SR60-10 so it's pretty new, they're a new option for Bluray's to pass trough sound directly on the receiver which I guess is the best option for movies ?

So if I get things right, I should used uncompressed 5.1 for gaming but maybe go bitstream for DTSX on movies ?
 

Deleted member 4072

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
880
So my Xbox One X fan spins up quite fast and loud while playing graphically intensive games. It sounds like wind blowing through a cracked open window. In fact, I thought it was a sound effect in the game I was playing for a while.

Does anyone have an Xbox One X that does NOT do this?


Don't pay attention to the overall noise since the camera is quite close to the system. I can't hear the normal drone during gameplay. Listen for the "whoosh" of air at 1:18 and at 3:20.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqCozmM-Ako
Mine does that too, only for a few seconds every few hours. It's in an open cabinet. Seen loads of people on reddit say the same too. Seems pretty normal.
 

dicetrain

Member
Oct 25, 2017
813
So for anyone who knew my unit died day 1 and I sent in for repair. UPS has lost it. :|

This week has been amazing..
More like stole it. UPS is hot trash and their workers break and steal shit all the time. I've experienced it both personally and professionally as a retail manager in the past and now operations manager for a warehouse. Push that shit hard as high up into corporate as you have to (or if the retailer you bought it from will cover it, whatev) because they have a bad company culture among their workers and supervisors. FedEx is way better, and while occasionally incompetent, at least always professional. Of course, USPS, while having some limitations on what you can do with them compared to private carriers, does have many laws on it making "failures" you get with private parcel companies a felony that will be found out by the postmaster, so they almost never happen.
 

Outtrigger888

Member
Oct 27, 2017
2,308
Is the lighting in Titan fall 2 messed up. The colors on the guns just go completely black when not lit by a light source. Can't member if this happend in the PS4 version. I can see the characters hand underneath the stock of the gun just fine.
 

dicetrain

Member
Oct 25, 2017
813
Is the lighting in Titan fall 2 messed up. The colors on the guns just go completely black when not lit by a light source. Can't member if this happend in the PS4 version. I can see the characters hand underneath the stock of the gun just fine.
Haven't played TF2 yet but I wonder if there is an API glitch to iron out because in FFXV when we drive into a tunnel, the whole car turns black (I painted it white).
 
Oct 26, 2017
5,435
So does the Xbox vent itself differently when standing vertically to overcompensate the fact that the vents on one side is blocked while standing?

I'm curious how much safer / louder the heat gets or the fan runs when stood vertically vs horizontally
 

krealian

Member
Oct 25, 2017
167
So I'm confused about RotTR. I installed the 30 GB update but the game only showed a black screen when I started it. I then learned about game shrinking and found out that I could shrink the game. However, now it doesn't show up in the shrinkable list but the size is still 57.3 GB with DLC. I don't think it has been shrunk at all? Anyway, I still only get a black screen when I start it. I have to download the whole game again, don't I? :/
 

JFoul

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,784
I was going to wait until next year to buy buy an X, but it's $459 out the door at Cosctco right now with their $25 coupon, plus 1.5% cash back with my credit card.

Edit:
Ordered.
Ends up being $453 after cash back
 
Last edited:
Oct 27, 2017
567
Ok I've got a 4K TV (Samsung U6300) and an XB1. Should i trade in all my old games and my OG one for the X1? I don't play too much now with school ramping up but if i can get it for ~350 with my trade in, it won't break the bank. Help meeeee! Thx
 

henhowc

Member
Oct 26, 2017
33,621
Los Angeles, CA
I realized I made a really dumb mistake... or not so much? I think when I bought it, instead of putting my receipt in my jacket, I put it in the bag, which I then threw away.

But then again, since I got it launch day, my warranty period is a logically deduced and it shouldn't matter?

Where'd you buy it from? Some places you can usually just go back and they can print you out a copy of the receipt. Assuming you paid with a debit or credit card. Not sure how cash purchases work.
 

Hawk269

Member
Oct 26, 2017
6,051
So does the Xbox vent itself differently when standing vertically to overcompensate the fact that the vents on one side is blocked while standing?

I'm curious how much safer / louder the heat gets or the fan runs when stood vertically vs horizontally

Please tell me you are using the stand for it??? With the stand the vents would not be blocked. If you are not using a stand, you are going to have issues. There should be no difference in the position of the console for cooling as long as you are using the stand. The stand gives more than enough room for air to get in to cool the system.
 

augmental

Member
Oct 30, 2017
134
So I'm confused about RotTR. I installed the 30 GB update but the game only showed a black screen when I started it. I then learned about game shrinking and found out that I could shrink the game. However, now it doesn't show up in the shrinkable list but the size is still 57.3 GB with DLC. I don't think it has been shrunk at all? Anyway, I still only get a black screen when I start it. I have to download the whole game again, don't I? :/
Did you do a legit restart? I know it sounds too simple but I always do that...
 

Terror-Billy

Chicken Chaser
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
2,460
How do I sign up to the Xbox Newsletter, if there is one? The PlayStation one was quite useful when I had a PS4.
 

CSX

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,913
https://twitter.com/CSX142857
Just got the console and it refuses to let me have 5.1 audio output. Keeps giving me an error message. The only time it lets me pick 5.1 without an error message is if I go back to Video Settings -> Advanced Video Settings and change Auto Detect to HDMI. However, if I do that, I can't do 4K HDR anymore...
 

Ravenhawk

Member
Oct 27, 2017
320
So I'm confused about RotTR. I installed the 30 GB update but the game only showed a black screen when I started it. I then learned about game shrinking and found out that I could shrink the game. However, now it doesn't show up in the shrinkable list but the size is still 57.3 GB with DLC. I don't think it has been shrunk at all? Anyway, I still only get a black screen when I start it. I have to download the whole game again, don't I? :/
Did you get the latest dash update form Thursday (455mb)?
 

KeyboardThug

Member
Oct 27, 2017
286
Just got the console and it refuses to let me have 5.1 audio output. Keeps giving me an error message. The only time it lets me pick 5.1 without an error message is if I go back to Video Settings -> Advanced Video Settings and change Auto Detect to HDMI. However, if I do that, I can't do 4K HDR anymore...
Have you tired bitstream out under the HDMI audio?
 

Fastidioso

Banned
Nov 3, 2017
3,101
Are they any chance MS will improve the disc installation in the future upgrade? I'm quite tired to wait hours before to play with a new game. That's ridiculous in 2017.