Maybe I wasn't clear enough.
Willow and Kris are charismatic stars and incredible wrestlers.
Aminata's snap suplex last week is one of the best I've ever seen.
Skye Blue is great on the mic and has a brilliant finisher.
Billie Starkz is so fast and smooth in the ring and her character is great.
Abadon is brutal in the ring and they had one of the most revolutionary wrestling interviews with RJ City recently.
But none of these GOLDMINES are anywhere near the WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP belt. Instead, commentators are saying stuff like "Serena Deeb and Deonna Purazzo are technical masters". Where? I've just spent months and months watching their matches and never seen anything to suggest that. I'm falling asleep watching them.
I don't think I'm crazy here. I know it's all good times and fun but I just want the main event scene of championship women's matches to be legit great like the rest of the women in AEW.
Willow is currently locked in a program with the "biggest women's signing" in AEW history.
Kris got pulled from a TBS title run because of her lack of charisma/mic skills. She's amazing in-ring but is currently being rehabilitated by her alliance with Stokely.
Aminata is a key piece for the future, but needs reps.
Skye Blue has great charisma (as a heel), is a great worker and has a great finisher (when her opponent knows how to take it). She's a key building piece for the future as well but still has to get some polish before being World Champ material.
Billie Starkz is a prodigy. She's going to have that belt in the not-too-distant future. For now getting reps and learning from Athena in ROH is a solid plan.
Abadon is fine. I enjoyed their RJ City appearance but in-ring they are average for AEW standards.
Serena Deeb and Deonna are grappling/submission specialists and are excellent at what they do. While I would argue neither of them has really had a great opportunity recently to showcase their craft and both have struggles at times getting their character across (mostly Serena in this respect though), they both have enough experience/pedigree/craft to be contending for the World strap and put over the champ to retain. Maybe you just don't prefer their style of wrestling?
Meanwhile the true main event storyline has been a masterpiece. Toni has developed the Timeless character from a mental break after she last lost the title and brought it from a losing character to a champion. She's over massively and while her in-ring has been hit and miss based on her opponent, her last PPV match against Thunder Rosa was excellent. Mariah is the true best women's signing this year, has retained the stiffness of her time in joshi and is great on the mic and getting her character across in-ring. Mina Shirakawa's presence has been an added bonus-- they worked together incredibly closely in Stardom and Mariah credited Mina with a lot of her success. Not only that, but the "queer-baiting" that you alluded to is an extension of their character work in Stardom, which was predicated on stereotypes of sorority party-girl behavior. They didn't change anything to hit a different audience in AEW. It's obvious that they're setting up a Mariah vs Toni feud in the future, probably after Mariah costs Toni the title. Toni relishes facing off against stiff workers, and between their ability to get their point across on mic and slap the shit out of their opponents in-ring, it will be a top feud.
In short, I've been a huge critic of the treatment of the women's division in AEW for years, but they have never been showcased and as full of talent at all levels as they are right now. In 12 months the upper card will likely consist of Toni, Mariah, Thunder Rosa, Mercedes (sans ring rust), Willow, Athena (hopefully), Britt and Hayter. The present and future are bright!