Well, I disagree:
-OT: great gameplay and OST, good visuals and some dark themes in the main story that make it stand out compared to most JRPGs. But the game is repetitive, the main structure is flawed. It's a good JRPG IMO.
-P5: the best game from your list. Fun to play, stylish and unique (unique in the genre, it's not even a good improvement over older Persona games), but yeah the pacing is a mess and it's too long. I enjoyed it a lot even considering the flaws.
-DQ XI: unremarkable and boring JRPG. It's beautiful, it's polished, but it does nothing interesting, both the plot, the gameplay and the game structure are boring and feel like "another generic JRPG". Some story arcs and cinematics are really nice, but the general pacing is terrible, especially when you start to re-visit the same areas again and again. The OST is really bad, making the presentation uneven.
-Resonance of Fate: I played 10 or so hours from this game when it released on the Ps3, it felt interesting but not that good. I remember that the game was visually boring and that the story never caught my interest.
-Radiant Historia PC: I liked the game for 20 hours or so, but the constant re-use of enemy sprites and areas killed my interest to see the ending. The combat system is really good, but it feels really slow, the constant switching between party members means that you are constantly underleveled, the time travel mechanics are nice but the game offers lots of sidequests that make you visit some specific place and moment and it can be really tiring... I think the first hours from the game are really strong (good music, good combat system, good dub, strong plot)... but as the game develops the plot and systems it gets tiring.
I think all the JRPGs on your list are good in some aspects, being P5 the best and DQ XI the worst, but the "good" games you recommend are heavily flawed too.