Revive Tony? Hulk already survived bringing back 50% of the universe. Putting on the gauntlet and reviving Tony would be no deal for him, before they returned the stones at the end of the movie.
(Avengers Endgame Spoilers) Why didn't they just use the Infinity Stones to...
- Thread starter Deleted member 227
- Start date
Because every time someone's used them, they suffer enormous damage to themselves.
OP
OP
But Hulk survived the energy emission of a larger snap, it shouldn't be an issue for him.
Hulk is permanently damage, another use would have killed him, no one else was strong enough to use the stones
OP
OP
Did Thanos use the stones to bring Gamora back?
Movie specifically says the sacrifices for the Soul Stone are restricted from being brought back.
I don't think it's possible with the infinity gauntlet to revive a previous holder like that. Some kind of cosmic balance, like how you can't bring back Gamora or Black Widow that sacrificed in Vormir either.
Just use the timestone to reverse time on Tony's person, like with the apple in doctor strange.
Or have Captain Marvel do it.
Or have Captain Marvel do it.
I dunno if you noticed Hulk still wearing an arm brace and probably receiving immense scars from it.
"Your mother is gone. Like really gone. There are some people that are only in a certain way kind of gone"
Directors said the Hulk is permanently damaged and will effect future movies.
Better question is why didn't Dr. Strange grab the timestone and revive Tony that way. Thanos brought back Vision and a stone that way. People say it would undo the snap but thats not true since Scarlet destroyed the stone/vision and the reversal Thanos did had no effect on her.
Why didn't Captain Marvel just use the Gauntlet? Why wasn't she in the movie at all? Why does she exist? As a vehicle to bring Tony+Nebula's ship back from outer space??
Better question is why didn't Dr. Strange grab the timestone and revive Tony that way. Thanos brought back Vision and a stone that way. People say it would undo the snap but thats not true since Scarlet destroyed the stone/vision and the reversal Thanos did had no effect on her.
Why didn't Captain Marvel just use the Gauntlet? Why wasn't she in the movie at all? Why does she exist? As a vehicle to bring Tony+Nebula's ship back from outer space??
Hulk also tried to bring back Nat on top of that.
The Gauntlet has limits.
Captain Marvel: I'm so strong, I can beat up Thanos.
Audience: Here's this gauntlet, Thanos was nearly killed after using it twice so you should be fine after using it once.
Captain Marvel: Sorry, the rest of the universe needs help.
Audience: Here's this gauntlet, Thanos was nearly killed after using it twice so you should be fine after using it once.
Captain Marvel: Sorry, the rest of the universe needs help.
OP
OP
Listen, that one makes sense in-universe. We just finished watching a 3 hour 2 minute movie about the Avengers not taking a loss like this, going as far as to invent time travel to reverse the loss, you're gonna tell me they just casually accepted this?
I mean like in doctor strange, when he changed time just on the apple, like in the middle of the movie. Not a time loop.
She could.
End of the day, its a movie, they made a choice, Tony had to go to seal the deal.
OP
OP
See:
The Soul Stone sacrifices on Vormir are restricted. Tony just died because his human body couldn't handle the energy emission. Both Thanos and Hulk survived way larger snaps.
there's alot of things that could have pretended Thanos from winning in the first movie. But then they wouldn't have a sequel. Also they wanted to kill Tony off for dramatic purposes. It's just a movie.
The Russos said this in an interview:
https://bgr.com/2019/04/30/avengers-endgame-ending-russo-brothers-on-captain-america-iron-man/
The Widow exception is explained in the movie. It's trivial for the gauntlet to bring a single person back to life. But why would they when he was at peace with it?
He permanently fucked up his arm doing it. What, should he fuck up the rest of his body as well when Tony intentionally made the sacrifice??? How does this make any sense to you?
Tony could be snapped back but nobody can do it, or damage from using the gauntlet is just unfixable; Either works I don't care.
You can't reverse time or reverse Tony because that would involve making him undo the snap.
You can't reverse time or reverse Tony because that would involve making him undo the snap.
They are gonna do that in ten years when they have to hype out how they are bringing back Robert Downey Jr. into the franchise.
Yeah, reading this interview it seems that's what's implied. To undo the damage to Tony they would have to undo his action, which means Thanos and everyone is back.
Otherwise it would make using all the infinity stones non-trivial if you could just have the person do whatever they wanted, then just reverse that damage to them with the time stone.
Are you seriously equating the death of half the people in the universe to Tony Stark's?
Thanos was able to rewind time to bring Vision back.
I'm sure they could have revived Tony if they wanted to. But then they wouldn't have bothered having the stones kill him in the first place.
I'm sure they could have revived Tony if they wanted to. But then they wouldn't have bothered having the stones kill him in the first place.
OP
OP
No, but in Infinity War Captain wasn't going to allow Vision's self-sacrifice to prevent half of the universe from perishing, how is this any different? They had a convenient method of bringing him back right in front of them.
There is a rumor RDJ was offered lead role amounts of money for small cameos like he had in Spiderman and he still said no.
They answer this in an interview, saving Tony would mean undoing his snap, which means Thanos and his army is back alive. The implication is that you have to undo the action that did the damage in the first place.
If they use the time stone on tony then his snap would also be reversed and everyone in Thanos army would be back.
yeah but then you would have your brand new franchise-leading character get permanently damaged like Hulk.. that won't do well. They still need to make a billion dollar Captain Marvel 2.
OP
OP
We all know they are going to use the Infinity Stones to revive Tony in 10 years when Spider-Man fails to defeat Buu anyway, and he'll have to do the fusion dance with Cap.
