I finished Wednesday yesterday, I really liked it, I don't usually much care for YA stuff (nor do I hate / avoid it tbh) but this really clicked with me. Like I said previously, for me it was what I wanted Sabrina to be. It has the gothic and supernatural thing going for it, but Wednesday herself is a thousand percent better main character than Sabrina was (in no small part because Ortega just kills it in the role), but more importantly, I felt all the YA cast surrounding Wednesday was much better (and much less annoying) than the one in Sabrina.
Enid is RIDICULOUSLY cute (that's another role where the actress kills it), the love interests are much less annoying than the dudes in Sabrina, the adult characters for the most part were good (helps when you have Gwendolyn and Ricci I guess), it looks gorgeous (everytime they did side by side shots of Enid and Wednesday in their room with the color / black and white split I wanted to frame it as a poster), and the mystery was actually compelling, even if the payoff was a bit flat. The CGI monsters are a bit spotty but it doesn't detract from the show.
Oh and all the little splatterings of the other Addams Family characters helped. And Thing was great (as is in the show a ton).