Tada Never Falls in Love 2
Boy, that moved right into standard "after school club activity" without missing a beat! I think it might've been nice to get to know everyone during daily school life before the club stuff came into focus, but since part of me is here for the photography stuff, I'm not as bothered by how quick the show is moving to establish everyone and their inevitable pairings. I can't say that anything that happened here was necessarily bad, but it has a very weightless feeling to it. Nothing is particularly funny, nor are any of the moments outrageously cute or heartwarming, but it is pleasant to watch in a very calming sort of way, reminiscent of how I enjoyed something like Flying Witch. I don't think that was the intent of the creators, but that was what I took away from this more than the first episode. That said, I'm still undecided if I want to continue after I finish the third episode because I've yet to find a real hook to be invested in other than admiring how pretty the show often is.
Megalo Box 2
A solid follow-up to the first episode, and one that sets things in motion for the inevitable showdown waiting at the end. The fight looked quite good despite not showing too much specific animation by often keeping the camera in the POV of one of the fighters. It's a solid technique because it helps drive home the physicality of the boxing, but I am sad that it makes the fight feel like a series of inconsequential blows with each stage of the match defined by a single, strategic blow. I'm well aware that might be more satisfying, but it makes everyone feel like they're one step away from being Glass Joe when I feel boxing is as much a sport of stamina as it is of strategy and skill. While I liked the visual design of parts of this episode more than the first, I still don't feel the low resolution is doing the show any favors. I want to give it one more episode just to see where it's going, but I'm not convinced I'll keep seeing things through to the end here.
Wotaku ni Koi wa Muzukashii 1 - PASSED... SORT OF
Oh, come on! Not another show this season with a middling first episode! How many of those have I suffered through?! I had really high hopes for Wotaku, and all I can say so far is that it's... okay, purely on the quality of the source material, IMO. This looks like one of the cheapest shows I've seen from A-1 Pictures in a while, at least visually speaking. Considering the simplicity of the material and the fact there's such a small core cast, why does Wotaku look like it has the technical quality of a rushed Deen show at times? Did no one at A-1 have any faith in this show? While Noitamina doesn't necessarily hold the place of prestige it once did, I still get the impression it's a place where studios looking to make a name for themselves will pour their best effort into making material for it like Wit Studio did with After the Rain last season. Compared with A-1 Pictures' slice-of-life style comedies from the last year or so (Demi-chan, Saekano ♭, Blend S, even Eromanga-sensei), this looks phoned in from an animation quality perspective.
It's not just the look of the show that feels rough, either. A lot of the comedy is solid and feels incredibly easy to relate to given my own personal experiences in the work place, but I don't feel its conveyed as well as it could be. In comparison to Tada Never Falls in Love, where the humor is so well-strung together that it elevates average material into something that's moderately more enjoyable than it should be, Wotaku often seems to alternate between trying too hard to make a joke land or breezing by something that seems like it could've landed with more comedic weight. I didn't find myself laughing as much as I thought I would mainly because the jokes felt mistimed, which is odd for an A-1 comedy: they usually have that much distilled down to an art.
That said, the qualities that people who've read more than I have did shine through all these production issues and I am interested in seeing what kind of relationship hijinks await our two couples, but I had really hoped I wouldn't be sharing my reservations about the Wotaku's overall quality that so many other shows this season have suffered upon initial impressions. These are the kinds of shows I think A-1 Pictures excels at making, so to see this many issues with a show in a genre they technically and artistically represented well last year is a real shame, especially with source material that feels like it stands out from the rest of their library.