Neither, since neither seems to be exactly what I want anymore, so I just tend to play whatever. AAA games used to not only look the best, they also used to be extremely innovative. Way back when, the now "pixel art" craze used to be what AAA games looked like, and then not long after the games in the early to mid 90s that were being released on PC. Now it's either high production values with way played out gameplay, or "we want to be an SNES game" with maybe some actual innovations.
Sometimes there are releases from certain developers though that aren't quite AAA, but aren't indies either that end up being some of my favorites from any particular year.